When Paige Mitzen’s 11-year-old daughter experiences something challenging, Mitzen reminds her: “Nothing good, true and beautiful comes easy.”

She reminded herself of that often over the five years it took for Day3Design, the company she shares with her dad, Rich Hetland, and their business partner, Matt Barnett, to complete the renovation of Downtown’s Maginn Lofts at 915 Liberty Ave.

“I’m not going to sugarcoat it,” she said. “The City of Pittsburgh doesn’t make it easy for small developers to renovate historic buildings like the Maginn. There’s a lot of red tape.”

The company also ran into shipping delays and increased costs related to the COVID-19 pandemic, plus Mitzen got married and had two babies during the project.

Advertise with us

“Just to add more chaos to my crazy life,” she said.

Built in 1891, the Maginn Building was designed by Charles Bickel in the Richardsonian Romanesque style and housed many businesses over its 128-year history, including a wholesale confectioner and fruit warehouse, a rubber company, a liquor wholesaler, a piano company, a flower shop and, most recently, Specialty Luggage.

Aiming to preserve the building the best they could, Day3Design converted it into seven 2,400-square-foot luxury condominiums — one on each floor — plus a retail space on the first floor next to the lobby.

Units 201 and 301 and the first-floor retail space have sold. Unit 401 is under contract.

There are four other condos for sale including the penthouse, Unit 801, which is listed for $1.395 million (MLS No. 1675914) with Denise Bortolotti of Piatt Sotheby’s International Realty (sothebysrealty.com or 412-515-7199).

Advertise with us

The three-bedroom, two-bath penthouse offers 2,400 square feet of living space on the eighth floor. The HOA fee is $768 per month and covers sewage, trash, building maintenance and building insurance. Parking is not included.

The new condo has not been assessed yet, but the 2026 assessment of a similar-sized unit on the second floor is $469,400. Annual taxes are $2,606, and there is a 10-year tax abatement.

Over the last year, two condos have sold at 915 Liberty Ave. for $750,000 in September 2025 and $883,000 in October 2025 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us).

A private elevator provides access to each condo via a key fob and opens directly into the kitchen. Mitzen hand-selected the light fixtures, cabinets, hardware, faucets and even the floor-mount doorstops for each unit. All kitchens have quartz countertops and JennAir appliances.

“We imported a lot of the materials,” she said. “The wainscoting is from Italy and the kitchen cabinetry is from Germany.”

Advertise with us

The fire extinguisher in each kitchen is encased in a custom-made brass cabinet.

“We spared no expense on those,” she said.

In the penthouse, Mitzen opted for gray kitchen cabinets with brass hardware and crystal cabinet pulls. Three brass globe pendant lights with frosted glass shades hang above an island that seats five.

The kitchen opens to a living area with exposed-brick walls and original beams that frame a wall of windows offering an unobstructed view straight down Seventh Avenue to PPG Paints Arena.

Since it’s on the eighth floor and sits above surrounding buildings, the unit is filled with natural light. All three bedrooms, the two bathrooms and the laundry room are located in its back wing.

Advertise with us

Despite the challenges Day3Design encountered while renovating the building, Mitzen said she loves the result.

“The people who are buying the condos are the people who I hoped would buy them — people who care about the details and want a home with character.”

The first owners to move into the building were Shea Agnew and his husband, Matheus De Souza Trindade. They lived in Fiji, Portugal and Brazil before buying Unit 301.

Agnew, vice president of a communications agency in Washington, D.C., grew up in Conneaut Lake in Crawford County but has spent much of his adult life away from Western Pennsylvania. De Souza Trindade, a software engineer, grew up in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. When he started looking for jobs in the United States, the couple considered living in Washington D.C., New York City or Miami.

“Matheus preferred Pittsburgh to all of those other cities because he thought it was more real,” said Agnew. “He liked the changing seasons and the fact that Pittsburgh was more gritty and unpretentious.”

Advertise with us

The chance to live closer to Agnew’s family was also a draw.

“Matheus is my mom’s favorite child,” Agnew said.

When De Souza Trindade was offered a job with Innovative Systems in Green Tree, it seemed like the perfect next step.

Agnew said they looked at other condos Downtown and in the Strip District as well as a few South Side townhomes, but they were “pretty cookie-cutter with a lot of millennial gray.”

“We fell in love with the Maginn. It just bleeds character,” Agnew said, noting the condo’s premium finishes, selected by Mitzen.

Advertise with us

“She’s a visionary,” he said.

The Maginn “checked all of the boxes,” Agnew said.

Those boxes included space for entertaining and a walkable neighborhood. Since moving into their home in November, Agnew estimates that they walk to 75% of their destinations and Uber the remaining 25% of the time.

They love walking to the Strip District to shop at Wholey’s, Reyna Foods and Pennsylvania Macaroni Co. Agnew said they also like the Strip District Terminal and walked to PPG Paints Arena for their first hockey game this past December.

Agnew said that the coordinated $600 million, 10-year plan to revitalize Downtown was a big reason why the couple decided to purchase a Downtown condo when they did.

“We knew it would be an investment,” he said.