When Charles and Marcia Deaktor bought an eight-bedroom home at 5238 Ellsworth Ave. in 1985, the empty nesters looked forward to opening their Shadyside home to family and friends.

“My parents were into entertaining,” said their son, Scott Deaktor. “I enjoyed watching them plan every event they hosted at the house. Every time they discussed the guest list and what food to serve, they acted like what they decided on was new and adventurous. But it really was pretty much the same people and the same menu every time.”

Scott and his wife, Marsha, always made the list, along with his parents’ eclectic group of friends.

“My dad prided himself on having friends from all walks of life,” he said.

Advertise with us

As president of Rodef Shalom Congregation and chairman of Deaktor/Sysco Food Service, Charles also hosted dinners for dignitaries and executives.

The menu usually included roast beef or salmon, green beans and burnt almond torte from Prantl’s.

Those meals took place in the 21- by 24-foot dining room at the back of the house. In the early 1990s, the couple converted a dining room window into a doorway, which led to an addition that included a 21- by 13-foot sitting room, a 31- by 19-foot eat-in kitchen and a 56- by 20-foot porch. The sitting room features a vaulted ceiling with wood beams and two rows of skylights.

The exterior wall of the addition is made up almost entirely of windows, plus glass doors that lead out to the porch. In the basement of the addition, the Deaktors added a 50- by 20-foot heated lap pool that was primarily used by Charles.

“My dad and I would go and sit by the pool and talk,” Scott said. “He and I were close. In fact, when I got married, I could think of no one I’d rather have as my best man but him.”

Advertise with us

Charles passed away suddenly in 1995 from a health condition while in Phoenix, Ariz., for a business meeting. After Marcia died in August 2025, Scott made the decision to sell the home.

The eight-bedroom house with four full bathrooms, four powder rooms and 7,556 square feet of living space is listed for $5.3 million (MLS No. 1714670) with Roslyn Neiman of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services (howardhanna.com or 412-889-5488). The sale also includes an adjacent 0.9-acre lot containing a one-bedroom, one-bath carriage house.

Built in 1920, the house retains many of its original features, including an expansive front porch, slate roof, front and side staircases with hand-turned spindles, six fireplaces, leaded-glass windows, hardwood floors and ornate crown molding and trim throughout.

Scott said that his mother stripped some of the woodwork that had been painted by a previous owner.

“She was a believer in restoring the natural wood,” he said.

Advertise with us

Marcia, a real estate investor and art collector, once hosted an art show in the home. Her favorite place was a garden she tended on the side lot that was recently removed.

Charles was an avid reader and spent a lot of time in the home’s library, which features built-in bookcases, dark-stained paneling and a fireplace. Across the hall is a formal parlor where the home’s original owners would receive guests.

Another remnant of the property’s past is a 10- by 6-foot wine cellar in the basement that has a heavy safe door with a large wheel handle that still locks. It’s hidden by a white wooden door that matches other doors in the basement.

“We think this is where the owners hid their alcohol during Prohibition,” said Scott.

The basement also has two workshop spaces and accesses the two-car garage.

Advertise with us

There are four bedrooms on the second floor and four bedrooms on the third floor.

The property’s 2026 Allegheny County assessment is $725,000 and annual taxes are $17,936. Over the last three years, one house has sold in the 5200 block of Ellsworth Avenue for $895,000 in June 2024 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us).

The property is less than a mile from shops and restaurants on Walnut Street, and the Deaktors enjoyed walking there together. Other notable spots within walking distance include Winchester Thurston School, Rodef Shalom Congregation, UPMC Shadyside, Carnegie Museum of Art and Natural History, Carnegie Mellon University and University of Pittsburgh.

“My parents were so happy to live in this house,” said Scott. “They loved the house and they loved the neighborhood.”