When Suzanne Hulton bought this Italianate-style Victorian 22 years ago, the decorator knew it would be the perfect showcase for her style.

Built in 1879, the five-bedroom, 2½-bath house in Butler had been only slightly altered from the time it was built. Mrs. Hulton and her late husband William proceeded to fill 236 E. Pearl St. with the Victorian wallcoverings, paint colors and antiques that they both loved.

Now, she has decided to downsize and has listed the property for sale for $265,900 (MLS No. 1318993) with Charles Schmitzer III of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services (www.howardhanna.com or 724-282-7903 ext. 215). It is open by appointment.

The red-brick home on a corner lot features its original window hoods, corbels and other trim. A hitching post is a reminder that once upon a time, horses and buggies pulled up to this home. Even the landscaping is old.

Advertise with us

“There are very old rhododendrons and several pin oak and maple trees that have been here probably as long as the house,” Mrs. Hulton said. “We added rosebushes along the front bank and there is an area of mature lilacs in white, lavender and purple.”

A large third-floor apartment has its own kitchen, dining room, bedroom and a gardener who is a longtime tenant.

“We call her side of the yard the secret garden. It is filled with perennials and flowering shrubs.”

The front porch has a porch swing and leads to walnut double entry doors. Inside, the 23-by-7-foot entry has Lincrusta wall coverings below the chair rail. Overhead, a 12-inch tall peacock frieze stands out against rich blue walls, near the 11-foot ceiling. Old oil paintings in gilded frames and antique rugs on original hardwood floors speak of another era.

Two parlors flanking the entry measure 19 by 17 feet and 12 by 11 feet. Both have working pocket doors. The larger of the two is referred to as the Pink Parlor.

Advertise with us

“There was a large decorative wool rug that was there when we bought the house. It is very large, so we went with it,” Mrs. Hulton said, adding that it will stay with the home.

The room has a Mission-style gas fireplace that the owner believes was added in the early 1900s. A small crystal chandelier illuminates antique seating and furnishings. Most of the house’s furniture will be sold separately. Across the hall, the green parlor has custom drapes, a marble fireplace and an angled bay window.

The 20-by-11-foot dining room features burgundy and gold wallpaper and a carved, columned fireplace mantel with a built-in mirror and red-tile surround. There is also a built-in china closet and crystal chandelier that was a wedding gift to the Hultons.

The 21-by-12-foot kitchen is long and narrow, she said, because it was utilitarian, not the gathering place that kitchens are today. Mrs. Hulton recently removed Schumacher wallpaper and painted the walls white to match the cabinets and laminate counter tops. She also had a wide-plank Pergo floor installed.

The first-floor powder room had pink fixtures when they moved in. Now it has a white pedestal sink and marble floor.

Advertise with us

The four bedrooms on the second floor have 9-foot ceilings and hardwood floors. The 23-by-15-foot master has a decorative fireplace and small pendant chandelier.

“That one matches the dining room and was also a gift. There is a third in the parlor,” Mrs. Hulton said.

The owners made some changes in the bathroom.

“It has a corner tub that has been in there for probably 80 years. We pulled up the vinyl floor and installed ceramic tile, a pedestal sink and new toilet. It has Monet waterlily wallpaper.”

Two other bedrooms measure 14 by 13 feet and are served by another bathroom. “We kept the original hexagon tile on the floor and the original cast-iron tub. We redid the shower inside and installed ceramic tile and added a new pedestal sink.”

Advertise with us

The house’s two furnaces were replaced seven years ago and the roof four years ago. All of the appliances in the third-floor apartment were recently replaced. Mr. Schmitzer is doing a feasibility study to see if a two-car garage and driveway can be added in back.

The annual taxes on this Butler County property are $4,770 (www.co.butler.pa.us/property-and-revenue-assessment). Over the last six years, two properties have sold in the 200 block of East Pearl Street for $176,500 in January 2013 and $180,000 in September 2012 (www.realstats.net).

Surrounding streets are lined with other grand houses, Mrs. Hulton said. “A group of people are working on making my street and others a designated historic district. This is a lovely area of big old historic homes.”

Rosa Colucci: rcolucci@post-gazette.com