Opportunity sometimes strikes at the oddest of times. For Scott McKee, it came when he was walking his dog and happened to see a sign for a sheriff’s sale in front of a large old home on North Washington Street in Butler.
His wife Jackie, a child and family therapist, was renting her office and looking for something with more space to buy or lease.
“I was in Colorado, taking our son to grad school, and he sent me a text,” she said.
They bought the early 1900s building in 2013. Her husband led the charge as the couple spent the next year resurrecting the shabby, rundown house into four office suites with a full kitchen, a waiting room and an apartment on the second floor.
Sadly, Scott passed away in September 2016 and now, after 12 years of ownership, Jackie is ready to sell the building.
“This was his baby. It’s a precious gift, and I would not be selling it, but I’ve retired and want to move closer to my kids in Washington, D.C.,” she said.
The mixed-use building at 128 N. Washington St. in Butler is listed for $259,900 (MLS No. 1663455) with Melissa Vaughan of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices’ Cranberry office (thepreferredrealty.com or 724-553-0885). It features four bedrooms and 1½ bathrooms and is zoned both residential and commercial.
The exterior of the house, which boasts original trim and railings and a covered front porch, recently got new coats of blue and white with highlights of burgundy.
McKee’s first impression of the interior was “fairly horrendous” — peach and mauve carpeting and 1970s decor at its finest. Fortunately, she and her husband found a father-and-son contracting team who took on the year-long project and brought the interior into the 21st century.
One of the first challenges was the original hardwood flooring that runs throughout the first floor.
“There were a couple of holes that had been cut in the wood flooring and I was like, ‘That’s horrible,’” she recalled.
“[The son] said, ‘Don’t worry, I’ll take care of it.’ I’m telling you, you cannot see where there were holes and he replaced them.”
The electrical system was another big issue.
“Our insurance would not cover it until all the knob and tube was removed and disconnected,” she said. “We had an electrical contractor we had worked with in our home that rewired and pulled all the knob and tube out.”
Next was the plumbing. They gutted the first-floor bathroom, replumbed and rewired it.
McKee said she was in charge of the decor and color selection, with some encouragement from her contractor.
“The son really had good taste. ... He was the one who encouraged me to go with the bolder colors — the blue in the waiting room, the red in the bathroom. He said you need to do this in a larger building.”
They didn’t always agree.
“The challenge for me in that bathroom is when the contractor chose the wood cabinet. I said it should be white,” she said.
But McKee finally agreed to go with dark wood.
“I was so happy when I went with his suggestion on that. I was like, ‘That did it.’ … He was absolutely fantastic.”
She suggested adding wood shutters to provide privacy, giving the rooms another layer of design and making them feel less like commercial spaces.
The office suites are on the first and second floors. All but one are serviced by a central air-conditioning unit installed in 2013. One office suite on the second floor has its own ductless heating and air conditioning unit.
On the first floor, there is a three-room office suite, waiting room, bathroom and full kitchen that is shared by all the office tenants. McKee’s private office is also on the first floor.
“When I started to retire, I took the two back rooms. I call that the back office suite,” she said.
There is also a two-room office suite on the second floor at the front of the house. Currently, the majority of the office space is rented.
“The one tenant has been with me for almost a year, and the other two for a few years,” McKee said. “I would hope whoever buys the property would give them adequate notice.”
The apartment on the second floor has its entrance on the porch at the rear of the house. While the tenants have access to the front stairs, the understanding is they would only use the front entrance in an emergency.
The apartment, which has its own air-conditioning unit, includes a living room, kitchen, two bedrooms and a full bathroom with washer and dryer.
“I have had people beg me to rent that apartment,” McKee said. “It has been consistently rented since we did the renovations in 2013,”
The high ceilings in the apartment are a clue as to how the office suites on the first and second floors were created. The larger rooms were redesigned with dropped ceilings and new interior walls.
Converting the building back to a family home would involve removing the drop ceilings and temporary walls.
There are several decorative fireplaces and one office features floor-to-ceiling, built-in bookcases that flank the fireplace.
The apartment tenant gets a bit off his rent for taking care of the grounds. That includes raking the leaves dropped by the large tree at the rear of the house.
“The arborist that comes and checks in on it every couple of years says it is probably over 100 years old. So my guess is it was planted when the house was built,” McKee said.
There is room for six cars in the parking area to the side of the building and there is public and metered street parking on North Washington and West North streets.
Two miles west of town is a shopping area that includes a Giant Eagle, Lowe’s and Sam’s Club. The surrounding neighborhood is a mix of owner-operated shops, churches and family homes along with fire and police stations.
Annual taxes on the property are $3,847.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.