This was once the home of Philander Knox, Secretary of State for President William Howard Taft and a cabinet member for Teddy Roosevelt and William McKinley.
Today, 322 Front St. in Brownsville retains that historic charm but has been updated for modern life.
Built in 1816, the house has timeless curb appeal. Owners Emily and John Payerchin have lived in the three-bedroom, 1½-bath home for six years.
“When we bought it, we didn’t have children,” she said.
Now they have two children and two dogs and are ready to upsize. “We have outgrown the space,” she said.
They have listed the historic house in Fayette County for $186,922 (MLS No. 1646391) with Ed Noschese and Kim Rostron of RE/MAX Home Center (www.remax.com or 412-370-2617). Annual taxes are $2,362.
The 2,478-square-foot house is in the Brownsville Northside Historic District on a quaint, tree-lined street not far from the Monongahela River.
Many of its original hardwood floors remain along with period molding in parts of the home. The foyer still has its original slate floor.
“The hardwood floors in the study, the living room and the hall are all original,” Mrs. Payerchin said. “Over time, previous owners replaced some of the other floors.”
She grew up in Cape May, New Jersey, where her father was stationed with the Coast Guard. But her parents are originally from Brownsville and they moved back after he retired.
Mrs. Payerchin began house hunting in this historic town to be closer to her family.
“When we saw this house, we fell in love with it,” she recalled. “It has beautiful high ceilings and large rooms with pretty crown molding.”
Her husband found more to love on the third floor.
“The loft area in the finished attic is pretty cool,” he said, noting the exposed stone chimney.
“It adds a very cool vibe,” his wife said.
“We used it as office space,” Mr. Payerchin said. “But it had been used as a bedroom and it is a sitting room with a TV right now.”
The house’s location makes it an easy stroll to downtown Brownsville.
“We do walk to town to the post office, the library and a couple of sandwich shops,” she noted.
It is the small town lifestyle they were looking for in 2018.
“We are on a pretty and quiet street so we take a lot of walks around our neighborhood. Nemacolin Castle is close by on our street,” Mrs. Payerchin said.
The castle, a brick structure complete with a tower, was built around a trading post established just after the Revolutionary War. Jacob Bowman began construction on what is also known as Nemacolin Castle in the late 1700s. Now on the National Register of Historic Places, it is a house museum open for public tours.
The river is another source of entertainment.
“We do kayak and paddle board and people use the river recreationally a lot here,” Mrs. Payerchin said.
The couple made some improvements to the property, including white vinyl fencing in the backyard and updating the kitchen.
“We did a kitchen remodel with new countertops and appliances,” she said.
They repainted most of the rooms in the house and the front in creamy yellow with dark green trim. One side of the house shows its stacked-stone construction.
“Our house is a mixture of stucco and stone,” explained Mrs. Payerchin.
A marker outside the house notes that Knox, a Brownsville native, served as attorney general under McKinley, the 25th U.S. president.
“He had many positions in the government when he lived here,” Mrs. Payerchin added.
“What we will miss the most is the history of the place,” her husband said.
The couple plan to leave a little bit of history for the next owners — if they appreciate its value.
“We have an antique game table that was gifted by the previous owner and it belonged to the Knox family, so we have an original piece of furniture,” she said.
They plan to leave it to the next owners as long as they are interested in preserving the history of the house. Otherwise, they might donate it to the historical society.
“I can’t imagine that a buyer of this home wouldn’t have some type of interest in history,” Mrs. Payerchin said. “The two front windows on the first floor still have the wavy glass and are original.”
The study features a bay window with a window seat and built-in book shelves.
The living room with its original fireplace mantel is a favorite spot.
“Before we had children we would hang out there,” Mrs. Payerchin said. “My husband would play the guitar and we always had our fireplace going.”
One thing they wish they could take with them are the neighbors.
“We have really great neighbors who look out for each other. It’s a good neighborhood,” she said.
Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.