The story of Pittsburgher Harry K. Thaw murdering famous architect Stanford White over his love for Evelyn Nesbitt was once front-page news around the country. But the 1906 shooting, which happened at New York City’s Madison Square Theatre in front of a large audience, has faded into memory.
Except at 820 Devonshire St. in Shadyside, a house once owned by Thaw’s cousin Benjamin. History remains strong here.
The house was built in the late 1880s by Edmund Morewood Ferguson for $13,000. He sold it to Julia Leishman, whose husband, John, was a colleague of Henry Clay Frick and Andrew Carnegie. He is said to have saved Frick’s life after an assassination attempt.
The Gilded Age mansion speaks of a bygone era, with leaded-glass windows, oak and mahogany woodwork and an elaborate, hand-carved oak staircase in the foyer.
Today, the house waits for someone new to start their own story in its six light-filled bedrooms and 3½ bathrooms. The landmark house is on the market for $1,995,000 (MLS No. 1491829) with Maryann Bacharach of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services (www.howardhanna.com or 412-874-8465).
“I love the history because there are not many homes left in Pittsburgh with this kind of background and such well-preserved rooms,” the Realtor said.
Read More
Owner Jessica Brown and her husband, Jeff, have lived in the 5,921-square-foot stone manse since 1999, when they moved back from London, England.
“We chose this house on Devonshire Street in Shadyside for three reasons: location, history and original features,” said Mrs. Brown.
“Like several of the home’s previous owners, we were enamored with the house’s fascinating history of residents and their roles in Pittsburgh’s development as a city and center of industry and finance in the U.S.,” she said. “We have enjoyed preserving and expanding upon the records they created.”
The Browns have maintained the house’s architectural integrity without sacrificing modern convenience. All of the bathrooms have all been updated.
“In the bathrooms, they did leave some of the original tile, which only makes them more beautiful,” noted Bacharach. “The owners are meticulous. Even in the basement, everything is spotless.”
The living room, foyer and dining room remain nearly the same as when the home was built. The dining room is similar to the one at Clayton, the Frick family home in Point Breeze. All of the pocket doors still work as well as they did originally. Since the house was constructed before central heating was common, every room has a fireplace. Today, most are decorative.
The bedrooms have cherry wood floors, while the entrance hall and stairs all the way to the third floor are done in beautiful quarter-sawn oak.
“Usually the third floor was off-limits and used only for the maids, but that was not the case in this house,” said Bacharach.
There is a billiard room on the third floor for the owners’ use.
“We fell in love with all of the original finishes that had been preserved by previous owners for more than 100 years, including the handmade English ceramic tile walls and ceiling of the kitchen,” Mrs. Brown said.
The kitchen tile is a gleaming cobalt blue.
“Those blue tiles are truly stunning,” Bacharach said. “That is not something you find often.”
While the ceiling and walls are a testament to the good taste of the past, the appliances, cabinets and counters have all been updated.
“We were excited to modernize the home to make it more suitable for modern family living while at the same time preserving the beauty and quality of those finishes,” Mrs. Brown said.
The total property assessment is $835,100. The most recent house to sell in the 800 block of Devonshire Street sold for $750,000 in March 2010 (www2.alleghenycounty.us/realestate/GeneralInfo.aspx?).
Mrs. Brown said she and her husband love the neighborhood.
“We have enjoyed this house because of the beautiful, green and quiet residential quality of the neighborhood, and because of its walkability and close proximity to the many resources of the city, including its parks, museums and other cultural assets, schools, universities, medical facilities, shops and restaurants.”
Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.