Many former houses of worship on Pittsburgh’s South Side have been turned into condominiums.
While the developers, architects and condo owners have embraced the buildings’ past, they have also introduced modern amenities that the original builders could only have dreamed of in a neighborhood that is home to many historic buildings and a booming nighttime social scene.
Condos are now on the market at the former St. Casimir Catholic Church on Sarah Street near South 22nd Street, St. Michael's Roman Catholic Church on Pius Street and St. Adalbert's auditorium on South 15th Street.
Dr. Dennis Monks is a Pittsburgh boomaranger who grew up in the South Hills, attended the University of Pittsburgh Medical School, then went off to New York City for his residency. He returned in 2019 and bought a piece of Pittsburgh history at the 22nd Street Condos, formerly St. Casimir Catholic Church.
“I lived in New York City for quite a while and in New York anywhere near this price point you’re living in a drywall box,” Monks said.
In Pittsburgh, he found what in New York would be considered the bargain of the century: a two-bedroom condo with an integral garage and amazing views in every direction.
Six years later, he has put unit 207 at 2132 Sarah St. (MLS No. 1724452), with two bedrooms, 1½ baths, a choir loft and its own bell tower, on the market for $875,000 with Sara Leitera of Berkshire Hathaway Home Services (thepreferredrealty.com or 412-521-5100). The monthly HOA fee is $853.
“It’s so unique. My living area has an arched ceiling — you don’t find that these days. Not even my style to have this ornate plaster but it’s so historical. It drew me to it the second I saw it in 2019,” he recalled.
Unlike most new builds, churches are unique structures in many ways, especially their soaring ceilings and towering columns. So when developers come in to rebuild them with the purpose of creating individual units, they had quite the puzzle on their hands. Sometimes that included going deep to accommodate a parking garage.
“The developer dug out below the church and created the garage. When they dug it out, there was a lot of broken glass bottles,” Monks said, noting that the site was home to a glass factory prior to being a church.
“We all have a heated parking space, and the elevator goes all the way down to the garage, he said. “That’s very convenient for shopping.”
A few months after Monks moved into his new condo, he had an EV charger installed for his parking space and that is included in the sale.
The Auditorium
Like the the 22nd Street Condos, the condominiums in what was the St. Adalbert auditorium also have an integral garage.
While not a church, the auditorium and social hall built in 1958 for St. Adalbert’s diamond jubilee became the center of the Polish Catholic community, hosting sports events, plays and dances. During the Cold War, the lower level of what is now the condominiums served as a nuclear fallout shelter, according to the The Auditorium website.
“Of the amenities, I think the gym and the rooftop deck are the ones that speak to people the most,” said Savannah Saccucci, a Piatt Sotheby’s International Realty agent who is handling the two-bedroom, two-bathroom condominium at 150 S. 15th St. (sothebysrealty.com or 412-387-6886). It is listed for $425,000 and has a monthly HOA fee of $438.
“The integral garage, I know it’s not exactly an amenity but still [it’s the South Side],” added Saccucci.
Other amenities include a dog bath, a miniature gym and either a green space or balcony for each unit, plus other common areas. The HOA fee varies with each condominium.
Angel’s Arms
At Angel’s Arms Condominiums on Pius Street, there is no integral parking, but parking is plentiful.
“We have a large surface lot at the back of the building. One level is covered with a second lot on top. That’s 26 units in the building with 52 spaces,” said Christina Stanley, the manager of Angel Arms.
Unit B1 at 1 Pius St. (MLS No.1699237) has three bedrooms and two full bathrooms spread over three floors. It’s listed for $485,000 with Kefalos & Associates Real Estate (kefalosandassociates.com or 412-334-3485). The HOA fees are $440 per month.
The condo features a wood-burning fireplace, a steam shower and a private lower-level suite with a full bath, jetted tub — and the original church safe.
Building amenities include access to the courtyard, which is original to the church and rectory, and 20 storage units, with plans to add more storage. There is a rooftop deck with great views, especially for Fourth of July fireworks.
“Right now it’s unfurnished but we just put a new roof, including decking on that section,” said Stanley, “We haven’t bought any new furniture yet, but we are in the spring.”
While the South Side is considered one of the most walkable neighborhoods in the city, parking is still important.
“It’s nice to have a garage but as far as my day-to-day activities, I can walk to Giant Eagle, I can walk to Aldi’s,” said Monks, the owner of the 22nd Street Condos unit.
“I can walk to 10 different coffee shops and tons of restaraunts,” he said.
There is a fitness center, secure entry, storage units and indoor bicycle storage in the building. One unique amenity is the onsite guest suite with a living area, kitchen, dining area, separate bedroom and a full bathroom.
“We have a gym and a guest apartment on the first floor that you can use for visitors and there’s no cost as it’s through the HOA,” Monks explained. “You just sign up on our app and you can have friends stay, which is really nice.”
In many church conversions, architectural details are a big attraction.
“I would say the ceilings are the number one thing,” said Leitera, the agent for the 22nd Street Condos unit. “People love high ceilings and these soar above you.
“In churches in general, you have the wide-open floor plan, good for entertaining, and also cosy little spaces with really beautiful architecture.”
Leitera said most South Side condos have a parking garage or a lot, and a community space, whether it’s a bike rack or a little outdoor space.
“From what I find, for condo buyers, it’s really more about what you’re getting in the condo itself,” she said.
These conversions invoke a certain feeling that doesn’t come with a new build. Monks stated it well.
“I love the living space, the rounded ceiling with all the plaster. It makes me smile every time I walk in and see it.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.