Living on the border of the Upper Hill District and Polish Hill, Laurel Coniglio had the best of all worlds. Though her house is just off Bigelow Boulevard, Ajax Street is a quiet street lined with single-family homes on one side and trees on the other. Yet she was close to shopping, bars and restaurants in Oakland and the Strip District.

But this is one house where location is secondary. What stands out at 3352 Ajax St. is the colors. Instead of boring neutrals, it sports rich reds, vivid blues, botanical greens and funky fuchsia.

“I put it together the best I could with a budget over time, reuse and recycle in a really stylish way,” said Coniglio, who grew up in Connecticut but moved here when she was in her 20s.

“I was living next door and I knew that the person who lived there had passed away,” she said. “As a cash buyer I wanted something I could afford.... Emptied out my bank account to buy this house.

Advertise with us

“It’s a modest house, not a fancy Friendship house, a working people’s house,” she said.

Now moving to Texas, Coniglio has put the two-bedroom, one-bath home on the market for $220,000 (MLS No.1492682) with Tirzah Decaria of RE/MAX Select Realty (www.remax.com or 724-933-6300, ext. 849).

Coniglio loved the neighborhood and was delighted to find another house there. But this one required a major renovation when she bought it in December 2013. Ripping out just about everything, she and her contractor boyfriend worked hard to preserve the house’s covered front porch, original wood floors and other 1910 details. The ceilings were stripped down to the furring strips and the wiring, plumbing and roof were replaced.

They painted the exterior two shades of blue and the front door fuchsia trimmed in white. The front porch leads into a living room with red paneled walls and a fireplace mantel hand-carved by the previous owner. The new owner could make it a working fireplace but it would have to be a gas-burner since the shallow firebox was designed to burn coal.

In the dining room, Coniglio preserved transoms over the doors and covered new mechanicals with vintage tin ceiling tiles to add texture to the room. The dining room opens to the kitchen, which contains her beloved Tappan deluxe stove.

Advertise with us

“The Tappan offered some sophisticated tech for the time. You can plug in your coffee maker and set it on a timer,” she said.

The dining room and kitchen have new bamboo flooring, but that’s not what most people notice. The cabinets, some with glass fronts, are painted fuchsia. They contrast with an olive green vintage double Youngstown sink that sits underneath a wide window overlooking the backyard.

The single bathroom on the first floor has lavender walls, white subway tiles with black bands and oversized black-and-white checkerboard flooring. Coniglio had to move the tub from its original location.

“The bathtub was underneath the stairs with a triangle-shaped shower — very strange,” she said.

Coniglio was told that eight people once lived in the house. That might explain the tub under the stairs and why there is a large farmhouse sink in the bonus room off the master bedroom. The extra room could be an art studio, crafts room or spacious home office with a little kitchenette to make coffee. The bonus room has a linoleum floor in a basketweave design of white, blue and maroon. The sink’s base is finished off with more tin ceiling tiles.

Advertise with us

Both upstairs bedrooms have bamboo floors and the hallway has a tongue-and-groove wood ceiling.

Another quirk can be found in the second bedroom — a window facing into the hallway, probably from a long-ago renovation. Stained-glass panels could be added for privacy.

The property’s 2021 Allegheny County assessed property value is $22,500. Over the last five years, two houses have sold in the 3300 block of Ajax Street, one for $20,000 in October 2018 and the other for $164,000 in October 2020 (www2.alleghenycounty.us/RealEstate/GeneralInfo.aspx?).

For anyone with an appreciation for creative reuse, the home is perfect in a wabi sabi way. Coniglio hid a Pirates baseball schedule behind one of the new walls, figuring a future owner would find it someday. She is sad to leave this unique house, and Pittsburgh.

“I’ve moved to West Texas in the middle of nowhere, but Pittsburgh will always be my home,” she said with a deep sigh. “It’s really special and I think, for me, it always will be.”

Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com