The Pittsburgh region is known for building bridges — large, steel spans that allow people to easily cross the region’s rivers and rugged valleys.

But when it comes to creating access to the internet, the infrastructure of the 21st century, Pittsburgh is still drawing up the blueprints.

That means certain communities — both in urban pockets and in rural areas of Western Pennsylvania — remain disconnected from movements in today’s economy, as well as from critical health care and education services.

Bridging the “digital divide” is a massive problem that the federal government has long recognized. Though internet adoption across all demographic groups has risen, 1 in 5 Americans — nearly 22 million people — still reported having no internet access in 2015, according to U.S. Census data. In Pennsylvania, nearly 1 million people reported having no internet access that year.

Advertise with us

This year, efforts underway in both areas could begin to bear fruit.

Making rural projects feasible

Read More

In rural areas, the challenge for companies to build and maintain internet access is inherently economical.

As with any network, whether it is an electric power grid or pipelines carrying natural gas or water, developers build where there is a high concentration of customers, said Blair Levin, a former official at the Federal Communications Commission who led the development of the agency’s National Broadband Plan in 2010.

The plan addressed three questions about funding internet expansion: how to finance it, what projects are eligible to receive the funding, and how the funds are distributed.

Advertise with us

“The better you answer one question, the easier the others become,” Mr. Levin said.

Therefore, the government has long subsidized infrastructure development both to help companies provide so-called “universal service” and to ensure rates charged to rural customers are “reasonable” compared to urban customers.

But the concept of universal service has evolved. In the age of landlines and payphones, the cost of that service was subsidized when callers paid extra to make long-distance phone calls, explained Eric Einhorn, senior vice president of government affairs at Windstream Communications, an Arkansas-based telecommunications provider with 185,000 customers in Pennsylvania.

In 2011, calling the internet an essential utility, the FCC established the Connect America Fund to fund the expansion of internet, as well as telephone services, to disconnected areas.

The six-year funding program provides money based on the agency’s assessment of internet expansion costs by census tract. In every tract that the agency found a provider could expand, the FCC offered companies a subsidy. The company could then accept or decline the subsidy, based on its own assessment of costs.

Advertise with us

Windstream agreed to take $13 million a year in federal taxpayer dollars to expand broadband in all areas of the state identified by the FCC. (The company decided to pursue projects in all but one of the states it serves, deeming New Mexico too expensive even with the FCC’s offer.)

Mr. Einhorn said the company expects to meet the FCC requirement that 40 percent of targeted areas are offered service by the end of 2017. All areas must be offered service by the end of 2020. The company would not disclose what areas specifically could see headway, but Greene and Armstrong counties have the largest swaths of FCC-funded areas in Western Pennsylvania, according to the agency’s website.

The FCC has not signaled what approach it may take to subsidize the maintenance of networks after they’re built by 2020, Mr. Einhorn said, which creates some uncertainty.

“This is a bit of an experiment right now that we’re in the middle of,” he said. “There’s risk on our side that we may take this deal and service those customers and have to build out facilities that, 10 or 15 years from now, we may not be able to recover.”

Bridging the gap between neighborhoods

Advertise with us

As sprawling as they can be in rural areas, solutions to the internet challenge can be just as hyperlocal in urban areas.

And that could be good news for expanding access overall, because income and education can be better indicators of internet access than geography, according to annual national surveys by the Pew Research Center.

While 98 percent of people people making $75,000 a year have internet access, just 79 percent of people making less than $30,000 a year can say the same, according to Pew. 

Between college graduates and those without a high school degree, the gap is 30 percentage points, the group found.

In the Pittsburgh-area, neighborhoods like Braddock, Allentown and the Hill District are seeing wireless networks pop up courtesy of Meta Mesh Wireless Communities, a nonprofit based at the WorkHard Pittsburgh co-working space in Allentown.

Advertise with us

Executive Director Adam Longwill started the venture with an idea back in 2013 that routers create neighborhood-based wireless networks by sharing unused bandwidth. The more routers — which share data among computer networks, constituting the internet — the bigger the network. If routers could be placed in businesses clustered in a community hub, for example, a coffee shop could share with a retailer, and both could share with a restaurant.

Since the end of 2015, Meta Mesh has “quadrupled in size” and expanded to four additional neighborhoods, said Becky Zajdel, the group’s outreach coordinator. The router Meta Mesh uses is a fraction the size from when it started.  

With nonprofit status, the organization can receive donations in money and equipment directly for projects, Ms. Zajdel said. Neighborhood Allies, a Pittsburgh economic development group, gave Meta Mesh a $15,000 grant last year to install 20 routers in the Hill District.

Just as important, Ms. Zajdel added, is the educational component. Meta Mesh teaches people in the neighborhood the basics of how to install and troubleshoot the mesh network. The demystification of a technically challenging concepts can make it easier to sell to more communities.

“One of the things about the digital divide is that a lot people don’t know about where their internet comes from or how it works,” Ms. Zajdel said. “If they’re in control — if they have a stake in how they get their own internet — we found they’re going to be more interested.”

Advertise with us

Meta Mesh has big news on the horizon, Mr. Longwill said, as it solicits “high-end donors” of bandwidth to feed into its networks. He said he is in talks with internet service providers “who say, OK, we want to do this. We have loads of bandwidth, you can have a little bit.”

“We’re not trying to became an “internet service provider,’” he said. “We’re simply trying to light up public spaces with wifi.”

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.