This 1908 Georgian was a rescue expertly transformed into a designer’s dream come true — actually, two designers.
After 24 years, Patrick Denham and Dan Vitalie of Denham-Vitalie Design are listing their home at 5321 Wilkins Ave., Squirrel Hill for $1.895 million (MLS no.1638329) with Christine Healy of RE/MAX Real Estate Solutions (remax.com or 412-512-1499). The property is under contract.
“We always felt we rescued the house,” said Vitalie, recalling their first impressions.
It was nearly completely covered in ivy when they decided to take it on.
“Even the windows were covered. It was foot thick; you couldn’t even tell it was a brick house,” remembered Vitalie.
The previous owners did not use the heat, instead warming the home with its fireplaces.
“We couldn’t get to the second floor when we first looked at it because of the animals [think squirrels, raccoons],” he said. “It was not condemned, but it was in very bad disrepair.”
With seven bedrooms and six baths over 6,146 square feet, it was a huge undertaking, but that did not deter the designers.
“I think we bought it mainly for the love of the architecture. You could tell it had good bones and a lot of the architectural elements had been preserved such as the woodwork and staircase,” Vitalie noted. “We could see the potential.”
The layout was a big draw as well. Its status as a true center hall colonial, flanked by the formal living room on one side and the formal dining room on the other, was key.
“Being a formal Georgian, we liked that it had the center hall entry, with the formal living room and formal dining room, said Vitalie.
They refinished all the floors, replaced molding where needed and rewired the entire home — then all old knob and tube. Much of the walls and ceilings were replaced during the rewiring process, and all the windows have been replaced too. Other improvements included relining the chimneys, replacing the boiler and adding air conditioning zoned by floor.
Even the garage was renovated.
“We put on a new garage door and made it into a carriage house apartment,” said Denham.
“Making it livable took about seven months and five dumpsters,” Vitalie recalled.
Another improvement was insulating and adding a radiant heated floor to what had been a porch, enclosed by previous owners.
“It’s now our family room,” he said. “We spend a lot of time there and in the kitchen and the back porch.”
“And we practically live in the outdoor space with the outdoor fireplace,” said Vitalie.
“When we did the back porch it added another dimension to the house for entertaining and for daily living,” explained Denham.
The porch can be enclosed with remote blinds and features an outdoor kitchen. They fenced in the yard, making it 40 square feet larger and adding a pond to create a tranquil retreat.
“With the warmer winters it is nearly a four-season space,” noted Vitalie.
The kitchen, back porch fireplace and pond were all finished within the last three years.
The kitchen got a professional facelift with new quartz countertops, freshly painted cabinets, new hardware, new wallpaper, new appliances and a subzero refrigerator. They left the original pantry.
“I wanted to leave that intact because I think it is just the coolest thing. It is really charming,” said Denham.
The property assessment is $502,600 and the annual tax bill is $11,580. In the last four years, two houses have sold in the 5300 block of Wilkins Avenue for $1.475 million in June 2020 and $1.23 million in November 2020.
With seven bedrooms and a new full bath on third floor, theirs was the place for family and friends to gather.
“It was always the holiday house,” he said.
Whether it was Christmas or Thanksgiving and almost always New Years the house was alive with people. They often hosted 50 to 75 guests for New Year’s celebrations.
“All of our friends and relatives liked coming here because they could stay if they didn’t want to drive home,” recalled Denham with a laugh.
Over the years it became the beacon for the holiday season.
“We have this reputation that when I put the reindeer in the front yard and I decorate the front that is when people know it’s Christmas, said Denham.
The location makes the house very desirable as well.
“I can walk to the office on Copeland Street and we could walk anywhere,” said Denham. “The location is ideal.”
It seems like the right time to find something smaller, a new project, they said, noting the possibility of looking for a project with a different style.
Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.