There is good reason for state GOP leaders to mull every option -- including postponing Pennsylvania's April 24 primary -- in the face of decade-old district lines. The old lines are an unexpected boon for Democrats and in a presidential year give the minority party a fighting chance to take back leadership in the General Assembly.
As the subject of legislative reapportionment may trigger narcolepsy, here is the state of play recast in movie terms:
Republicans are Kevin Bacon at the end of "Animal House" trying to face down a riot. "Remain calm. All is well!" his character says, before being flattened like a pancake.
Democrats are Jim Carrey in "Dumb & Dumber," after his dream girl says he has a one in a million chance of dating her.
"So you're telling me there's a chance," a smiling Lloyd Christmas responds.
A four-member majority of the state Supreme Court on Jan. 25 rejected newly drafted boundaries for the state's House and Senate districts, and ordered lines set in 2001 to remain in place until revised maps are approved.
Map-drafters in the state Capitol were expected to submit new proposed boundaries to the chairman of the Legislative Reapportionment Commission last week. That panel -- made up of the four leaders of the legislative caucuses and the chairman, Judge Stephen McEwen -- is to vote on a preliminary plan Wednesday.
Despite those lightning-speed steps toward Legislative Map 2.0, the next steps of allowing for public comment and a period for legal challenges will take at least two months to complete. Between that timeline and the dozens of unopposed Republican lawmakers likely averse to reopening the primary ballot, it is looking more likely that this year's elections will be held using those old boundaries.
Top Harrisburg Republicans are still giving themselves leeway on how the primary process will unfold, despite the fact that the deadline for filing ballot petitions was Thursday. The Senate majority leader said when the Supreme Court opinion was released that the primary date was "in jeopardy," though there have been no public steps yet toward adjusting it.
Changing the primary date would require a bill approved by both GOP-controlled chambers and signed by the governor.
"The legal and legislative options are still under review," said Erik Arneson, spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, on whether the April contest might be delayed.
His counterpart in the House, Steve Miskin, reiterated the goal of using the new maps for this year's contests: "The goal is still to have an April 24 primary, but we'll see what happens."
Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati said altering that date could be politically dangerous, and viewed by the public as a selfish move.
"I'm not ruling it out, but we better be very cautious before we do it," said Mr. Scarnati, R-Jefferson. "I'm not so sure that the voters are going to be supportive of that."
He said the presidential balloting also occurring on April 24 should be a factor as well, particularly after the past efforts to increase the state's role in that contest.
Proceeding with the election as planned -- and chancing that they will in fact be running for their currently drawn seats -- would be a boon to his Senate Democratic opponents, Mr. Scarnati conceded.
Democrats are trying to take further advantage by seeking to force House Speaker Sam Smith, R-Punxsutawney, into scheduling special elections for six empty House seats using the old lines, four of which are held by their party. Lawyers in Philadelphia filed a suit Friday asking the state Supreme Court to trigger the elections.
Under the 2001 lines locally, Democratic seats in both chambers that were set to move east are still in place. Two suburban Pittsburgh Democratic seats that were supposed to be combined are still separate.
Generally, candidates are not exactly sure which municipalities are in their districts, or which side of the state their district will be on if and when maps are approved. Deadlines for filing for office and challenging petitions are now running on a separate track from those running for federal or statewide positions.
Statewide, remapping efforts to further protect GOP incumbents at the expense of Democrats have been pulled back.
Chris Nicholas, the political director for the Pennsylvania Business Council and a longtime GOP operative, said "in general Republicans loathe the 2001 as compared to the 2011 discarded maps. Democrats were going from bad to worse -- now they're going backwards from worse to bad."
Redistricting, when successful, "locks in the status quo and the status quo benefits Republicans," he said.
For Democrats, said Muhlenberg College political scientist Chris Borick, "If you look at the picture as a whole and take it each district by district, it's pretty clear the 2001 lines are preferable to the ones [Republicans] just came up with."
"Given the right political climate it could open doors for them to make it competitive," he said, though probably more so in the House then in the Senate.
Though numbers are in flux due to some vacant seats, the GOP enjoys a 10-seat advantage in the 50-member Senate and a 21-seat edge in the 203-member House. To take over, House Democrats would need to hold all their current seats and win back 11 held by the other side.
They plan to look first at winning back seats taken over by the GOP in their 2010 midterm wave year, when they won back House leadership. That includes the District 39 and 56 seats lost respectively by Dave Levdansky, D-Forward, and James Casorio, D-North Huntingdon.
"It's a tall order, but as Republicans showed last election it can be done," said state Rep. Brendan Boyle, D-Philadelphia, the chair of the House Democratic Campaign Committee.
His GOP campaign counterpart, state Rep. Dave Reed, R-Indiana, said his party would battle back by targeting up to eight seats Democrats won by fewer than 1,000 votes in 2010. The rejected maps would have better protected Western Pennsylvania Democrats Frank Dermody of Oakmont and Joe Markosek of Monroeville, Mr. Reed added, so the old maps make those districts more competitive for the GOP.
"I'm not sure there's a huge advantage either way," he said, but acknowledged "the new districts certainly would have changed the dynamic for us."
Senate Democrats are targeting eight Republican-held seats that show underlying Democratic performance, under statistics compiled by the National Committee for an Effective Congress, a Democratic consulting firm.
They include the 49th District seat being vacated by Jane Earll in Erie; the 47th held by Elder Vogel, largely in Beaver and Lawrence counties; and the 15th District in the middle of the state, which had been set to lose Democratic-voting Harrisburg.
"Running on the 2001 lines will provide an unprecedented opportunity for Pennsylvanians to elect candidates without the partisan gerrymandering that has been a part of the process for too long," said Aren Platt, spokesman for the Senate Democratic Campaign Committee.
Democrats are also hoping for some presidential year magic, when turnout increases for both parties, but more for their side. Where 20,000 might vote in an off-year House election, roughly 27,000 pull the digital lever in a presidential year, said Mr. Boyle, the Philadelphia legislator.
"The confluence of a big turnout year and older district lines are clearly an advantage for Democrats in what could have otherwise been a soft year," Mr. Borick said.
Republicans took over the state House in 1994, the "Republican Revolution" year, while Democrats won it with their own 2006 and 2008 waves. It swung back two years ago and the reapportionment mess looks to weigh on whatever happens this year.
"I expect in 2012 everything to even out," said Mr. Reed, the Indiana Republican. "When the pendulum stops swinging we'll see where Pennsylvania really is."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.