Two simple solutions are offered for generating the hundreds of billions of dollars needed to restore the nation’s debilitated infrastructure.
We can either tax the hell out of the rich or turn the problem over to the private sector.
As difficult as it may be for ideologues on either end of the spectrum to accept, neither solution is practical.
Higher taxes “just wouldn’t generate enough money,” said David Dzombak, who teaches civil and environmental engineering at Carnegie Mellon University.
Public/private partnerships, which are complex, long-term arrangements transferring infrastructure responsibilities from government to profit-motivated investors, can work. But very often they don’t.
“They’re not a panacea,” said Steve Ellis of Taxpayers for Common Sense, a Washington, D.C., watchdog group. “They’re not going to fix everything. If not properly structured, they can end up costing taxpayers more.”
So where will the money come from?
“There is actually only one source of money for infrastructure. That’s you and me,” said Donald Cohen of In the Public Interest, a Washington, D.C., think tank that analyzes terms of privatization deals.
While Mr. Cohen believes public/private partnerships, or P3s, can work, there frequently are problems with them, he said. An example of one of the most problematic partnerships is the Indiana Toll Road, which went bankrupt eight years into a 75-year privatization deal that turned the highway over to private investors. Among other problems, traffic and toll revenue from the venture did not meet the projections used to finance the $3.8 billion deal.
Mr. Cohen finds it curious that the investors did not see that coming.
“People are price sensitive. You raise the tolls, they’ll find another road. Don’t they know how markets work?” he asked.
Still, people remain interested in P3s for several reasons. There is little appetite for tax increases. Private investors seeking double-digit returns are eager to provide the cash. And the theory that the private sector can be more efficient and innovative than government is appealing.
“We need to engage a lot more private financing. There’s no other way to meet it,” Mr. Dzombak said. “There is a lot of private capital around looking for private investment opportunity.”
Mr. Ellis believes more funding would be available if users paid their fair share of the costs. One example he cited are barge operators. While they pay a 29-cent per gallon diesel fuel tax to fund half of the cost of major lock and dam rebuilding projects, barge operators pay nothing toward the cost of operating and maintaining the facilities, he said.
Another example is the federal highway trust fund, which is financed by an 18.4-cent federal gas tax that has not been increased since 1993. Mr. Ellis said more than $1 trillion in general tax revenues have been transferred to the fund to pay for costs that road users should be shouldering.
Because more fuel-efficient cars have dented gas tax revenue, Oregon and other states are experimenting with taxes based on miles driven in an effort to make users pay their share. Meanwhile, Pennsylvania and other states are increasing their gas taxes to make up for the lack of federal funds.
“States, even conservative states, are realizing they have to pay for things,” Mr. Cohen said.
President Donald Trump’s $1 trillion infrastructure plan relies on privatization. It includes tax credits designed to encourage private investors to fund infrastructure improvements.
“The idea of tax credits is insane,” Mr. Cohen said. “Basically, you’re going to give away money and fund it, and they’re going to make money on it. That’s Orwellian finance.”
After eight years during which President Barack Obama’s most ambitious infrastructure proposals were rejected or pared down by fiscal-minded Republicans, many question whether conservative Republicans will support Mr. Trump’s big spending plan. The Democrats’ counter proposal would be funded by closing tax loopholes used by corporations and the wealthy.
Infrastructure’s higher profile of late could indicate Washington might actually do something about it. But with contentious debates over tax reform, Social Security and Medicare also on the agenda, and a standoff between those who want higher taxes and those who want to turn public assets over to profit-motivated investors, don’t bet on it.
Len Boselovic: lboselovic@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1941.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.