Contrasts converge at Chaz & Odette.

The restaurant sits in the former Toast! Kitchen & Wine Bar space on a peopleless stretch of Baum Boulevard in Shadyside where cars whizz by. It doesn’t feel like a neighborhood restaurant from the outside, but once you open the nondescript door, you step into a cozy setting that has an upscale-rustic ambience.

Chaz  & Odette

5102 Baum Blvd.,

Advertise with us

Shadyside

412-683-8300 (Has Facebook page; website is under construction)

  • Hours: 11 a.m.-9 p.m. Wednesday, Thursday and Friday; 5-10 p.m. Saturday.
  • Prices: Appetizers, $7-$10; flatbreads, $11-$13; sandwiches, $8-$14; entrees, $15-$26; desserts, $8.
  • Sound Level: Very quiet.
  • Details: Full bar with extensive wine and beer list. Parking along the street in front of the restaurant. Wheelchair accessible. Credit cards and reservations accepted.
  • Wild Card: Refreshing limoncello, made in-house, has distinct lemon, lime and orange flavors that come together nicely.

A bar, stocked with wines, craft beers and a refreshing housemade limoncello, runs almost the length of the narrow dining room, which has an exposed wood-beam ceiling. Recycled wooden chairs and small wooden tables with plain cutting-board tops accentuate the rustic theme. Chalkboards to the back and side of the bar list the beer and dessert options, and it is hard to ignore the wall of bottled pickled vegetables in between the boards. Little lights in Mason jars illuminate the bar area and add a warm touch.

The two charming dining rooms upstairs drop the rustic accent and have chic ceiling fans with lights and linen-covered tables. Service is charming, too, and friendly and honest. Wait staff don’t pretend to know something when they don’t, and their recommendations are spot-on.

Chefs Charles “Chaz” Smith and Odette Smith-Ransome opened C&O last October, and by December it had gotten a shout-out from Zagat, which ranked Pittsburgh as the No. 1 food city of 2015.

Advertise with us

But maybe it wasn’t loud enough because on all my visits the restaurant was practically empty. On one Friday evening, my friend and I were the sole diners, and on another dinner visit only three other tables were taken.

C&O has gone through a lot of transformation in the past six months. Mr. Smith left the restaurant in June, and the menu has been revamped.

“I decided to keep the name; it was an amicable separation,” said Ms. Smith-Ransome over the phone. The Mount Washington native was a private chef to the late University of Pittsburgh chancellor Wesley Posvar for two years and a culinary arts professor at the Art Institute of Pittsburgh.

Her menu speaks with a classic and nouveau American tone and also a global voice, with plenty of options for meat lovers, vegetarians and the gluten-free. It also reflects her belief in real food that is locally sourced. Sausages and beef are smoked (on a smoker built by her brother) and cured in-house, herbs are grown on the back deck, and flatbreads are made with a 3-year-old yeast starter called George.

Everything about the strawberry and feta salad ($7) was real, and it sent out positive signals even as it arrived to the table — the fresh smell of ripe berries was tantalizing. Tossed with a mild feta, Bibb lettuce, walnuts with hints of clove and cinnamon and the right amount of orange vinaigrette, the salad was light with everything singing in harmony.

Advertise with us

Charred Brussels sprouts ($8) veered off script from the menu. The dish came with pine nuts instead of sunflower seeds, and there was no sign or taste of the listed shallots. But I didn’t miss them because what was served was one of the best charred sprouts I have ever had. Drizzled with a honey-balsamic dressing that struck a piquant balance between sweet and tangy, the crispiness held up even after the sprouts had cooled some.

It was difficult to taste the chorizo, potatoes, peppers and greens in the Patatas Bravas Empanadas ($9) because the filling was skimpy inside the thick, hard, over-fried pockets of pastry shell. But the house-cured chorizo, with a good dash of red pepper flakes and cumin, shined on the C&O Sausage Three Ways plate ($10), along with a mild bratwurst made with mustard and garlic and a smoked andouille spiked with ancho chili powder and black peppers.

The sausages were accompanied with delicious pickled sweet and sour cucumbers, carrots flavored with jalapeno and dill, cauliflower with hints of dill and watermelon rinds spiced with cinnamon and nutmeg; sourdough puff bread; and chunks of cheddar, smoked Gouda and mozzarella. It was impossible to stop pecking on sausages and the vegetables, but then there was also an amazing charred bread made with George to tear into. It was so fluffy and light that even carb curmudgeons will yield to it.

C&O Sliders ($12) also came three ways — thinly sliced corned beef with a tangy sauerkraut and homemade Thousand Island dressing on a rye bun, moist fuchsia-pink pastrami with grainy mustard on a pumpernickel bun, and tender smoked brisket with a mild horseradish sauce on a sweet challah roll — along with homemade chips.

Pollo al Limone and C&O Steak ($24 each) were hearty entrees available only for dinner. The crisp golden chicken revealed a moist and lemony meat. Candied baby carrots with a good dusting of cinnamon were divine and appeared as a side instead of the menu-prescribed spinach. Capers were MIA as well, but scattered lemon slices made up for the pucker power.

Advertise with us

A generous topping of mushrooms, caramelized onions and a crisp strip of hobo bacon topped the sirloin steak. Its blackened exterior with overcooked ends was a sharp contrast to the rosy tender interior. The sides — candied carrots and creamy dreamy potatoes made with Parmesan and garlic — were showstoppers.

Surf and surf complemented each other wonderfully in Crab Stuffed Cod ($24), a pure pleasure in the mouth. The flaky and delicate fish was filled with robustly spiced crabmeat and crowned with crunchy breadcrumbs. A skewer of grilled vegetables added color to the plate, but the bland and gummy sushi rice would have been better off left out.

Ratatouille Nicoise ($18) tasted fresh but had little else going for it. The stew with mushroom, zucchini, bell pepper and tomato was underseasoned and got no help from the accompanying flavorless sushi rice.

Chantilly cream made an appearance with every dessert ($8) I tried. The crepes were a letdown. I had to almost saw through the tough palacsinta, a Hungarian crepe filled with a berry jam, only to find that the dollop of mango pulp on top was a bully and had overpowered the berry flavor. The dainty cream was voiceless.

But there were winners. Studded with strawberries, blackberries and blueberries on a layer of cream, a crumbly shortcake with lemon zest was as indulgent as it looked. Crisp palmiers, shaped like elephant ear cookies and topped with caramel and sugar granules, were buttery and scrumptious, and needed to carry a warning sign that it would be difficult to stop with one or two or even three.

Advertise with us

I don’t often care for din when dining out, but I strangely missed it during my visits. The place was practically empty, which is a shame. C&O deserves to be seen and sampled.

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1494 or on Twitter @arthisub.