It isn’t easy for Megan Finkelstein to sell her mother’s Mount Washington home. It is filled with 30 years of memories, red rooms and neon lights.

Needless to say, it’s not your typical 1880s Victorian. That’s because it was the home of two rather unique people.

“It’s hard to sell, to be honest with you. You want someone new in the house who feels the same way,” she said.

Her mother, Sandra Spatter, died in May after working in real estate for 35 years. Her husband, Sam Spatter, who died in 2014, wrote about real estate for The Pittsburgh Press and, in retirement, for the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.

Advertise with us

The couple brought their passion for real estate to the house they bought in 1991 and, over the years, filled it with color and creativity.

The three-story house at 45 Wyoming St. has four bedrooms, 2½ baths and is priced at $499,000 (MLS No. 1773609) with Roberta Allen of RE/MAX Realty Brokers (remax.com or  412-287-4781). An open house is scheduled for Sunday, Oct. 4, 1-3 p.m.

Unlike many homes its age, this Victorian is not covered by a layer of vinyl siding or painted in boring neutral colors.

“When my mom and Sam bought it, it was a beige-white color, and then they repainted it, making it look like a cute little dollhouse," said Finkelstein.

“They tried to keep everything as original as they could. My mom loved Victorians.”

Advertise with us

The exterior is painted a sage green and buttery yellow with red trim, a traditional Victorian color palette that shows off its gingerbread molding and wraps around the large front porch.

“She was a little eclectic, as you can tell by the house,” Finkelstein said. “She loved the old Victorian but also liked modern.”

Her mother loved color — especially red — and she and her husband updated the home while adding a bit of whimsy. The formal living room has rich red walls, original stained wood trim and hardwood flooring installed in the early 1990s.

“When they bought the house in 1991, the contractor-builder who previously owned it helped mom and Sam. He was like a modern-day flipper.... They bought it from him, and then they contracted all the work that they wanted from him,” Finkelstein said.

They had the contractor redo the kitchen with a vinyl floor and builder-grade oak cabinets. Years later, Mrs. Spatter decided the kitchen needed a complete makeover.

Advertise with us

“My mother did things the way she wanted to do things,” Finkelstein said. “She and Sam did a lot of traveling, were very active socially and were foodies who loved to cook.

“She wanted an upscale gourmet kitchen, and she wanted this red clock with neon lights. Sam said ‘no’ — he was not interested in that idea. But my mother said, ‘That’s what we’re going to do.’”

Mrs. Spatter got a kitchen with a built-in pantry, a Wolf range, a French-door refrigerator, a large island with seating on one side, a bookshelf for cookbooks, and a breakfast nook surrounded by windows with access to a private patio and garden on the large, double lot.

She also got the large clock and neon lights that highlight a bright red ceiling.

Her husband was not a fan at first, but grew to like his unique kitchen.

Advertise with us

“Anytime anyone came into the house – remember it was Sam who initially said, ‘No, I don’t want neon all over my kitchen' – the first thing Sam would do is say, ‘Come look at this,' and he’d be turning on the neon lights for everyone,” Finkelstein said.

“He loved it. It was their relationship. It was adorable.”

After he died, Finkelstiein noticed that her mother was having trouble getting around the 2,314-square-foot house. She spoke to her about moving.

“My mother had no intention of leaving. That was their forever house,” she said.

“And my mother, when she had something in her mind, that’s how it went. We had many conversations about that. She said she was putting an elevator in because ‘I’m not going to leave my house. That’s what I’m doing.’”

Advertise with us

Finkelstein believes the elevator, which goes to the second-floor bedroom Mrs. Spatter used as a study, could be removed by the new owners, but they would need to replace some flooring. The installers “literally put a hole in the ceiling” but did not change the house structurally, she said.

The second floor contains a large primary suite with a walk-in closet and a deck that has a view the Downtown skyline. Its bathroom boasts a sauna, a jetted tub and a rather unusual red sink.

“When P.F. Chang’s at The Waterfront opened, she was there and the bathroom had that sink. Right after the opening, she came out and she said, ‘I’m putting that sink in my house,’” recalled Finkelstein.

“We were all asking, ‘Why you would put a cement sink in your house?’ But she was having that sink and Sam would just smile and say ‘OK.’”

The laundry is also on the second floor, which made life easier for Mrs. Spatter.

Advertise with us

The third floor contains a second full bathroom and two bedrooms with angled ceilings that follow the house’s Victorian roofline.

The house has central air-conditioning, radiators with a gas-powered boiler and six off-street parking spaces.

The couple loved nature, especially one tree in the backyard.

“They just built around the tree.... The tree was there, and they didn’t want to take it down, so they just built the deck around the tree. They didn’t want to disturb it,” Finkelstein said.

The Spatters also loved the holidays. The side lot came in handy for parking during Fourth of July parties and Halloween was a favorite of Mrs. Spatter. She kept a jack-o'-lantern in a window year-round, much to the confusion of her family.

Advertise with us

The property’s 2026 Allegheny County assessment is $148,900 and annual taxes are $3,924. Over the last four years, one house has sold in the first block of Wyoming Street for $410,000 in October 2024 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us).

Finkelstein realizes the house’s new owners will likely make changes.

“You think about the people back in the 1800s. Would they have liked her neon clock? Maybe not. I get that.

“It’s keeping the character of the house that I would love,” she said.