Benny “Bucky” Palermo spent his life working on leather, starting as a shoeshine boy at age 10. Joining his uncle, a cobbler in Lawrenceville, he grew into a master craftsman who repaired skates and athletic shoes for the Pittsburgh Steelers, Pirates and Penguins while also fixing handbags, loafers and more ordinary footwear.

He worked for most of his career on Butler Street in Lawrenceville, but his last shop was a former Baptist church at 6328 Butler St. in Stanton Heights, on its border with Upper Lawrenceville.

“He bought the building in 1996 after being in Lower Lawrenceville for more than 50 years,” said his son, Tony Palermo.

“He retired in 2015 at the end of the year. I worked there every weekend for the last 15 years. My dad worked five days a week, Tuesday through Saturday.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Palermo lived in the unique space, which underwent extensive upgrades, and passed away in June 2017. The family has decided to list the building and garage boasting a total of 22,000 square feet for $299,999 (MLS No. 1306865) with Caryn Rosenthal of Howard Hanna Real Estate Services (www.howardhanna.com or 412-389-1695).

The property is zoned mixed-use industrial and sits on a 0.54-acre lot facing the Allegheny River. Mr. Palermo said that everything has been upgraded except for exterior paint.

“The family has taken care of everything for the last 20 years,” he said, adding that Amish carpenters spent a week installing a new steel roof.

A small workshop was added onto the front The main level has one very large room, probably the church’s sanctuary, with original hardwood floors with an espresso stain and semi-gloss finish.

A large kitchen area features new cabinets, appliances and lighting. Natural light streams in through long, thin windows that probably once contained stained glass. All of the windows have been replaced in the past two years.

Advertise with us

Toward the back of the main level, a small hallway leads to two small bedrooms and a bathroom. There is also a separate powder room on the main level.

Upstairs, the second level has been finished and was Tony Palermo’s living quarters for several years. The large, loftlike space has a kitchen at one end with dark-stained wood cabinets and a vinyl floor.

The rest of the space is carpeted and has a painted tin ceiling and new, exposed ductwork. There is a full bath on the second floor that has a standing shower, 30-inch vanity and toilet.

All of the HVAC systems have been updated.

“There is central air conditioning on both floors and there are new furnaces and an overhead heater, and the garage is also heated,” Mr. Palermo said.

Advertise with us

Outside, a long curved driveway allows easy access to Butler Street. The garage has room for four vehicles and overhead storage. A landscaper rented the garage for 15 years before selling his business.

Mr. Palermo said the current zoning allows for multiple rental spaces — two residential and two commercial. The lot is surrounded by city property, he said.

The property’s Allegheny County assessed value is $173,400 (www2.county.allegheny.pa.us/RealEstate/Search.aspx).

One thing the property has that can’t be assessed is good mojo. Bucky Palermo was well-known in Pittsburgh as a family man, friend and businessman, as evidenced by the many people who paid tribute at his funeral. In a Post-Gazette obituary, Sabrina Riccelli tried to describe her grandfather:

“Everybody knew him as Bucky but I only knew him as 'Pap.’ He had a heart of gold and a smile that could light up a room, but he always put everybody ahead of himself. I can't even put into words how great a guy he was."

Rosa Colucci: rcolucci@post-gazette.com.