When Sue McMillen bought a multiuse building in Polish Hill, it had what she refers to as “sommer windows.”
“Some windows were there, and some were not,” she said, laughing.
According to the original blueprints, the building was built in the early 1900s by “Mrs. Rose Hartnett.” The first owners ran a business on the first floor and lived on the second and third floors.
McMillen was familiar with the property at 3567 Bigelow Blvd. because her business partners had been renting it. They used the recording studio to produce commercials, rerecord music and conduct photo shoots. McMillen had some previous construction experience from managing rental properties, so she bought the property in 2011 for $150,000 with the intention of turning it into an event space.
After six years of renovations, followed by seven years of living there while renting it out for events, McMillen is ready to sell.
The 14,500-square-foot space includes four bedrooms, four bathrooms, three powder rooms and a three-bedroom, one-bath apartment, plus recording and photography studios, a rooftop deck and a two-car garage with additional parking available in the adjacent parking lot. It’s listed for $1.6 million (MLS No. 1719339) with Donna Tidwell of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices (thepreferredrealty.com or 724-244-0470).
During the extensive renovation process, McMillen and her team replaced all of the windows, cut through concrete block to put in two staircases and a double-sided elevator, installed new HVAC and sprinkler systems, updated the wiring and poured a new concrete floor. They also constructed three new rooms above and below one of the new staircases.
“Anything we could keep that was original to the building, we did,” she said.
In the 2,500-square-foot main room on the first floor, that meant sandblasting the brick walls “several times” to restore them. She replaced glass-block windows in that room with doubled-paned, insulated windows that let in more natural light and offer views of Polish Hill, Bloomfield and the Strip District.
“No one saw that view until we replaced the windows,” McMillen said.
From the room’s 17-foot ceilings hang three pendant chandeliers that were original to a Downtown bank. They were then painted black and used in the former Strip District nightclub Metropol. The fixtures were being stored in the building when McMillen bought it. She had the black paint removed to reveal the original brass, copper and milk glass and hung them up.
“They just kind of go in that room,” she said. “They’re a piece of history.”
A number of weddings have been held at the building. Some of the couples chose to have their ceremony in the main room, while others opted for the 70-by-25-foot rooftop deck and adjoining bar area on the third floor.
“It’s everyone’s favorite spot,” said McMillen.”My granddaughter got married on the deck and then served cocktails inside at the bar.”
On a clear day, the rooftop deck offers a 280-degree view that spans from the Bloomfield Bridge to Downtown. Some notable landmarks that can be easily spotted include West Penn Hospital in Bloomfield, Children’s Hospital and the Church Brew Works in Lawrenceville, Acrisure Stadium on the North Shore and PPG Place Downtown. There are also lots of trees and lush hillsides, plus unobstructed sky views.
“Once, during a Fourth of July party, we saw 21 different fireworks displays,” she said.
The second floor features a 96-by-25-foot room with an original non-working fireplace.
“That room holds a special place in my heart,” said McMillen.
She said she likes how the ceiling tapers toward the view out the back window.
There’s also an office on that level and two side-by-side bathrooms that could be converted into one large one.
The three-bedroom apartment is on a floor below the first floor and includes a kitchen, living room, dining room, family room and laundry, plus a studio with a cyclorama wall and recording studio.
There are two levels below the sub-floor apartment which McMillen uses for storage.
The property’s 2025 Allegheny County assessment is $674,900 and annual taxes are $15,900. The building next door sold for $425,000 in 2020 and a triplex in the same block sold for $270,000 in February 2024 (realestate.alleghenycounty.us)
The property is currently zoned commercial-office and warehouse.
Tidwell, the agent, said that McMillen “did the expensive things” to make the building livable.
“Now just the design work is left,” she said.
“We built it out for our needs,” said McMillen. “But the infrastructure is all there for someone to come and really make this place their own.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.