Whenever the Pittsburgh Public School District announces another “journey of modernizing our footprint,” as it did last week, it usually means closing schools. Then the question becomes: What do you do with all those empty classrooms, long hallways, gymnasiums and ballfields, usually right in the middle of a residential neighborhood?
Over the past 10 years, Pat Morosetti and Fourth River Development LLC (fourthriverdevelopment.com) have been tasked with marketing many former schools in the city and surrounding suburbs. In 2012, Fourth River was asked to sell 21 city properties, most of them vacant schools. Five of those properties are still available, four of them elementary schools. The schools and their reserve prices are Belmar in Homewood ($300,000), Horace Mann on the North Side ($190,000) and Arlington ($155,000) and Bon Air ($55,000) in those South Hills neighborhoods. All but Bon Air Elementary are currently under contract. Also, 23 acres of vacant land in New Homestead is priced at $350,000.
“They’re unique assets and there are challenges,” said Mr. Morosetti. “They were specifically designed and built to educate students. It’s my experience with all of these schools that it takes the right buyer with the right vision.”
McCleary School Condos in Lawrenceville is a school reuse Mr. Morosetti offered as a success story. Built in 1900, the school on Holmes Street closed in 2002 and was sold by the district in 2015. The project was developed by E Properties and Development.
The developer preserved much of the charm of the old school — marble staircases, built-in bookshelves and even the occasional chalkboard, making the 25 units, all of which are currently occupied, a time capsule of sorts. Amenities include a fitness center, dog washing facility, covered off-street parking, an outdoor bicycle storage area and a rooftop lounge.
The condominiums sold for prices ranging from $159,985 for a one-bedroom, one-bath unit in September 2017 to $640,000 for a three-bed, two-bath unit in April 2019 (www2.alleghenycounty.us/RealEstate/Building.aspx?).
Could someone do the same with the four Pittsburgh elementary schools? Or the former Jeffrey Primary School in the Shaler Area School District?
Jeffrey School, at 201 Wetzel Road, Shaler, sits on 6.1 acres near McKnight Road. The building, which was closed in 2018, has 31,482 square feet and comes with a ballfield. It was listed for $499,000 in December and is now under contract with ANG Real Estate LLC “subject to a pending 90-day due diligence period,” said Shaler Area communications specialist Bethany Baker.
When it comes to repurposing schools, the issues are size and condition, especially for buildings at least 100 years old.
“Older schools were very well constructed,” said Mr. Morosetti. But sometimes you are left with “a pretty tough structure.”
Horace Mann School was built in 1874 and named in honor of a mid-1800s educational reformer from Massachusetts. Listed for $190,000 with Fourth River Development, it has 3.1 acres and 56,760 square feet spread over five floors, including the basement. The imposing red-brick building is framed at the corners with granite and has multiple gables, dormers and chimneys. The school is surrounded by single-family homes and is not in a commercial corridor.
Belmar School at 7100 Hermitage St., Homewood, is listed at a minimum reserve price of $300,000. The 58,832-square-foot building sits on 1.7 acres. The building, which was completed in 1903, once had tiled halls, grand staircases and stained-glass windows, according to HistoricPittsburgh.org. A separate two-story building contains a gym and basement. Other additions have been made to the original brick building, which is surrounded by single-family homes and is near Penn Avenue's commercial area in East Liberty.
Arlington School at 2428 Arlington Ave. is listed at $155,000. This is a smaller, more modern building — if you consider the 1960s modern — with three stories, including the basement. It comes with 25,310 square feet of space and nearly a half-acre of land. Surrounded by homes, it has a parking lot/playground that measures 67 by 75 feet.
Bon Air Elementary, the only one of the four city schools not under contract, has 14,563 square feet spread over three floors. The school takes up nearly the entire parcel at 252 Fordyce St. and has a reserve price of $55,000. Built in 1955, the brick building contains five classrooms and a separate kindergarten area along with administration offices. One unique feature is the long wall of windows on one side of the building.
“It sort of epitomizes the phrase neighborhood school, nestled right in the middle of the Bon Air community,” said Mr. Morosetti. “There has been some interest shown in Bon Air. Nice community schools like Bon Air represent good opportunities but with that opportunity can come issues.”
Lizabeth Gray: lgray@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.