Sitting in a diner in Oklahoma City in March 2009, the day before her Pitt team would lose to Oklahoma in the NCAA women's basketball Sweet 16, coach Agnus Berenato took a few minutes to look ahead and talk about what seemed like a bright future for the Panthers program.
At that time, she and many others believed the Panthers were on the verge of becoming one of the elite programs in women's college basketball, even though they were graduating a highly successful senior class that included Shavonte Zellous, one of the best players in school history.
There was good reason for optimism. The program had been to the postseason for four consecutive seasons and had a strong group of sophomores that were key contributors to consecutive Sweet 16 teams.
It was actually the beginning of the end of the Berenato era of Pitt women's basketball.
That era ended Monday when Berenato was fired on the heels of a second consecutive winless conference season. Such a move seemed impossible just a few years ago given the success of the program and popularity of the coach.
So, how did the program fall so far, so fast?
The answers are simple: The players who were sophomores in 2008-09 never lived up to expectations, and two lost recruiting classes were followed by more misses in recruiting and too much attrition of players and staff.
The problems began in 2009-10 season, when juniors Shayla Scott, Taneisha Harrison, Chelsea Cole and Jania Sims, who had returned from injury, tried to build on the success and experience from the two Sweet 16 runs.
But that class, which was supposed to take the baton from the class of Zellous and Xenia Stewart and take the program to new heights, never came close to fulfilling its potential for a variety of reasons.
Chemistry issues between some of the players helped undermine the 2009-10 team, and the Panthers finished 16-15 and were knocked out of the WNIT by Toledo.
The class didn't do any better the next year, and had two more key departures, Brittaney Thomas and Sophronia Sallard. As a result, the team finished the 2010-11 season 14-17, a far cry from what Berenato had envisioned from that senior group.
But members of that class for the most part finished their careers at Pitt, which is more than can be said for those in the next two recruiting classes. For a variety of reasons, all left the program before they significantly contributed to it.
That's why that 2009-10 team had six juniors or redshirt juniors and two freshmen -- and no sophomores -- and why the next season's team had seven freshmen and redshirt freshmen and four seniors, and nothing in between except for sophomore Abby Dowd, who transferred from Buffalo.
That led to consecutive teams of underclassmen -- many of whom were reaches in recruiting and have not proven to be good enough to play and succeed in a conference as tough as the Big East.
The team was 0-16 in the Big East in 2011-12 and duplicated the feat in 2012-13. Pitt's record was 5-46 in its last 51 Big East games. With no solid help coming in the form of highly regarded recruits, there is no reason to believe next year would be much better in the Atlantic Coast Conference.
There are two legitimate Big East/ACC players left on the roster in Asia Logan and Brianna Kiesel, but the next coach will have to rebuild significantly even though all players from this past season will return.
Along the way Berenato also lost key assistants in Shea Ralph, Jeff Williams and Caroline McCombs. Each was a major loss for different reasons.
The key loss was Williams, who became the head coach at La Salle in 2010. The associate head coach was a bulldog recruiter with an eye for talent and the connections to identify and land good players. He also had the unique combination of tough love and a shoulder to lean on that made him popular with players.
Berenato reloaded her staff with some quality assistants, but, by that point, the program was slipping, the roster had too many holes and too much youth. The free fall was coming, and Berenato was unable to stop it.
Although things ended poorly, Berenato leaves Pitt as the school's all-time leader in wins. She led Pitt to its only NCAA tournaments and is the only coach to lead the Panthers to five consecutive winning seasons.
She never built on that success by turning it into high-level recruiting success, especially after the loss of Williams.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.