If the walls of this Clinton Township farmhouse could talk, they might be whispering sweet nothings.

During one of several renovations at 121 Brewer Road, love letters were found hidden in the walls that offer a voyeur’s glimpse into the private life of one of its earliest inhabitants — Ida Maizland.

"They were written to Ida, the daughter of the original farm owner, by her suitor, W.J. [Harbison],” said Kristan Allen.

Kristan and her husband, Andy, are the current owners of the property, a generational Butler County farm near Saxonburg known as Duncancroft Stables.

Advertise with us

Harbison was writing to Ida from the Pierce Hotel in Wichita, Kan., in 1890-92. Though his handwriting is sometimes hard to make out, his feelings are not:

“1,600 miles from home and I often think of home and you and will never forget,” he wrote. “I'm longing to hear from you.”

William J. Harbison, who was born in Middlesex in 1868, did eventually return and marry his sweetheart in January 1893, according to “History of Butler County Pennsylvania, 1895”. They had four children.

The Allens believe Ida hid the letters in the walls of her parents’ home when she moved to live with her new husband, believing they would never again see the light of day.

Instead, they are framed and hanging on the walls of the house, which was recently used as an Airbnb.

Advertise with us

The love letters will remain with the house, which is now for sale along with 147 nearly flat acres of land and several barns and outbuildings for $4.2 million (MLS No. 1740283).

“Knowing the love letters were found in the walls of the house, it felt only right to keep them here,” said Mrs. Allen.

Elaine Shetler-Libent of Keller Williams Pittsburgh South is the listing agent (horseproperties.net or 724-681-0412).

The original red farmhouse built in 1900 features five bedrooms, three full bathrooms and four fireplaces, two made from stacked stone.

“The living room has two of the fireplaces and it is what I love about the house — one on each side,” Mrs. Allen said. “The living room is spanned by the covered front porch that overlooks some of the pastures, which is really cool.”

Advertise with us

The house has undergone at least two or three major renovations over the decades and now sports a country-meets-mountain-modern interior.

“The house has seen many generations and this is going to sound corny, but you can feel that it has been built on love and built on connection and legacy,” she said.

The country estate is an equestrian's paradise, with 16 fenced pastures, an 80-by-160-foot indoor riding arena that opens on all four sides and a fenced-in outdoor arena.

“We did all new footing and LED lighting and painting for the indoor arena,” said Mrs. Allen. “It offers versatility as far as riding year-round.”

The indoor arena is characterized by a full wall of mirrors, perhaps for checking out how tall you sit in the saddle. It’s mostly used for precision work with rider and mount, Mrs. Allen said.

Advertise with us

The previous owners lived there for more than 70 years, raising horses and their families.

“It has been stewarded since its inception by families who have a love for the land,” she said.

The well-preserved 100-year-old bank barn, complete with its original floors, is evidence of that.

“I call it the party barn because we had a few parties in there,” Mrs. Allen remembered fondly.

The bank barn is built into the side of the hill and holds 12 stalls underneath. Located next to that barn is the main horse barn, which features 20 stalls, a manager's office and living quarters. In all, the property contains 32 stalls of varying sizes, including four foaling stalls.

Advertise with us

The well-ventilated stables offer plenty of natural light for the animals and their human caretakers.

After going through the paces with your pony, head to the 3.75-acre lake or a half-acre pond filled with bass, bluegill and catfish.

The Allens live next door at Armstrong Farms. They bought the property in 2024 to keep it out of the hands of developers.

“A lot of farms were being bought up by developers and being turned into multihome tracts and we really didn't want to see that happen to this beautiful piece of property,” she explained.

The Allens are determined to keep the land intact. Under their stewardship, it became part of Butler County’s Farmland Preservation Program, which prevents it from being turned into a housing development.

Advertise with us

“Selling is very bittersweet for us because it is such a beautiful place and one built for a family to congregate and be together,” said Mrs. Allen. “The whole place is just infused with warmth and feels instantly comfortable.

“We want someone who can enjoy this property to its full potential.”