As the supervising attorney at the University of Pittsburgh’s environmental law clinic, Emily Collins saw that the need for environmental legal services for people of modest means in the region was far greater than the clinic could meet alone.
At the same time, she saw that her students faced a perilous gap of their own as they prepared to enter a legal profession that offered few jobs and little advanced training for lawyers just beginning their careers.
“There needed to be some kind of solution out there to fill the gap in the services,” she said.
So she started something new.
In 2013, Ms. Collins founded Fair Shake Environmental Legal Services, a Pittsburgh-based nonprofit that helps underserved low- and middle-income clients address environmental issues while training new lawyers to build their own practices with a similar focus. She left the university to become the firm’s executive director and managing attorney when it opened last year.
Fair Shake has two offices, in Lawrenceville and in Akron, Ohio, and employs seven attorneys: Ms. Collins, a senior attorney, a staff attorney and four new lawyers who will spend two years as resident attorneys at the firm representing clients and being mentored as they develop plans for their own businesses.
In that way, Fair Shake is a unique combination of a post-graduate legal residency program and an incubator for future firms, two trends in the legal profession that aim to smooth the unsettled path between law school and employment or a stable practice for young lawyers.
Jamie Baker Roskie, a Fair Shake board member and a clinical legal education scholar who writes about law firm incubators, said the “genius” of the incubator movement is in building a long-overdue post-graduate training infrastructure to prepare new attorneys for the business of being a lawyer while also serving clients for whom legal services might otherwise be out of reach.
“Medicine has public teaching hospitals,” she said. “Law doesn’t have anything like that.”
Even in the relatively new arena of legal incubators, Fair Shake is different, she said: It stands apart because of its paid residency program, its environmental focus, its multiple regional offices, its independence — it isn’t hosted by a law school or bar association — and the depth of its foundation funding.
It received startup support in the form of an $800,000 grant from the Heinz Endowments, as well as grants from the Colcom Foundation and the George Gund Foundation.
“To start Fair Shake at this scale and get these funders to buy in — trust me, nobody else in the country right now has gotten anybody to do what these funders have done for Emily,” Ms. Roskie said.
Ms. Collins describes the firm’s target clients as people with too much income to qualify for legal aid but not enough to afford the high hourly rates that lawyers normally charge.
Fair Shake’s lawyers represent people who need legal help but who would not necessarily know to ask for it. The firm also represents public interest groups, small businesses, local governments or community associations.
“As a whole, I don’t think lawyers have been extremely good at thinking about business models in a comprehensive way to address folks who can’t pay top dollar,” she said.
While some of the cases the firm has taken up might have the precedent-setting potential that large environmental organizations seek out, that is not Fair Shake’s motivation. Instead, its goal is to help people navigate the routine but often bewildering experience of objecting to a permit, commenting on a proposed regulation, contesting a violation notice or filing a lawsuit over environmental harm.
The firm focuses on educating communities about their rights and how to participate in environmental decisions.
Half of Fair Shake’s cases so far have related to oil and gas development, but the firm has also handled matters to do with coal mining, wastewater, air quality, property transactions, hazardous waste, civil rights and the environmental rights described in Pennsylvania’s constitution.
In less than a year, the firm received about 140 requests for services — a nearly overwhelming number for a startup nonprofit firm that is navigating a course toward greater self-sufficiency while still trying to establish that its model works.
“We’re still kind of in the proof-of-concept phase,” Ms. Collins said. “It’s an interesting place to be, where you’re figuring out the conundrum of being sustainable while teaching others to do the same.”
Ryan Hamilton, a resident attorney who ultimately wants to open his own firm with a focus on community sustainability, said Fair Shake provides a relatively safe structure for building skills and trying out business ideas before he assumes those risks on his own.
“Fair Shake gives me a chance to experiment a little bit in learning those areas of law and also starting to practice in them,” he said. “I don’t know of anyone else that I graduated with that’s doing exactly this.”
Ms. Collins said one version of success might mean Fair Shake puts itself out of existence by spawning enough new practices to meet the need for equal and affordable access to environmental legal representation in the region.
That won’t happen soon. In mid-February, she said, she reported to funders that the firm could double or triple its original goal of increasing legal services by 25 percent in the first two years based on the response it has gotten so far.
“Surely it’s not just that we have a Web page,” she said. “Surely it’s that the need is that great, that people really are searching for help.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.