DEAR NATALIE: I have a friend who feels that I have wronged her in some way. Because of this, she feels that it is perfectly acceptable to do rude things to me or give me the silent treatment, etc., until it dawns on me that I must have angered or hurt her, at which point I ask her what is wrong.

Because I’m not a mind reader, I submit that this type of behavior is counterproductive and can result in more misunderstandings. Instead, I believe that when a person is angered or hurt by a friend or significant other, the responsibility for initiating a discussion really rests on the person who is angered and/​or hurt. At that point, I think the person doing the confronting should give me an opportunity to own up to what I’ve done, apologize and make amends, if possible. What are your suggestions? — NOT A MIND READER

DEAR NOT A MIND READER: Sounds as if you have a very passive-aggressive friend. It’s challenging to be close with people who do not express themselves when they are hurt in the moment and instead take their frustrations out on you later. However, it is not OK to give a friend the silent treatment or be unkind in other ways.

Your friend is in the wrong here, regardless of why she is upset. Instead of dealing with her feelings, she is choosing to make a problem even bigger. But, sometimes people are afraid to own their feelings, therefore, she can’t just tell you what upset her. Anger is merely a mask for fear. And when we are afraid, we become irrational.

Advertise with us

Perhaps the best thing (and what I have tried to do in my own relationships with friends who are not open with their emotions) is to explain to her that while you are not a mind reader, you never meant to hurt or upset her. You love her, and while all of us are human and make mistakes from time to time, the worst mistake would be in not communicating how we feel. Don’t make the conversation about her. If you say, “I feel …” instead of “You make me feel …,” you will get a better result because she won’t immediately become defensive. This works well with lovers, too. Be specific and state how you feel, and give her the opportunity to respond in kind.

DEAR NATALIE: In early December, I mentioned the possibility of spending New Year’s Eve together to the lovely and enchanting lady I had recently begun dating. On Dec. 19, she brought up the invitation and said she would like to spend that night with me! We talked about what we would like to do, and she wanted to host me for dinner in appreciation of the several enjoyable dates we had experienced at my invitation. She even said it would be her preference for me to stay overnight at her home because she would be worried about me driving home at a dangerous hour in the wee small hours of New Year's Day. She proposed a certain dish for our meal and said that she would plan the perfect menu for this special night. I worked on trying to get my pet-sitter to take my dogs for the 31st so that I could stay overnight with my date.

Then, over a posh birthday/​celebration dinner I arranged for her on Dec. 26, I began talking about the arrangements for New Year’s Eve and told her that it appeared that I would be able to make provisions for my dogs and stay overnight with her. She looked me in the eye and said, “Oh, yes, New Year’s Eve. Why don’t you have a few more sips of wine before we discuss that?” She went on to say that she was flattered by the invitation but responded to it prematurely and that she has decided to spend that night the way she has in recent years, with friends out of state. She apologized profusely and asked what she could do to make this up to me (nothing). I told her that she handled this poorly, that I had been looking forward to this night, that I was hurt and that I would never have done this to her. I would never have done this to anyone.

What are your thoughts about the actions of a person who five days before a scheduled date would rescind an invitation to be together on one of the most, if not the most important, date nights of the year in order to accept an offer that she decided was more desirable? This was a first for me, and you can imagine how hurt and dejected I felt. — ALONE AND ASLEEP AS THE BALL DROPPED

DEAR ALONE AND ASLEEP AS THE BALL DROPPED: My initial reaction to this letter was that she must not be as into you as you previously thought. But, then I thought about it again and realized that NYE is a really weird night, and there are exceptions to rules. We put way too many expectations on this evening. Oftentimes, we are disappointed because of that.

Advertise with us

In this case, she probably agreed to your invite because she genuinely wanted to spend time together but later got cold feet. Perhaps she worried that you would think this meant something that it didn’t, or that you would expect to sleep with her that night — and maybe she wasn’t ready for that — or that maybe you would start treating the relationship more seriously than she was prepared for. All in all, she was inconsiderate and even insensitive to your feelings, but I am not sure if I can say with certainty that she meant anything beyond that. Being with her friends on that night was probably a lot less mental pressure, and it seems as though the closer it came to the date, the more pressure she was putting on herself about the situation.

Have a redo and see where the relationship goes from here. Give her a pass on this one, and if you are still together by next NYE and things don’t change, well then, Houston, you have a problem.

Natalie’s Networking Tip of the Week: Don’t be afraid to follow up. If you gave some people your business card and they said they would contact you, but they didn’t, don’t assume this means they aren’t interested. We all get busy and overwhelmed. Instead, look them up on Facebook, LinkedIn or Twitter and reach out to them. They will be flattered that you took the time to do so!

Natalie Bencivenga is the Post-Gazette’s Seen and society editor. She has a master’s degree in social work from the University of Pittsburgh. Need advice? Send questions to nbencivenga@post-gazette.com. Follow Natalie on Twitter @NBSeen and on Instagram @NatalieBenci.