“Are you sure you know what you're doing?” Judy Holden’s mother asked when she walked into the home that Judy and her husband, Kevin, had just bought in Fox Chapel.

It was 2001 and the interior of 700 W. Waldheim Road was filled with white dentil molding and wallpaper of various designs, including pink roses set in a gray diamond pattern and cream-colored damask.

“It was very Colonial, which did not fit the original style of the house,” Judy said.

They weren’t sure what architectural style it was, but they liked it.

Advertise with us

“It’s not completely an English cottage. We think it most closely resembles the Cotswolds,” a region in south central England filled with homes of golden limestone.

The Holdens loved the bones of the 1925 home designed by architect Lamont Button, including rustic fireplaces, hardwood floors and a Prohibition-era bar hidden behind a bookcase in the family room.

Outside, they were charmed by the stone garden beds, pond and fountain that they later found out were designed by landscape architect Ezra Stiles. And how about that winding brick staircase in back that leads to one of four bedrooms?

“I could envision our son going up that staircase,” Judy said.

Armed with the original blueprints left by the previous owners, the Holdens have spent the last 25 years restoring the home while also renovating it to fit their family’s wants and needs.

Advertise with us

“Every nook and cranny of this house is us,” she said.

The Holdens weren’t planning on selling, but eight years ago, they started on another project. They moved an old barn from Old Mill Road to a piece of land near Hartwood Acres and began renovating it as a weekend getaway. With the renovations complete, Judy recently asked her husband, “What if we don’t go home?” It’s been their permanent residence ever since.

So now the four-bedroom, 3½-bath house on 1.6 acres in Fox Chapel is listed for $1.35 million (MLS No. 1723929) with Jill Chapman of Howard Hanna Real Estate (howardhanna.com or 412-445-6104). It’s currently under contract.

The house is filled with decorative touches, some original.

Not long after they bought the home, while Kevin was away on a business trip, Judy removed the white fireplace mantel and pink marble hearth in the dining room to find a mostly intact original brick fireplace underneath. They hired a stone mason to restore the broken brick and commissioned a blacksmith to create a wrought-iron mantelpiece that matches the original staircase railing in the hall.

Advertise with us

During another business trip, Judy removed thick white trim in the dining room to uncover original square black tiles lining the base of each of the windows.

“No one knows what type of tile it is,” she said. “It isn’t porcelain or ceramic and it’s impossible to match.”

In addition to the hidden bar, the family room features an original beamed ceiling, one of the home’s two gas log fireplaces and two original round windows.

Sunset brings an orange glow to the windows, Judy said.

“It’s very pretty. You think there’s a light on, but there isn’t.”

Advertise with us

The family room was a favorite for the couple and their son, Caldwell.

“In the winter, we lived in the family room and in the summer, we lived out on the patio,” said Judy.

The Holdens enlarged the back patio, added a stone fireplace and built a second garage underneath. They also knocked down the wall between the kitchen and original dining room to make a large eat-in kitchen.

“Judy was hellbent on making the cabinets look like they had been here since 1925,” said Kevin.

Apparently she was successful. Shortly after the custom-made cabinets were installed, a visitor asked how long they had been there, assuming they were original.

Advertise with us

“About three months,” Judy replied.

She hand-selected the stones for the kitchen floor from Fox Chapel Stone on Old Freeport Road and loves the soapstone countertops they chose together.

“They’re the most striking thing in here,” Kevin said.

Upstairs, the master bedroom leads to a second-story porch that was stabilized to become “an actual, walkable porch.”

Judy said the house stays cool in the summer because of the stone exterior.

Advertise with us

“It’s so insulated we’ve never done air conditioning,” she said.

The property’s 2026 assessment is $382,000 and annual taxes are $12,555. Over the last six years, nine houses have sold in the Fox Chapel section of West Waldheim Road for prices ranging from $650,000 in February 2020 to $1.8 million in May 2024 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us).

The Holdens have also worked on the yard. Judy removed a fence that enclosed the garden beds and placed the stones the way that Stiles had originally arranged them.

They have planted or tended close to 100 native wildflower species, including trillium, Virginia bluebells, Solomon’s seal, hellebore and wild columbine. Kevin likes to go for walks on the trails they have made and jots down the flowers he spots in a notebook. His favorite is the trout lily.

“It’s not ostentatious,” he said. “You have to look for it.”

Advertise with us

He counts four distinct phases of blooms from April through June, but one month is the most prolific.

“May is the most incredible time for the wildflowers,” he said.

Correction, updated April 17, 2026: An earlier version of this story did not include all of the property sales over the last six years in the Fox Chapel part of West Waldheim Road.