If you're a food writer, you generally don't favor eating out on Valentine's Day. Like New Year's Eve, it's supposed to be "amateur hour," reserved for people who can't imagine anything better than filet mignon and molten chocolate cake and are willing to be crammed into restaurants two-by-two to enjoy it.
But at this point, bashing the Valentine's Day restaurant meal is as much of a cliche as actually eating it -- and a lot less delicious.
While there are plenty of restaurants that inflate prices on big holidays, there are just as many that offer a spectacular night out. Whether the menu is classic or creative, the setting elaborate or simple, restaurants provide particularly memorable spots for a romantic evening. And unlike, say, Sunday brunch, a lot of restaurant employees actually enjoy working on Valentine's Day.
"People are always in a good mood," agreed Jennifer Love, general manager of Casbah in Shadyside. "No one is in a rush; it's all around a nice, pleasant evening."
And for some diners, it will be a significant one. Valentine's Day is a very popular day for proposals, many of which will take place in restaurants. Each proposal is unique to its participants, but some truly are memorable, and become an endearing part of the restaurant's lore.
One year at Casbah, a local artist brought in an abstract painting that included the words "Will you marry me?" said Ms. Love. They hung the painting on the wall, as if it were just another piece of art, and then sat the artist and his girlfriend underneath it. It took her awhile, but finally the woman noticed the painting and realized what he was asking her.
In the past couple of months, Isabela on Grandview, on Mount Washington, has been the site of six or seven proposals, said executive chef Dan Leiphart. The restaurant's celebratory tasting menu and gorgeous view of the Pittsburgh skyline makes it a top choice for romantic dinners, and Mr. Leiphart suspects there will be several more proposals on Valentine's Day.
He'll find out soon enough. In his experience, people planning to propose have the event meticulously mapped out. Many bring the ring to the restaurant in advance, or drop off surprise gifts, like a small cake or cupcakes.
But some heartfelt Valentine's stories don't involve proposals.
Isabela's general manager, Justin Armstrong, recalled an incident last year when a young couple arrived for dinner, but then weren't certain about staying because of the prices. They had been seated next to an older couple, Mr. Armstrong recalled, who had dined at the restaurant many times before and who approached Mr. Armstrong and asked if they could take care of the bill for their young neighbors.
"Seeing the generosity and the caring, it made it special for us, the staff, as well," Mr. Armstrong said.
Restaurant staff typically enjoy celebrating with their guests -- after all, they are in the hospitality business. And for diners, experiencing a special moment in a favorite restaurant can add a glow to each future meal.
The Hyeholde in Moon has been a popular spot for proposals for nearly 75 years. The current owner, Barbara McKenna, recalled one couple who got engaged on Valentine's Day many years ago when her parents owned the restaurant. They got married and moved to Wisconsin and later sent her father a picture of themselves with a boat that they had bought -- they'd named it "The Hyeholde."
Ms. McKenna particularly enjoys this holiday, as she herself got engaged on Valentine's Day. This year, she's decided to offer diners two options for celebrating. Upstairs, a six-course tasting menu will be offered, but downstairs in the Round Room, there will be a Hyebar, with cocktails and small bites.
The latter option might be a good one for those who don't have a date, but don't want to let a fun evening pass by. Most restaurants will host at least a few groups of friends, and they're just as happy to have them.
"Last year, we had a few groups, which was nice," said Ms. Love of Casbah. "One was nine women, they all came out on their own and celebrated Valentine's Day with the girls."
Whether planning a casual night or a proposal, start thinking about making reservations now. Valentine's Day is a Tuesday this year, but many restaurants will offer special menus on other nights as well, such as the Saturday before, when many will likely choose to celebrate.
Local restaurants are just beginning to post their Valentine's Day offerings. Call your favorite restaurant and ask what they're planning.
And if you're looking for something a little more unusual than dinner at a restaurant, there are options for you as well, such as this special event at the Pittsburgh Zoo: On Feb. 11, enjoy cocktails and hors d'oeuvres followed by dinner, all complemented by a special presentation on "how the animals of land, sea and air find love in the wild."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.