By March 2010, when Consol Energy Inc. announced a $3.5 billion deal that would trampoline its ambitions in the Marcellus Shale, Michael Dudas, a mining and metals analyst, felt he was covering a much different company than when he first started.
It was the first thing he told Consol’s then-CEO Brett Harvey during a call with analysts to unpack the oil and gas deal.
But Mr. Harvey downplayed the transformation he would later tout.
“Yeah. It has changed. But you know what? We still have 4.5 billion tons of coal,” he told Mr. Dudas.
A few minutes later, he returned to the thought to make something absolutely clear.
“We’re not going out of the coal business. We’re entering a low-cost gas business. And it’s making our company bigger and stronger.”
Mr. Harvey predicted five years of growth in the gas side of the company would be followed by a decade of growth in coal.
“It all depends on the economy and what we need,” he said. “It’s a play in energy, not in coal or gas.”
The company Mr. Dudas covers today is a far cry from the one he found hard to recognize six years ago.
Its coal reserves have shrunk by 42 percent. Instead of more than a dozen mines, it now operates a single complex in southwestern Pennsylvania and a smaller mine in West Virginia, having sold five mines to Murray Energy Corp. in 2013. It also shed its metallurgical coal-producing Buchanan Mine in early 2016. Instead of 8,000 employees, Consol has around 2,900. At one point, nearly half of its workers were unionized. Today, there are none.
At every appropriate moment, the Cecil-based company makes sure to remind observers of its transformation into a “pure play” exploration and production company. That coal still makes up more than half of its revenue is a postscript.
“I want to be as clear as we can,” Nick DeIuliis, who took over as Consol’s CEO in May 2014, told analysts shortly thereafter. “Who are we? We’re a growing [exploration and production] company that’s focused on developing the Appalachian shales.” The “best in class” coal assets the company still owns serve to finance its oil and gas aspirations, he said.
For the past decade, since natural gas began playing an increasing and eventually dominant role in the company, it has been difficult to categorize Consol. That’s not just a mental exercise. Figuring out where a company fits into an industry determines how much its executives get paid, how it measures success, and what metrics analysts use to evaluate its worth.
“When it’s all blended together, it’s hard to figure out who do you compare it against,” said Evan Mann, a credit analyst with Gimme Credit.
Less than half of the equity analysts that cover Consol are oil and gas specialists, up from a third last year. Most analyze metals, mining and industrial companies; and the metrics they use are not the language of oil and gas.
Mr. Mann, for example, still sorts Consol in his metals and mining group, “but I should probably put them into energy,” he said.
Undervalued, underappreciated
The company has struggled to educate its analysts and investors on how to properly evaluate it and has frequently overhauled its peer group of companies against which it benchmarks its executive compensation packages.
“The scarcity of companies similar to Consol makes it more difficult for the market to value our diverse holdings of coal and gas assets, which leads to a more complex business than most, if not all, of our peers,” the company’s proxy statement has said for the past three years.
The inability of the market to give Consol its due has been a long-running theme on company earnings calls. As far back as 2010, Mr. Harvey told analysts at an industry conference that its divisions are undervalued and underappreciated.
“We run at a discount compared to some of our peers,” he said. “Part of it is because we look like a conglomerate in energy. Part of it, it’s hard to understand some of the pieces.”
Spinning out the pieces
To clarify the value of its distinct parts, Consol has spun out three publicly-traded companies in the past 10 years. In 2006, it launched CNX Gas, which it reabsorbed back into the mothership four years later. In 2014, Consol and its Marcellus and Utica joint venture partner Noble Energy Corp. spun out Cone Midstream Partners, a master limited partnership that owns pipelines and compression assets.
Last year, in the face of virtually unanimous puzzlement from analysts, Consol carved out CNX Coal, a master limited partnership that holds a 20 percent interest in the Bailey mine complex in southwestern Pennsylvania, in an effort to prove its worth to investors and better delineate the value of the company’s gas business.
It’s hard to evaluate the success of Consol’s transformation as the shift unfolded during major changes in energy markets which, in the short term at least, spelled a collapse in oil, gas and coal prices, said Mr. Mann.
“You couldn’t have picked a worse time,” he said.
Consol’s original idea was to take the money being generated by the profitable coal business and pump it into growing its natural gas arm, he said.
“The strategy made sense,” Mr. Mann said. “Nobody expected either of these commodities to get as bad as [they] did.”
In June 2014, a note from Iberia Capital told investors to pile up shares of Consol’s stock as the coal business has likely reached its bottom, “is profitable now, and thus ‘either makes some or a lot of cash flow’ over the [industry’s] cycles.”
The note implied that any opportunity to buy Consol stock at less than $45 per share was a steal.
But coal demand and prices continued to decline in 2015 and Consol found itself losing money on both sides of the business. Its stock price cratered, hitting a low of $4.99 per share on Jan. 15.
So Consol remains undervalued, according to its management.
The coal spinout was “an important first step, and we plan to continue to drop interest into [it] over time,” said Brian Aiello, a spokesperson for Consol. “We believe the markets are not affording proper value to either side of our enterprise, and that our ultimate goal is the separation of our E&P and coal business.”
So did its transformation strategy work?
“Given the nature of current commodity prices, it is difficult to fully analyze at the moment,” Mr. Aiello said about the coal spin-out, “but we believe strongly that the overall strategy is the correct one.”
Mr. Mann agreed.
“When you look forward, to me, it seems like natural gas is going to be a better place to be than coal,” he said. “So at least they moved to the right spot.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.