One of the joys of owning an older home is discovering the history of the people who once lived there.

Homeowners Wendy Pashman and Michael Patrizio moved from Chicago to 420 Pressley St., North Side, in 2021 and discovered one of its former owners was a German immigrant who became a prominent 19th-century Pittsburgh vocalist, music instructor and artist associated with the Scalp Level School of painters.

“It was built for a guy named Frederic Bussman, who was a musician,” Pashman said. “His family lived here then. Some years later, it went to disrepair.”

Fortunately, that isn’t where the story ended for the three-story Victorian built in 1880. It was one of 15 homes in the Deutschtown neighborhood renovated by the East Allegheny Community Council in 2000-2001.

Advertise with us

Now, the four-bedroom, three-bathroom home with 3,184 square feet of living space is on the market for $649,000 (MLS No. 1742342) with Ella Serrato of RE/MAX Select Realty (remax.com or 412-606-0969). An open house is scheduled for 1-3 p.m. Sunday, April 26.

The heart of this home is the kitchen, which has been renovated to create a space for entertaining their large family during the holidays.

“We always have Christmas Day here with 25 people,” said Pashman. “My daughter comes in from New York, my other daughter comes in from Boston and we have the big family Italian Christmas. Michael’s sister has, like 45 people in Ohio, then people come here on Christmas Day.

“When we moved in four years ago, the kitchen space was good, a very large space, but it wasn’t set up the way we wanted it to be exactly set up. So we did a complete redo of the kitchen,” she said.

“Then we brought our appliances from Chicago. The refrigerator for instance, I don’t know if you can buy it anymore. It has a glass front on it. It’s very distinctive.”

Advertise with us

The Sub-Zero refrigerator and freezer, along with a Wolf gas range, were packed up and brought to Pittsburgh. The new kitchen design includes a breakfast bar with seating for two, a serious amount of prep space and custom-made cabinets that reach from the floor to the ceiling along the rear wall.

The design aesthetic of the kitchen is more modern than the majority of the home, which retains many of its original details, including crown molding and tall windows and ceilings.

The main living area at the front of the house includes two large windows and a pair of tall doorways leading to a cozy family room lined with bookshelves.

“Michael’s father built bookshelves in the living room and if you didn’t know, you would think they were here forever,” said Pashman.

Renovators opened up the first floor. The floor plan has the spacious kitchen at the end, with a powder room tucked underneath the stairs leading to the second floor. Exposed-brick walls are painted white, contrasting with the darker tile floor throughout the first floor.

Advertise with us

“The house is a wonderful mixture of historical and modern,” Pashman said. “In 2000, it was completely redone. They kept all the original crown molding, the big doors, the 10-foot ceilings and all the wonderful details, but they opened it up.”

On the second floor, the primary suite is spacious enough for a king-size bed and a couch for some relaxing reading time. The bedroom also features a decorative fireplace and hardwood floors that run throughout the second floor.

Next to a walk-in closet is a bathroom with a vintage soaking tub, a separate shower and a large vanity with a wide sink.

Down the hall is a second bedroom with a larger decorative fireplace. A family bathroom off the hall has a walk-in shower and subway tile and there is a bonus room currently being used as a walk-in closet.

A third-floor bedroom is illuminated by two dormer windows and leads to another room that could become a home office or reading nook.

Advertise with us

The roof was replaced last year and the furnace is new. There is also central air-conditioning,

Pashman is especially proud of the window coverings, which were chosen to reflect the home’s blend of modern and historic decor.

“For instance, in our kitchen, we have these beautiful draperies that are sewn together ... in a patchwork. It’s not going to be everybody's taste. I love the fabric.... If somebody wanted it, we would leave it,” she said.

The 2026 Allegheny County assessment is $311,200 and the annual taxes are $7,699. Over the last five years, this is the only house to sell in the 400 block of Pressley Street, for $518,500 in December 2021. Two houses sold in the 500 block for $335,000 in July 2022 and $480,000 in October 2024 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us)

The house is within walking distance of Downtown and the two stadiums on the North Shore. It’s a short walk or bike ride over to the Strip District, where you will find Pashman’s favorite coffee shop, De Fer Coffee & Tea, and lots of shopping and restaurants. There is easy access to I-279 and I-376.

Advertise with us

“I hope that somebody buys the house that really appreciates the house, that appreciates the aesthetics of it,” she said.

“It would be for someone who has a design aesthetic as opposed to ‘I just want a location.’ It’s very specific. We’re here with two other historic houses, this little pod of ours. It’s a nice little neighborhood.”