People in the area know the house at 1318 Perry Highway in Portersville for the most unusual of reasons. It’s the only house with a bright red British phone box by the driveway.
Not your usual amenity for a century-old brick farmhouse, but there it is, and could be yours.
The three-story house with four bedrooms, 2½ baths and a detached two-story, two-car garage is listed for $379,000 (MLS No. 1670976) with Amy Alexander and Joe Clark of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices (www.thepreferredrealtor.com or 412-417-1332).
In 1987, Tom Reiber and his wife, Kaye, were living in Perry Hilltop. With a group of friends, they had renovated an older home in Zelienople, roughly 29 miles from Pittsburgh. But they wanted a change.
“One day, I was looking through the Post-Gazette’s real estate ads and saw this property in Portersville,” said Mr. Reiber. “I didn’t even know where that was. I told Kaye this is a place we should look at.”
They went, looked, and bought the Butler County farmhouse with over 2½ acres of land.
Read More
“Character — that’s what attracted us to the Porterville house,” he said.
At the time, the house had been converted by the previous owner into two apartments. The Reibers gutted the place and discovered the original molding had been turned into furring strips as they went along. Suspended ceilings and walls were removed, drywall was installed and the house was converted back to a single-family home.
Mrs. Reiber restored the original hardwood flooring in the living room, dining room and entryway.
“The floors were not in good shape,” her husband recalled. “We had a professional come in and said they wouldn’t touch it. So my wife rented a floor sander and did it herself.”
The couple installed a kitchen on the first floor and then created the primary bedroom and a bathroom with a walk-in shower reached by a new set of stairs from the kitchen and family room. Off the hallway by the primary bedroom are steps to the attic bedroom, which has a shiplap wood ceiling.
A front staircase leads to two additional bedrooms, a bathroom with a shower-tub combination and a laundry room.
It’s not a traditional floor plan, but that is a big part of its charm. You can see the house’s history in the changes made over the years.
Finding out more about the house proved difficult because all the real estate records were destroyed in a fire long ago. There is a large wood beam across the ceiling in the kitchen that looks so original that it’s hard to believe it came in through the kitchen window, courtesy of his brother-in-law.
“My father-in-law thought it was neat to have it in there, so we brought it in through the window,” Mr. Reiber said.
He also had to figure out how to attach cabinets to very old bricks.
Another unexpected gift from his brother-in-law, who owned a commercial landscaping firm in Westmoreland County, was the red telephone box on the driveway.
“Unfortunately, it was broken in transit, so he ordered a second one. In the meantime, the architect decided to go in a different direction,” said Mr. Reiber.
Now his brother-in-law had two of them.
“Then one day, a truck showed up at the house with one of them and I had to hire a crane to get it off the truck, had to pour a concrete pad, too. We called it the time-out booth.”
Estimated annual taxes are $1,747.
A touch of charming creativity is found in many of the rooms. In the living room is a Franklin stove, a metal-lined fireplace named after Benjamin Franklin.
In the dining room is a functioning wood stove. A couple of the bedrooms feature skylights and there is exposed brick in some of the rooms.
On one side of the house is the two-car garage built in 1997. The second floor was to become a mother-in-law suite.
“We built the garage with an office in the rear of the first floor and the second floor is open space currently,” said Mr. Reiber.
The second floor walls are framed in and ductwork is in place. There is a space for a hot water tank, and the plumbing has been pressurized. Mr. Reiber will include architectural drawings showing the garage connected to the main house in the sale.
In the unfinished basement, there is a water heater that was installed in 2023, and a gas furnace and air-conditioning added in 2015. There is a septic tank that Mr. Reiber hunted down by poking a stick in the ground.
“When we went to pump the septic tank, we had no idea where it could be. So Kaye called a cousin who said it was right up from the pig pen,” he said with a chuckle. “Fortunately, there was a cement trough in the yard, so I walked around the yard with a pole until I found it.”
Portersville is near Moraine State Park, where you will find Lake Arthur and various recreational activities. The Butler County borough lies between Butler and New Castle.
Tom and Kaye Reiber saved this home’s character, brought it back to life and raised a family there. Now it’s someone else's turn.
Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.