Blue North is in a league of its own in a humdrum strip mall in McCandless.

When I pulled into the shopping center, which houses a nail spa, a hair salon, Dollar Tree, Rite Aid and a driver’s license center, I thought I had Google Mapped the wrong address. I didn’t notice the restaurant tucked away in the far corner of the humongous parking lot.

Blue North

1701 Duncan Ave.

Advertise with us

McCandless

412-369-9050

Bluenorth1701.com

  • Hours: 4-10 p.m. Monday through Saturday.
  • Prices: Appetizers, $7-$15; salads and sandwiches, $5-$15; entrees, $18-$36; desserts, $8.
  • Sound level: Loud near the bar; quiet in wine room and semi-private dining area.
  • Details: Full bar with emphasis on American wines and frilly but potent martinis. Parking in lot. Handicapped accessible in main section of dining room. Credit cards accepted.
  • Wild card: Lotus roots, which are actually the stems of the water plant and known for their lacy pattern, are bought from a local Asian store, sliced and pickled with Korean pepper flakes, Korean chili paste, pickling spices and vinegar.

Blue North is open only for dinner, a time when most of its neighbors are closed. So what was a restaurant with an interesting and eclectic menu doing in this shopping center?

I quickly forgot about that question when I walked in because Blue North is a world apart, figuratively and literally. The bar area was filled with people ordering frilly but potent martinis, and red and white wines. A cozy burgundy-colored wine room, with a linen-covered long table used for special dinners and tastings, spread warmth to the cool, stylish and blue dining room, which was divided into three sections and dimly lit.

Advertise with us

The kitchen did not confine itself to one particular cuisine, and almost every item on the long contemporary and American-fusion menu offered a twist on classics and introduced unexpected ingredients.

Made with spinach, the hummus ($8) was treated to a good squirt of lemon juice and built up a reservoir of goodwill instantly, along with the kalamata olives and soft pita wedges.

Sugar and salt were used creatively and deliciously as a crust in the 5 Spice Shrimp ($12), which were not only beautifully presented but also perfectly cooked and flavored with star anise, Sichuan pepper, cloves, cinnamon and chili flakes. An added attraction was the lacy-looking pickled lotus root slices, which were more tender than crunchy.

It was hard to resist the lightly breaded long eggplant fries ($7), which came with fried sage and a creamy Tuscan aioli perfumed with basil and sage. I wasn’t sure if I was eating the fries for the sake of the aioli or dipping into the aioli just to have more fries.

Although it seemed ubiquitous, asparagus wrapped with prosciutto ($12) was anything but. A poached duck egg with a deep yellow yolk and eggier taste was surrounded by verdant grilled spears that got a salty kick from the prosciutto and a tangy lift from the balsamic reduction.

Advertise with us

I could rhapsodize for hours over the seared ahi tuna ($13) crusted with sesame. Prepared perfectly rare, the fish slices were layered on top of crackling-crisp wonton sheets and exploded in taste from a good splash of sweet soy sauce and a drizzle of Sriracha aioli. A fresh cucumber salsa was the sidekick, and just as superb.

Lobster Stuffed Mushroom Caps ($12) dusted with paprika also looked like a piece of art. The mushrooms were meaty and the hollandaise sauce rich and creamy, but then I had look hard to find the lobster meat, and when I found it, it was tasteless.

With flavors such as the tomato-based cherry Buffalo barbecue and the chili bean paste-based Korean barbecue, I was lured toward the Chicken Wings 3 Ways ($12). Although the barbecue sauces were piquant, the wings had little meat on them and were rather dry. The third flavor was a sweet chili garlic, which tasted as pallid as it looked.

When Grainne Trainor, who previously owned the Mighty Oak Barrel in Oakmont, opened the restaurant on April 1, 2015, she changed its name from Blue to Blue North, and that wasn’t an April Fools’ joke.

“I wanted to maintain the existing customer base of the previous restaurant,” she said over the phone. “I added north because I am from Northern Ireland, the restaurant is in the North Hills, and I have an affinity for the North Star — it’s a constant, it’s solid, and I want my restaurant to be like that.”

Advertise with us

Tables in the spacious dining room were not covered with linen because Ms. Trainor wants people to think of Blue North as a casual and not an expensive place, and to remember it for the diverse menu. And those diverse surprises continued to dominate the entrees.

Grass Fed Lamb Rack ($36) came in a range of textures — crisp, moist and juicy. The lollipops were more medium than medium-rare but still very tender, and the char cut through a gorgeous spinach that popped with a curry flavor. A fresh mint puree was mixed in with the lamb’s pan sauce, adding a whole other layer of wonderfulness to the meat. Crisp fingerling potatoes, simply seasoned with salt, were a delight as a side.

Delicate and yet full of character, the pan-seared, oven-roasted meatballs in the Salmon Meatball Pasta ($19) were lacquered with an elegant and light lemon beurre blanc that got an extra wink of flavor from finely minced shallots. The meatballs had a natural affinity with the accompanying spinach and tomatoes, but the overcooked angel hair pasta loaded with Parmesan cheese didn’t do them justice.

A velvety red-eye gravy made with ham hocks and a coffee reduction stole the show from the chewy Coffee Crusted Filet of Beef ($35) that was salty at the ends. Green beans and polenta made with white cheddar cheese added color to the plate and contrasting textures.

Vegetable Timbale Pasta ($18) was summery, simple and satisfying, built with zucchini, yellow squash, red peppers and onion on a bed of al dente pappardelle pasta circled with garlicky pesto.

Advertise with us

The desserts (each $8) were worth leaving space for, especially the Banoffee Pie. After every spoonful of the coarse cookie crust layered with a mild toffee sauce, fresh sliced bananas, whipped cream sprinkled with cocoa powder and chopped nuts, I had only one word — wow!

Naughty and nice, the Southern Fried Chocolate Pie required a rating that it was strictly for chocoholics. Intense Belgian chocolate ganache was encased in a pie crust and fried. Dusted with powdered sugar, it looked prim and proper on the outside but was nothing but wanton inside.

On the other hand, the Strawberry Lemon Cheesecake tasted as genteel as it appeared, and even the berries, lemon curd and whipped cream could not weigh it down. Creme Brulee was sensuous with a thin crackling crust of caramelized sugar and an oh-so-creamy vanilla custard.

There’s no view to be had from Blue North, unless you sit by the window or dine outside and want to look out into a desolate parking lot. But it is worth seeking out if you want to expand your fusion palate and be introduced to unexpected flavors.

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1494 or on Twitter @arthisub.