With 10,000 plus square feet of living space, including six bedrooms and seven bathrooms, 5135 Ellsworth Ave. in Shadyside qualifies as a mansion in the truest sense of the word.
Built to impress for William Penn Snyder, the home is reminiscent of the White House with its Greek Revival style and two-story columns at the entrance.
Like the White House, it has had the distinction of hosting various dignitaries including Princess Grace of Monaco (Grace Kelly), Nobel Prize winner Marie Curie as well as U.S. Presidents Calvin Coolidge and William Taft, among others.
Owners John Reilly and Tres Whitehead have listed 5135 Ellsworth for $2.645 million (MLS No. 1605127) with Aaron Garland of RE/MAX Select Realty (www.remax.com or 724-933-6300).
“It has been a fantastic house to live in,” said Reilly, who is moving with Whitehead to Madrid, Spain, for Reilly’s career as chief operating officer of a leisure park group.
The men shared the house for three years with a big dog; both of their mothers lived there at various times. They were happy to be in a 22-room home, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, which began the year they moved in. The home includes a third-floor guest suite with a full kitchen and a separate entrance and there is a separately deeded two-bedroom, one-bath carriage house.
All this is within easy walking distance of shopping and dining in Shadyside.
“What we loved the most about the house was the living room,” Reilly said.
“It is remarkably quiet inside. The walls are thick and upholstered with fabric, the windows are new and it is just a terrific, relaxing room.”
An original Irish cross plaster ceiling, leaded-glass bookcases and marble fireplace add to the elegance.
The ballroom and dining room are part of an addition that was completed shortly after the main house was built and is not accessed by the back staircase, which runs from the basement to the third floor.
Built in 1900, the house was often referred to as the Babcock mansion after it was sold to Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Babcock, founder of Babcock Lumber Co. The property has been restored to its former glory with its gleaming hardwood floors, original ornate molding, ceiling beams and pocket doors by previous owners as well as Reilly and Whitehead.
It is hard to believe that this historic landmark designed by architect George Orth was once scheduled for the wrecking ball. Designer Herb Beatty saved and restored it in 1975, which is why it is sometimes referred to as the Beatty mansion.
“We did a lot of the exterior renovation while the previous owners did much of the interior,” explained Reilly. “The outside of the house was one of our big focuses moving in because it provided an opportunity for an update.”
They had the fence and some of the concrete walls in front restored, and completely renovated the landscaping using landscape architect Elise Keely of e.k. Smith Landscape Design.
“The design of the landscape offers a bit of screening so that, when you are sitting there, you aren’t on display, but you can see people and they can see you. It is just a nice place to sit and spend time,” he offered.
“We also had all the trim painted, including the columns, and had all the masonry updated and put in custom iron gates for the front porch and driveway entrances,” said Reilly.
The two large hanging lanterns on the front porch were another Reilly and Whitehead update. Inside, they restored a stained-glass window in the main stairwell that depicts William Penn Snyder.
The property’s assessment is $1,706,300. Over the last three years, four homes have sold in the 5100 block of Ellsworth Avenue for prices ranging from $775,000 in June 2021 to this house for $1,950,000 in October 2020. (alleghenycounty.us).
“I know there is so much about the house that is grand, but it is just a wonderful house to live in because it is surprisingly cozy and we just loved having friends and family come and stay and enjoy it,” Reilly said.
“We do love Pittsburgh but we are excited to embark on another chapter in Madrid.”
Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.