In 2014, a Susquehanna River angler reeled in a smallmouth bass with a huge bulbous tumor on its lower jaw. The executive director of the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission was literally in the boat.

The photo of the disfigured fish went viral and made the national news, quickly becoming the sickly public face of the Susquehanna River, a waterway once considered a world-class smallmouth fishery.

“If sick fish had a PR company, they might pull something like this,” quipped John Arway, then director of Fish and Boat.

At the time, several environmental problems including an unidentified disease were killing off young bass.The mystery disease baffled scientists for 13 years and caused a rift between Pennsylvania environmental agencies. But now it’s virtually disappeared.

Advertise with us

“We’ve seen the [bass] population rebound since 2012 and it’s largely attributable to the absence of the disease that was once prevalent among young bass,” said Geoffrey Smith, chief Susquehanna River biologist for the Fish and Boat Commission.

His recently published report on middle Susquehanna black bass found no young smallmouths bearing the lesions that formed on tens of thousands of fish that later died.

“This reflects favorable recruitment and survival of the moderate to strong year-classes produced in 2012, 2014 and 2015 [that] benefited from reduced incidence of disease, which had caused mortality of young-of-year smallmouth bass to varying degrees since 2005,” Mr. Smith wrote in the report.

Despite some confusing anomalies, studies appeared to show a connection between the diseased smallmouths and agricultural runoff, parasites and municipal sewage discharge. John Quigley, Department of Environmental Protection secretary at the time, argued that because water from some Susquehanna tributaries doesn’t mix with the main stem for more than 40 miles, chemical pollutants fail to dilute, resulting in concentrated individual “lanes” of unmixed waters.

Mr. Arway wanted DEP to flag the river, or parts of it, as “impaired,” a designation that would trigger actions and funding from the state and federal governments. But with support from the federal Environmental Protection Agency and the Freshwater Research Initiative at Susquehanna University in Northumberland County, DEP challenged Fish and Boat’s hypothesis citing the absence of a practical action plan and insufficient data. Very publicly, Mr. Arway challenged DEP, straining inter-agency relations.

Advertise with us

Mr. Smith said throughout the imbroglio that biologists from Fish and Boat and DEP continued to cooperate. The issue is now moot, he said, since the disease seems to have disappeared and Tim Schaeffer, the current Fish and Boat executive director, was hired away from DEP.

The Susquehanna River flows nearly 465 miles from branches in New York and north central Pennsylvania through the state’s capital to the Atlantic Ocean. Older than the Appalachian Mountain chain it dissects, it is one of the oldest rivers on Earth. Its 27,500-square-mile watershed drains nearly half the state, including waters fished by many Western Pennsylvania anglers. The Juniata River, Little J, West Branch Susquehanna, Yellow Breeches Creek, Penns Creek, LeTort Spring Run, Pine Creek, Spring Creek and dozens more tributaries as far west as Indiana County feed the Susquehanna River. It empties into the Chesapeake Bay in Maryland.

Agency heads were still squabbling in 2012 when an increased number of healthy juvenile smallmouths began showing up in studies. Mr. Smith said disease mortality continued but spawning increased in 2014, 2015 and 2016.

The new middle Susquehanna nighttime electrofishing study was conducted at four sites in Dauphin County from Clemson Island to Halifax on Oct. 22-25, 2018. Mr. Smith’s team measured smallmouth population, size, age and other parameters. Not only did they find an absence of the disease, the catch rate was the fifth highest since standardized surveys were initiated in these waters in 1990.

The survey also documented a robust population of channel catfish.

Advertise with us

“Of interest to anglers targeting trophy smallmouth bass, more 20-inch and longer bass were caught during the 2018 survey than all other surveys from 1990-2017 combined,” the report states. “Anglers targeting smallmouth bass in the middle Susquehanna River during the popular fall through early-winter period can expect to encounter high numbers of bass, including high numbers of large fish, as they prepare for winter.”

Mr. Smith said unidentified lesions were found on some adult bass.

“We don’t know what it means or the cause,” he said, “but we have have not seen much effect on the adult fish population. We don’t think it’s the same as with the juvenile fish, where the lesions occurred in summer. This is a different kind of lesion in winter on adults.”

Catch and Immediate Release Regulations currently ban smallmouth and largemouth harvest year-round on 98 miles of the Susquehanna, including the survey waters, and nearly 32 miles of the Juniata River.

“We want to relax those regulations to allow fishing during the spawning season,” said Mr. Smith. “They’ll be relaxed in mid-April this year.”

Advertise with us

What killed tens of thousands of immature smallmouth bass on the Susquehanna River? Despite years of research, no one knows. But Mr. Smith said there’s a working theory about how nature cured itself of the mystery disease.

“Several successful year-classes in a short period of time, and eventually more fish were living and it just overwhelmed the disease,” he said. “That’s the theory.”

Susquehanna River anglers who catch a smallmouth bass with a lesion are asked to photograph the fish and email it to Fish and Boat. On the homepage (fishandboat.com), click on Susquehanna River Impairment and Report Diseased Bass, and fill out the electronic form.