It was voted the most overused piece of business jargon in 2015 — transformation.
More tiresome than “disruptive” and “human capital” and even “millennial,” according to a survey of 900 business leaders by U.K. consulting firm Brand Learning.
And overuse isn’t even the worst of it.
“When executives use the word transformation, they scare the pants off people,” said Robert Goldberg, managing partner with Greensboro-based Organization Insight LLC.
Is that code for layoffs, workers wonder?
The fear is not altogether unfounded. For example, the “transformational journey” that U.S. Steel embarked on in 2014 has resulted in the disappearance of hundreds of jobs.
Read More
Mr. Goldberg traces it back to the 1980s, when companies in restructuring started leaning heavily on transformation jargon while their plants and offices purged workers.
Now, a word that’s meant to signal excitement, momentum and opportunity has often come to mean that something is wrong.
And yet change is the most necessary and constant state for a successful business.
“Transformation, it’s very in right now,” Mr. Goldberg said, and often it’s a poor choice of words.
“A caterpillar transforms,” he said. “But a company that’s banking in one way and then banking in another way, they’re evolving.”
So much for PNC Bank’s “retail transformation,” a move away from traditional bank branches toward tellerless ones, which also comes with obvious job losses.
If a retailer used to sell T-shirts in stores but now also sells them online, that’s not a transformation, Mr. Goldberg said. It’s adapting to the reality of online commerce.
But American Eagle Outfitters sees it as something bigger and more fundamental. The South Side-based retailer’s move to combine its retail and online sales infrastructure resulted in new facilities, a major shift in how orders are filled, and a corresponding improvement in revenue.
It was, executives said, a transformational decision.
In the past, Mr. Goldberg spent a lot more time cringing when he heard companies using the “T” word. But he’s come to realize that if the change radically alters someone’s experience of his or her job, it might well be transformative.
“It really is in the eye of the beholder,” he allowed.
In the past year, a dozen Pittsburgh-based public companies have referred to some kind of transformation.
For II-VI, it’s a “quality transformation.” For GNC, a “cultural transformation.” Consol Energy Inc. is trudging through a “strategic transformation” to convert itself into an oil and gas exploration and production company. At Kennametal, a “supply chain transformation” and an “operational transformation” are afoot.
“One transformation at a time, please,” cautions Kim Hanson, a Rhode Island-based change management consultant with On the Same Page LLC.
She isn’t so much irked by the word. But Ms. Hanson knows that when companies launch too many transformational initiatives at a time, workers and investors get fatigued. And confused.
“Pull it all together under one umbrella and tell the whole story,” she said. “You call it one thing — one campaign that has many parts. If you combine it together, it will also make more sense to investors and customers.”
For CVS, the drugstore chain-turned-behemoth healthcare company, the one decision that pulled together its decade-long transformation came in 2014. That’s when CVS became the first drugstore chain to stop selling cigarettes.
CVS’s head of retail, Helena Foulkes, told the New York Times last year that quitting tobacco was “the most important decision we’d made as a company.” After billions of dollars of acquisitions that made CVS the largest prescription drug dispenser and the largest operator of health clinics, dropping a single product from its shelves became an anthem for its transformation. It made the new direction tangible to the world.
“That decision really became a symbol both internally and externally for the fact that we’re a health care company,” Ms. Foulkes told the newspaper.
Making sure employees, customers, and investors understand what is driving a company’s transformation is the difference between panic and excitement, Ms. Hanson said.
“In reality, any company that isn’t going through some type of change, it’s very possible they’re not going to survive,” she said. “Creating something new is always full of possibilities and as long as you share the whole story, people will understand that.”
Ideally, they’ll even think it’s cool, she said.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.