In 2018, two friends bought a home in the North Side’s Deutschtown neighborhood. They had great plans for the place, which is actually two buildings. It’s in an urban setting that is walkable, diverse, convenient and part of a developing community.

“He was walking down the street with his dog and saw the place and called me and said we have to do this,” said Oliver Scigliano, referring to the fateful day when his friend, Chris Zappa, found the brick building with old barn doors for sale.

“The original owner had it in his family a long time,” said Scigliano. “He was ready to become a snow bird, to sell but still very attached to the building.”

It would need a ton of work but the duo were ready to invest themselves into creating something special. So they plunged into the world of planning, which meant surveys, architectural drawings and all the bureaucratic stuff that comes with turning what was an old garage into a home.

Advertise with us

They closed in 2019, got their plans together over the next year and then, just as construction looked to be not far down the road, COVID-19 arrived and their project, like so many things, was put on hold.

Their lives took different directions over the next couple of years. One got married and had kids. The other got a new job. And their grand plan for the property got sidelined.

The two men recently decided it was time to let their dream go and give someone else a chance to take on this project. They put 622 Emlin St. on the market for $200,000 (MLS No. 1673361) with Coldwell Banker Real Estate agent Amy Rick (www.coldwellbankerhomes.com or 412-585-3500).

The two-story brick building that looks like a carriage house appears to be on Foreland Street. But it’s actually on Emlin Street and has been attached to a two-story concrete-block building.

After closing on the property in 2019, Scigliano and Zappa worked with an architect to figure out how to turn the two buildings into a home. They knocked down the walls between the buildings, creating one very long building between the two streets.

Advertise with us

“I have the survey plans. I also have the architect drawings that we had to send to the city,” Scigliano said. “We are happy to include those in the sale.”

The portion of the building on the lot that was 625 Foreland St. is older, and has 860 square feet on each floor. The ground floor is a clear reminder of the building’s past life as a garage where mechanics worked on Model T trucks, as the partners were told.

They’re not sure when it was built.

“I believe it’s like 1902, sometime around there,” Scigliano said. “In the 1970s, someone built on the addition,” referring to the Emlin Street portion of  the property.

With high ceilings and a concrete floor, the space is urban rustic with original joists. A vehicle lift that runs down the middle is too narrow for modern cars.

Advertise with us

“Someone took some trolley tracks and put them with the joists,” Scigliano said.

Wooden steps lead to the second floor, which has exposed brick walls and what looks like original wood flooring.

“We really haven’t done too too much — cleaned it up a bit and maintained it,” Scigliano said.

A previous owner upgraded the electrical system, adding a new 200-amp electric panel and a hot water tank in 2015.

To the rear of the second floor is a bedroom with two windows that offer a view of the Downtown skyline across the Allegheny River.

Advertise with us

The newer part of the building that fronts on Emlin Street has a large double garage door. It is a bit shorter than the older portion.

The ground floor is also concrete.

Though this end of the building is mostly two stories, a portion in the middle is only one level, resulting in an odd roof line. On the other hand, there is potential for two roof decks.

The total property assessment is $52,100 — $45,600 on Foreland Street and $6,500 on Emlin Street. Annual taxes are $1,200.

There are no comparable sales over the last four years. However, three homes have sold in the 600 block of Foreland Street for prices ranging from $85,000 in February 2024 to $225,000 in January 2024 (www2.alleghenycounty.us/RealEstate/).

Advertise with us

On one side of the building are three very narrow lots. Two are owned by a private company and the middle lot, which is currently listed for sale, is owned by the East Allegheny Community Council.

“It’s unique in that regard, a lot of flexibility with that garage as it’s not considered a historical building,” Scigliano said. “So you can do what you want with it, not confined to doing an exact restoration.”

This is not a project for the faint of heart. It will take time, money and grit, but the potential is there for a great return.

Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com