While renovation and restoration may sound similar, they are not the same thing. Renovation involves improvements, change from what is. Restoration involves preserving a home’s original character and history, returning to what was.

For Dennis Lapic, restoration was the only way to go with an 1824 house built by the Harmonists in the historic district of Old Economy Village.

“Somewhere in the ’90s I bought it. I was restoring another house, my very first one that was next door,” he said. “My neighbor walked up and said, ‘You remember me? I want you to buy my house.’” And he did.

Several restorations and a lot of living later, Lapic made the decision to sell 1501 Church St. in Ambridge. The two-bedroom, 2½-bath house is listed for $255,000 with Steven Roberts of Keller Williams Realty (412-867-9311 or www.kw.com).

Advertise with us

Lapic is also the owner of the Heslet House Bed & Breakfast at 1427 Church St., an early 1820s log house he restored. It was the winner in the commercial category of the Post-Gazette’s 2016-17 Renovation Inspiration Contest.

Open houses at this house are scheduled for 3-9 p.m. Saturday and 2-7 p.m. Sunday. It’s no coincidence that this weekend is also Old Economy’s Christmas at the Village. With paid regular admission, visitors can walk the candlelit streets, tour restored Harmonist buildings, do a bit of Christmas shopping and even visit Belsnickel, the German version of Santa Claus. Visit oldeconomyvillage.org for more information.

If you stop by 1501 Church St., look for the guy wearing the pork pie hat. That’s Lapic and he’s a storyteller extraordinaire. He can tell you lots more about this house, which is on the National Register of Historic Places, and also about the Harmony Society. The celibate group of Lutheran Separatists originally migrated from Germany to Butler County in 1804 under the leadership of George Rapp. Mostly farmers and craftsmen, they moved to Indiana for a time and returned to Western Pennsylvania to settle along the Ohio River in Beaver County in 1824. They called their village “Oekonomie” (Economy).

While the Harmony Society dissolved in 1905, the quality of their work, their efficiency and the simplicity of their lives are still reflected in this historic village. It has endured nearly 200 years of change, including numerous wars and the rise and fall of the local steel industry.

When Lapic bought this house, its history was hidden beneath layers of linoleum, wallpaper and dropped ceilings.

Advertise with us

“A normal house in a non-historic community — they probably would have condemned it,” he said. “It was horrible. I didn’t even want to walk on the floor. That’s how bad it was.”

Its restoration began with stabilization. His mission was to bring the house back to its original appearance while integrating modern conveniences as unobtrusively as possible.

Like many houses in the community, this one originally had three rooms on each floor. Lapic removed the extra walls added later to bring back the original floorplan. The walls are a combination of plasterboard and plaster.

“Upstairs is all natural lime and gypsum mix,” he said. “It will absorb carbon out of the atmosphere to cure it. It’s always curing.”

The walls weren’t the only thing in need of patching. The floors, after nearly 200 years of living and abuse, were a mess. They’re “mostly oak on the first floor and the second floor is pine — all original Harmonist flooring,” he said.

Advertise with us

Lapic was able to salvage pieces of oak flooring from other homes in the area that were being demolished. He decided not to use a power sander, opting instead to do them by hand.

“Gently refinished it … you don’t want to use a big old belt sander. Not only does it remove the thickness, it removes the patina,” he explained. “It’s the footsteps for 200 years, and a little bit of dirt ground in there.”

The living room or stube (a German term for a parlor) is a spacious 22 by 20 feet, as is the master bedroom on the second floor. Sunlight floods both rooms, highlighting the rich colors of the wide, hand-hewn planks.

For another glimpse of history, look for the hatch under the stairs by the front door. Pull on the iron ring and check out the two cellars. Once a jumble of wire, ducts and pipes, the main cellar is now an open storage area whose stone walls speak of the Harmonists. Lapic moved the high-efficiency gas furnace, central air-conditioning and high-efficiency water heater into the smaller cellar room.

On the first floor, there is a powder room with a newer vanity that sits by the pantry and a long room with wide plank flooring that runs along the front of the house. It has the potential to be a family room, bedroom or a commercial venture.

Advertise with us

The kitchen includes a refrigerator, a gas stove (hardly used as the tenant didn’t like to cook) and a dishwasher. There is a stacked washer/dryer in the pantry. While the appliances are definitely modern, Lapic made a point to keep it simple. Upper cupboards have been replaced with open shelving.

Upstairs, the wide planks of the mellow pine floor stretch across the master bedroom. A brick fireplace on one wall is a focal point. Off to one side is the master bathroom, with a clawfoot tub, a dark wood vanity and a walk-in dressing room.

There is a smaller second bedroom (13 by 10 feet) and a family bathroom with a walk-in shower and tile flooring. The large second-floor landing could be used as a home office or a quiet reading nook.

Another challenge for Lapic was restoring and in some cases replacing the numerous windows of the house. This task involved working with a skilled window maker and some trash picking.

“My wife and I, if we would see windows out at the curb by a garbage can, we would have a look,” he said.

Advertise with us

They were looking for windows with small panes similar to the ones the Harmonists made by hand using cylinder glass. “It never lays 100% flat. That’s where you get the wavy glass.”

There are some modern elements — recessed lights, high-efficiency appliances and a new metal roof — but nothing can interfere with the spirit of this handmade house.

Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com.