When Emily Saxman moved into Webster Hall Apartments four years ago, she was a University of Pittsburgh student with no idea of its unique history. She simply wanted a calm place to study and live.

Now, having graduated, she works at Webster Hall as a community assistant and is part of continuing and preserving that history.

The hotel-turned-apartments is a reflection of the changing community and culture of Oakland. Celebrating its 100th anniversary this year, Webster Hall predates the nearby Cathedral of Learning on the Pitt campus. It was converted into apartments in 1979 and now houses many students from Pitt and Carnegie Mellon University.

“During the 100 years, Webster Hall has really seen Oakland come into itself,” said property manager Jessica Stanislaw.

Advertise with us

Webster Hall opened in 1926 as a hotel designed by architects Henry Hornbostel and Eric Fischer Wood. It was designed for single men because women didn’t often travel unaccompanied at the time, according to Stanislaw.

“Luckily, with the progression of women’s independence, after about 10 years or so the hotel just changed into a regular hotel and was open to all guests. That reflected more and more people coming into the area as the universities were being built,” she said.

Initially, the hotel had just nine rooms. In the 1940s, a sun deck was added, revolutionary for the time.

The sun deck was later transformed into a rooftop pool, believed to be the first at a hotel in the city.  After another renovation, the pool gave way to three more stories, and the building topped out at 12 floors. At its peak, the hotel had more than 600 rooms.

Oakland was becoming a cultural hub for Pittsburgh, with museums, restaurants and theaters, and Hotel Webster Hall reflected that growth. The hotel contained restaurants and coffee shops and a large ballroom.

Advertise with us

“We find the ballroom seems to be one of the things that really connects the people of Pittsburgh to Webster Hall,” Stanislaw said.

Hotel Webster Hall hosted weddings, proms, family reunions and many other events. In the 1960s and ’70s, the hotel frequently housed visiting athletes, especially teams playing the Pirates at nearby Forbes Field.

“There’s a rumor that they celebrated the [1960] World Series win here at Webster Hall,” said Stanislaw, a huge Pirates fan.

The Green Book

As the universities gained prominence, the hotel changed again, attracting students and businessmen, including people of color. Webster Hall was included in “The Negro Motorist Green Book,” which alerted Black travelers to hotels, restaurants and other places that would serve them. It was written and regularly updated by Victor Hugo Green and others from 1936 to 1966.

“I am glad to hear that there is evidence of the hotel even in its renovation and conversion to an apartment complex,” said Marsha Hardeman, 75, a historian with a focus on the Green Book and an adjunct professor in Africana studies at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque.

Advertise with us

“It gives an anchor to historic perspective. This is pretty extraordinary because in a lot of places everything has been torn down and rebuilt.”

Green was a mail carrier, Hardeman said, “and in his work of course he had a heightened awareness more than others about travel and moving the mail as he did from different parts of the country.”

When the book was first published in the 1930s, “a Black man was very much aware of the discrimination that Black people faced and of the harm and danger for many,” she said.

“Black people could travel [but] they might have had to stay in their cars when they traveled,” she said.

Pittsburgh attracted many Black touring musicians. It was a regular stop between New York City and Chicago.

Advertise with us

“When I teach the Harlem Renaissance, I remind my students that so much talent was bubbling up in the U.S. during the era of the Harlem Renaissance,” Hardeman said. “They were headliners in those spaces, but where could they go and sleep and eat? It’s just amazing to think of almost a double life that these talented, famous people had to live.”

Webster Hall is one of the few buildings still standing in Pittsburgh that was listed in the Green Book.

Travelers remember receiving a warm welcome at the hotel. Stanislaw was recently contacted by a college professor from Texas who was helping a colleague go through some of her grandparents' things. They found keychains from Hotel Webster Hall, which suggested that her grandparents had an extended stay there.

“What was really interesting was that her grandparents were Holocaust survivors and the professor was wondering if there was a connection between them being survivors and staying at the hotel,” Stanislaw said

The keys had the original hotel crest.

Advertise with us

“We haven’t been able to find out any information about that yet, but what another wonderful story for our building,” Stanislaw said.

Hotel to apartments

As the nearby universities grew, students and their families became common guests in the 1970s. The hotel’s ownership changed and in 1979, the building was renovated as apartments.

Currently, there are 172 units with about 350 residents. Not all are college students; anyone who qualifies can live there, Stanislaw said, and there are some families and young professionals.

The apartments’ layouts are very different than they were when they were hotel rooms, Stanislaw said.

“That is another thing that makes us unique. Because it used to be a hotel, we have more than 30 different floor plans,” she said.

Advertise with us

Studio apartments range in size from 346 to 419 square feet and rent for $1,695-$1,725 per month. One-bedroom units rent for $1,910-$2,215 and range from 591 to 864 square feet.

The rent for two-bedroom apartments is $2,415-$2,830 and their size is 756-1,241 square feet. Three-bedroom units rent for $3,640-$3,660 and range from 1,301 to 1,438 square feet.

Amenities include a fitness center, community rooms and work spaces. There is a $60 application fee and $300 security deposit. Information: websterhallapartments.com.

When she first visited Webster Hall, Saxman was impressed with her one-bedroom apartment’s storage space, which includes two bedroom closets, two other closets and a linen closet.

“I think I have more stuff than I actually need because of the closets,” said Saxman, 30.

Advertise with us

She has a beautiful view of the Cathedral of Learning from her kitchen, she said, and her living room is flooded with natural light. Every floor at Webster Hall has a laundry room, and hers is never crowded, she said.

“Even today, Webster Hall is its own little community, not just the people that live here but the people that work in the businesses,” Stanislaw said.

Kevin’s Deli

Some have worked here for decades, like Kevin McAllister.

McAllister, 56, of Wilkinsburg, runs Kevin’s Deli inside Webster Hall. In 1987, after he graduated from high school, he began working in the deli. A year later, they laid him off. The owner called him back later that year.

In 1989, McAllister met his future wife while working at the deli. She used to come in every day and get Jenny’s Old-Fashioned Cheddar Cheese Popcorn. He and his wife Marion have been married for 35 years. He bought the deli 17 years ago.

Advertise with us

“That’s how I got it,” he said. “I am just a big-small part of the space.”

Throughout the day, McAllister is busy filling orders for deli favorites such as grilled cheese or turkey club sandwiches, Philly cheesesteak and steak salad.

He’s had other jobs, but said he’s never taken a day off from the deli.

“The history of the building really captures the heart of anyone who spends time in the building,” Stanislaw said.

“In a large building that is 100 years old, we are always uncovering hidden details that we weren’t aware of before.”

Advertise with us

Other Webster Halls

Hornbostel, the architect, initially had the idea to have a chain of Hotel Websters, with at least four others in the planning stages.

“They built one in Chicago and one in Pittsburgh, but our building and the one in Chicago are the only hotels still in existence,” Stanislaw said.

Chicago’s Webster Hall is now a concert venue. “Webster Hall in Pittsburgh is the only one still used as a residence,” she said.

The apartments have ongoing events for the residents, but this year they are doing a few special things to celebrate Webster Hall’s 100th anniversary.

One of the hotel’s prominent businesses was a coffee shop that was widely known its Bavarian coffee cake. Stanislaw said the recipe was “a closely guarded secret” and that several bakeries have offered what they claim is “the Webster Hall coffee cake.” She is working with a local bakery to revive and recreate the recipe.

Advertise with us

Later in the year, there are plans to bury a Webster Hall time capsule that would be opened on its 200th anniversary.

Stanislaw reflected on the building’s legacy.

“I like that it feels like the influence of each generation remains here as time passes. I hope as we go into the future all the work and love that we have put into this building continues to be felt.”