The jurors hearing the criminal case of state Sen. Jane Orie have gone home for the evening and will return at 9 a.m. Sunday to continue deliberations.
The jury told the judge at about 6 p.m. that they were at a "serious impasse." The judge told them to keep deliberating, but after another hour and 45 minutes the jury broke for dinner and returned to their hotel.
The jury had to weigh evidence on 24 counts against the McCandless Republican alleging she used her legislative staff to do campaign work.
The trial began Feb. 29.
The seven women and five men began deliberating on counts of theft of services, ethics violations, tampering with evidence, perjury and forgery about 3 p.m. Thursday.
The light in the jury room went off around 6 p.m., signaling that the jury had either reached a verdict or had a question for Judge Jeffrey A. Manning. Jurors told the judge that they were not able to reach a verdict. Judge Manning instructed them to continue trying.
The jurors did not describe the impasse, but one male juror was crying in the courtroom when the jury came back to tell the judge of their problems. A male juror asked Judge Manning if the jury could find Orie guilty on some counts and not guilty on others, and the judge said they could.
Defense attorney William Costopoulos said, "The jury appears to have sent a message that they are at an impasse and with great reluctance that would normally constitute a mistrial. The truth of the matter is I don't know if anybody wants a mistrial. We've been here four weeks, this is the second time in two years we've been here four weeks. A mistrial would allow a reprosecution for the third time, and I can tell you, I don't think anybody wants that. Certainly not the defense."
The jury began deliberating Thursday afternoon, continued all day Friday until 11 p.m., and Saturday from 9 a.m. until they signaled that they wished to speak to the judge.
On Friday, the jury foreperson sent the judge three questions, all pertaining to election law violations against Ms. Orie.
The questions pertained to counts 15 and 16 in the second case filed against the senator in August.
"Is count 15 pertaining to the allegation that Sen. Orie did not sign or have notarized the 2006 campaign finance report?" read the first question.
The second question then asked if count 16 "pertains to the allegation that an in-kind contribution was not reported in 2006?"
The third question asked if the jurors should have the relevant exhibits, and informed the court that they did not.
In answering the questions, Judge Manning instructed the jurors to re-read his instructions on the charges, and also told them that new copies of the relevant exhibits would be provided.
After court recessed, defense attorney William Costopoulos said it's impossible to predict what the questions mean.
"I can tell you, unequivocally, the worst thing you can do is put a spin on it and see what direction they're headed," he said, as Ms. Orie stood beside him.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.