When you walk into some houses for sale, you wonder what the owner was thinking.
There’s no doubt when you step inside 2535 Fife Drive in Upper St. Clair. The owner clearly loves antiques and the entire house is a period piece, a stage to show off her finds.
So what was collector Donna Walker thinking? That this house was exactly what she always wanted, and it was perfect.
“This was like her museum,” says her daughter, Teal Walker. “She cleaned it every day.”
Teal likes a clean house, too, but she is not a collector. So she is selling the 1870 house she grew up in for $1.2 million (MLS No. 1750001), listed with Jen Schalk of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services (howardhanna.com of 412-327-4209).
Teal hopes the buyer will want the furniture, too. It will be sold separately.
“I would like as much as possible to go with the house,” she said.
The four-bedroom, two-bath woodframe house has seven fireplaces, three of which are wood-burning, and large rooms. The dining room, living room and family room each measure 17 by 15 feet and three of the bedrooms — each with a fireplace — are nearly as big. The fourth bedroom is currentlly used as an office.
There is also a detached summer kitchen and a one-car garage with a Belgian-block driveway.
The house is not as full as it once was. Crocks, paintings and other smaller items were auctioned in October 2025, when Donna’s husband, Charles “Bob” Walker, died. He had carefully preserved the house and its contents after Donna passed away in April 2009.
Together, they spent over 25 years restoring the “remuddled” farmhouse they bought in 1976. It was “only” 100 years old then, one of two late 19th-century houses still standing on land pioneer John Fife purchased from a local Indian tribe “for one flintlock and a pair of moccasins,” according to a member of the Upper St. Clair Historical Society.
The Walkers rebuilt three of the fireplaces, tore down plasterboard and crown molding, patched plaster and stripped “every piece of woodwork in the house,” Donna told me in January 2001, when I visited and wrote about the house.
Donna Walker antiques-filled farmhouse Fife Drive Upper St. Clair PG 1/6 2001
Article from Jan 6, 2001 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania)
“I probably should have lived 100 years ago,” she said, laughing.
While she and her husband were working on her dream home, Donna was buying antiques dating from the late 1700s to the early 1900s during vacations in Vermont and at shops in nearby Washington and Greene counties. She bought more than half of the antique furniture in the house from June Stout, a legendary dealer from Ruff Creek, Greene County.
Some pieces remain in the same rooms as when I visited 25 years ago, including a painted late 1700s corner cupboard in the dining room and a Hepplewhite walnut secretary in the living room. Stout also sold her the Civil War-era four poster beds in three of the bedrooms.
Also intact is an early American reproduction chandelier Donna had made for the dining room and stencil designs she painted in some of the rooms. She didn’t paint the wonderful period-style mural that runs up the staircase. Teal said it depicts other houses her family had lived in and beloved family pets and other animals. She’s not sure who painted it.
Other unique features of the property include an original covered side porch and a side patio leading to the summer kitchen, which was supposed to be a hangout for Teal and her sister, Jessica, but ended up handling overflow from their mother’s antiques booth at Antique Junction in nearby Canonsburg.
The house stands on 1.7 acres in the middle of a development of much newer homes. The 2026 Allegheny County property assessment is $187,200 and annual taxes are $7,648. Over the last three years, three homes have sold on Fife Drive for prices ranging from $298,000 in May 2023 to $540,000 in June 2025 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us)
Growing up in this house, Teal said her family never used the dining room or living room. They preferred the family room, whose old fireplace has a wood-burning insert. She said her mother kept a detailed catalog of every antique she owned — including its provenance, where she bought it and for how much.
Donna was meticulous about cleanliness, too. During our interview, she told me she kept a small rug hidden under the oriental carpet in the front hall so visitors could wipe their feet.
“I never wanted to turn into my mother, but I have turned into her as far as cleaning,” Teal said. “But I don’t need a lot of stuff. I’m a very simple person.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.