There’s an old saying, “When life gives you lemons, make lemonade.” But what if the lemon is an 1875 brick house in terrible shape?

Kathy and Paul Palicki were hoping to preserve many original elements of the house at 626 Suismon St. in the North Side’s Deutschtown neighborhood — until they dug into it.

“We realized as we peeled back the layers that it was so old that there was very little holding that baby together,” said Mrs. Palicki. “It was the paint holding the bricks in place.”

They then transitioned from a historical renovation project to a major reconstruction of the house, located just a few doors down from their own home. The couple had wanted a place where their large extended family, including two grown sons, could stay rather than having them scattered around town when they visited — and something they could rent in the meantime.

Advertise with us

So the couple pivoted and, with the help of neighbors, they turned the 2½-story brick house into a “virtually” brand new home.

“We leaned heavily into neighbors for references,” Mrs. Palicki said. “Our wonderful neighbor, architect Bob Baumbach, was a big help.”

“We didn’t have a primary contractor and pretty much used a bunch of contractors and did a lot of the work ourselves,” her husband added.

“We spent a lot of time, just the two of us, peeling back layers of carpeting to find linoleum, to find old newspapers,” Mrs. Palicki said. “I have funny pictures of just the two of us, in the thick of things, covered in coal dust.”

They found fireplaces full of corn cobs and filled many dumpsters with “our hot little hands.”

Advertise with us

Now they’re turning their hands to a new project, in Friendship, and have priced this two-bedroom, 2½-bath house (MLS No. 1704619) at $550,000 with Heather and Ryan Edmondson of Keller Williams Realty (ergpgh.com or 412-370-1815‬). The sale includes three parcels: the home and a side yard  as well as a rear lot (905 East St.).

While the couple missed the opportunity to restore the much-desired features of an older home, they instead reaped the benefits of adding modern improvements such as new Marvin windows, Moen plumbing fixtures and solid oak flooring throughout the home. The plumbing, electrical and dual zone HVAC systems are all new, along with spray foam insulation and a new roof.

The first floor has an open plan with a spacious kitchen (19 by nearly 17 feet), living room (16 by 13½ feet) and a powder room.

The living room boasts two large windows and the kitchen sports two even larger windows next to French doors leading to the rear patio. Tucked-away window shades offer privacy when needed, including at the front door.

Samsung kitchen appliances were installed during the renovation and are characterized as virtually new due to light use. The large kitchen island seats four, and storage shouldn’t be an issue with cabinets that extend to the ceiling.

Advertise with us

While the couple worked with an architect, they chose many of the details, especially in the bathrooms.

“When it came to the bathrooms, it was Kathy who took the reins,” Mr. Palicki said.

Most of the second floor is taken up by the primary bedroom, which measures 12½ by 15 feet and has a walk-through closet leading to a sleekly designed bathroom with subway tiles that wrap around a walk-in shower with a frameless glass door.

“It’s always a balance with trends that are timeless, but not too trendy,’ Mrs. Palicki said.

The other full bathroom on the second floor features the same subway tile around a walk-in shower. This floor is more whimsical with black-and-white geometric tiles.

Advertise with us

Mr. Palicki noted that his wife also made design decisions in the kitchen. “I grew up working for my dad in a tile shop, and having this kind of fun style is interesting for both of us,” he said.

The nearly 370-square-foot third floor is a large bedroom with built-ins and two large windows set into alcoves created by dormers on either side of the room.

The 2025 property assessment is $144,500 and annual taxes are $1,258. Over the last four years, four homes have sold in the 600 block of Suismon Street for prices ranging from $182,000 for this one in December 2021 to $654,000 in December 2023. (realestate.alleghenycounty.us).

Rebuilding an older home with modern features while trying to blend it into a historic neighborhood took lots of time, work and patience. The couple had previously lived in the North Hills, going from 4 acres to having a much smaller house with a lot of work to be done.

“We worked both outside and inside until we got to a point. We don’t plumb, we don’t do electric or any of that so we hired people to do all of that,” Mrs. Palicki explained. “The deconstruction — whatever could be done with a hammer or a crowbar, without removing a structural wall — we did.”

Advertise with us

She is also an avid gardener. “I loved the fact that we bought a house with a triple lot, so I had a ton of yard work to do, which I love.”

The Palickis also invested their time into the community. They volunteer at Pittsburgh King PreK-8 in the Reading is Fundamental program. They shop at the farmers market at Allegheny Commons and know where to grab a good cup of coffee. They have become a part of that community, which is reflected by the photographs and artwork found on the wall of this house.

“Paul and I have been married 35 years, and we’ve lived in a lot of places,” she said. “But this area has the strongest sense of community of anywhere we’ve ever lived.”

An open house is scheduled for Sunday, August 17, 2025, noon to 2 p.m.

Lizaabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com