Bob McCafferty hopes the money will flow in the Harmony Inn, which he bought last fall and spent a year renovating. Just not in the way it did late one night back in the early 2000s when he was a bartender there.
Alone in the three-story Italianate-style house built in 1856 for banker/railroad executive Austin Pearce, Mr. McCafferty was washing the last few glasses behind the inn’s long, wood bar. It was eerily quiet, but he wasn’t particularly fearful, despite the inn’s long history of being haunted.
Then out of nowhere something came flying through the air, narrowly missing his head before hitting the wall fronting Harmony’s Mercer Street and clattering to the floor.
It wasn’t until he saw them rolling across the antique pine floor boards that he realized what the tiny missiles were -- coins, five in all.
“They came right out of the wall,” says Mr. McCafferty, a former archaeologist who also owns North Country Brewing Co. with his wife, Jodi, in his native Slippery Rock. “It definitely felt like someone was trying to hit me.” Shaken, he did what any sane person would do. He got the heck out of there as fast as he could.
Ghost stories abound on the scariest night of the year, Halloween. But they’re part of the everyday fabric at the Harmony Inn, which at the end of August reopened for business with a brand-new menu featuring German-inspired fare by Chef Rob Morris.
The McCaffertys purchased the inn this past November after hearing the building, which had fallen into disrepair, was headed for sheriff’s sale. Having worked there while North Country was coming together, both had a soft spot for the picturesque-but-struggling restaurant, which sits on the main drag in Harmony’s quaint National Historic District. It’s where Mr. McCafferty first got his wife-to-be’s phone number, after all.
So when rumors started circulating that a pizza place would replace it -- without a liquor license, no less -- they knew they had to act.
“I love pizza, but I couldn’t stand it, and Jodi couldn’t stand it either,” he says.
The ghosts came along with $150,000 in back taxes.
Even before previous owners Gary Barnes and Carl Beers purchased the mansion in 1985 and turned it from a hotel/boarding house into a restaurant, it’s been believed by those who believe in such things to be one of the most haunted places in Western Pennsylvania. Along with the strange noises, flickering lights and unexplained electrical impulses, visitors have felt gusts of cold air blow past them, seen objects move by themselves or fly off shelves and heard their names being called out from empty rooms.
Customers and staff also have witnessed hair-raising appearances by at least two resident spirits: Louie, the original innkeeper; and Grandma, a skeletal figure who haunts a second-floor dining room. They don’t always keep their hands to themselves.
More than one server has felt a finger going from the base of his or her neck down the spine while taking orders in the upstairs dining room, said Mr. McCafferty, who counts his scariest one-on-one experience as the time he saw the silhouette of a man in the basement cooler when he was changing kegs.
“I got the sense he wasn’t good,” he says, noting how the light glimmered around his head and shoulders instead of passing through him.
Not so with the young boy he spotted a few weeks ago on the second-floor landing as he was climbing the stairs. After mischievously peering around the door frame, he disappeared into the hallway by the bathrooms, “like he was playing.”
“It’s a bonus if you come for dinner and get to see something,” says Harmony regular Jason Sarver, recounting how a friend once saw someone standing behind her in the bathroom mirror, only to have the figure disappear when she turned around.
Bartender Scott Calvert recalls getting locked in the bathroom one night by some unknown force, while co-worker Krista Burton, who started as a server in 2004 and now tends bar, has heard phantom vacuuming and moving of chairs upstairs.
“But they don’t bother me at all,” she says. “Everyone has a story if you’ve been here long enough and are by yourself.”
It’s not the only old restaurant building said to hold non-drinkable spirits.
Drew Topping, owner of Piper’s Pub and neighboring Pub Chip Shop on E. Carson Street in the South Side, has heard plenty of weird noises on the buildings’ second and third floors. Stuff also tends to fall over when it shouldn’t, such as a bucket filled with 15 pounds of dried mortar left over from a bathroom remodel.
Things have also flown off the shelf in Mr. Topping’s office, “usually behind you,” and more than once a broom leaned against the wall or a coffee cup set on a desk inexplicably falls over.
There also have been spirit sightings over the years, he said. A women in the neighborhood who is “enlightened” has seen ghosts sitting in the window and beside customers at the bar, and there’s also an unknown female who likes to look out the second-floor window.
“But she’s pretty content,” says Mr. Topping, who adds, “If they’re hanging out and not terrorizing us, it’s all good.”
Before it closed last year, Papa J’s Centro on the Boulevard of the Allies, Downtown, built in the 1860s, also reported a ghostly past dating to its days as a brothel. Many customers reported seeing an apparition of a woman upstairs or in the women’s room that used to be a bedroom, where a person was murdered many years ago.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.