The Tudor-style house at 4430 Brownsville Road in Whitehall has been the mayor’s house — twice.
Jim Nowalk, the borough’s current mayor, is the eldest son of Teresa and Francis J. Nowalk. He grew up in a family of six children and is very proud of the home his father created.
“My parents moved into the house in my first year at college, Notre Dame,” he said. “It was home to John Malady, the first mayor of Whitehall.”
Nowalk’s father, the late owner of Nowalk Lighting, had big ideas when he moved in. He had worked inside the homes of wealthy members of Pittsburgh’s elite: Penguins star center Mario Lemieux, Pittsburgh Mayor Richard S. Caliguiri and Steelers owner Art Rooney. He had also created lighting for Rodef Shalom Congregation, the Duquesne Club and St. Paul's Cathedral in Oakland.
The senior Nowalk absorbed the interior design styles of what he saw and incorporated it into the family home. Not only did the home feature his life’s work, unique chandeliers and lighting that is found in just about every room, but also other design ideas he liked.
“When he was redoing his own home, he wanted it to be the best it could be,” said Nowalk, and that started with the garage. “What we knew as the family room was actually the garage.”
It’s now a large room with hardwood floors and a wet bar tucked into a wall of built-in cabinetry. A pocket door leads to the grand foyer, with bookcases and storage for board games.
“We spent many, many wonderful family events in that room,” Nowalk recalled.
Now the four-bedroom, 2½-bath home is on the market for $659,900, listed with Susie Cancelliere of Coldwell Banker Reality (coldwellbanker.com or 412-226-8570).
The house was built in 1922 and the Nowalks bought it in 1971. It has 2,909 square feet of living space and a two-car garage with a storage area above.
Outside amenities include a covered front porch, large front and backyards with mature trees and a pastoral view of the fairways of South Hills Country Club.
For help on the interior, the elder Nowalk turned to renowned Pittsburgh interior designer, Louis J. Talotta.
“Both of them were pursuing excellence,” said his son.
Sometimes, excellence came at a cost.
“I can remember when I was in law school. My father was a perfectionist. He decided he wanted a higher ceiling.”
To lower the floor, workers used jackhammers, sometimes early in the morning, and the law student lost some sleep, he said.
Original hardwood flooring is found throughout the house, including the living room, which has a commanding fireplace.
The dining room with two built-in corner cabinets. Both of these rooms include original leaded and stained-glass windows. The diamond designs of the windows are garnished with insets of colored shields.
The kitchen can be accessed from the family room, dining room, or the main foyer. The main kitchen area is U-shaped with both upper and lower cabinets wrapping around. Appliances include a double oven, countertop range, dishwasher and French-door refrigerator. A breakfast nook with even more storage sits off to one side of the main area with large windows and a door leading to the rear patio.
One major renovation involved the creation of the primary bedroom. Originally, the main bedroom was located at the front of the house. There were two bedrooms on one side of the hallway, with a third bedroom on the other side. If you turned left at the top of the stairs, there was a door to a rather unique room.
“Straight ahead was a door that took you into this room that had a slanted ceiling, and it was on the smaller side – you could touch the ceiling,” explained Nowalk.
His father had the door closed and went on to create a primary bedroom suite.
Four pairs of French doors lead to Juliet balconies, opening the room to a view of what at first appears to be the countryside but is actually greens of South Hills Country Club.
“When we were kids, when we cut the grass, every once in a while a ball would come over,” recalled Nowalk, “Haven’t seen any in recent years.”
The walk-in closet in the primary suite is also special. It is a dressing room with a place for everything.
The adjacent bathroom features ornate sconces, a large mirror framed in gold and a sink where cherubs frolic. A large towel warmer means a ready supply of toasty towels. There is both a walk-in shower and a soaking tub.
Both the bedroom and the ensuite enjoy cathedral ceilings, making this “wing” of the home a perfect parent’s hideaway.
The 2026 Allegheny County property assessment is $240,500 and annual taxes are $8,832. Over the last three years, one house has sold in the 4400 block of Brownsville Road, for $293,000 in September 2025. (realestate.alleghenycounty.us)




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.