For some, Thursday's night basketball game between Pitt and West Virginia -- the 184th between them -- was the Backyard Bawl.

For no one knows how long, the Petersen Events Center contest served as the longtime rivals' last meeting in the NCAA's two major sports after more than a century spent competing with unusual ferocity -- among fans as much or more than players.

"I feel like I lost a chapter in my life," said WVU Alumni Association president Steve Douglas. "It is a very sad day."

"I truly enjoy going down to West Virginia and having them come up," said Pitt alumnus Tom Bailey, a season ticket-holder in both football and basketball who now wonders if his motor home has made its last trip down Interstate 79 to tailgate in Morgantown.

Advertise with us

West Virginia is departing the Big East Conference later this year for the Big 12. Pitt makes its own jump within a year or two for the Atlantic Coast Conference.

Considering the two schools' history and proximity (75 miles), it seems unfathomable to some fans that officials wouldn't work out a plan to continue competing through regular nonconference match-ups. But that assumption ignores some of the realities of modern, big-time college scheduling, finances, contracts and -- perhaps in this case as well -- egos.

"It was a fun series. In distance, Pitt is closer to Morgantown than it is to State College," observed Beano Cook, the ESPN analyst whose Pitt loyalties stretch back to undergraduate days there in the early 1950s.

"But if they don't play, life goes on," he noted. "Look, Penn State dropped Pitt [from its regular football schedule after 2000], and Pitt's still here."

Between three dozen and four dozen Pitt students skipped classes Thursday afternoon so they could line up in the lobby of the Petersen Events Center hours before the game, hoping to catch good seats for what few wanted to be the last Backyard Brawl.

Advertise with us

"It's our biggest rival. It's the team you want to beat the most," said Ben Wachsman, a 20-year-old junior from Lancaster, who said he stumbled into the rivalry when he began attending Pitt.

Few of the students sitting on the lobby floor Thursday said they could pinpoint reasons for the rivalry, but many said they had a true hatred for WVU and the city of Morgantown.

"There's really not much difference between us, but there's just so much tradition there, you have to hate them," said Kiersten Williams, a 21-year-old junior.

The loss of the rivalry, several students said, will be devastating.

"It just does a lot to bring the students together," junior Sarah Pierotti said. "It says a lot about your school spirit."

Advertise with us

In Morgantown, the Mountain Maniacs, a student fan club, rented a local theater for 100 or more people to watch the basketball game and make a party out of it.

"It's a big game for us, and it could be the last one for a while," said Steve Staffileno, president of the club. "We definitely would not want to miss this chance for everyone to watch it together."

Alumni of the schools who have followed the series closely since before those current collegians were born agreed on two things:

• The Backyard Brawl, while circled boldly on calendars at both schools, carries more meaning in West Virginia. The thought of Pitt stirs Mountaineers fans more than any other opponent, whereas the Panthers' supporters remain more likely to get worked up about Penn State -- even without playing them the past 11 years. (Pitt and Penn State are scheduled to play football again in 2016 and 2017.)

• The intensity of the football series between Pitt and WVU is more responsible for the "brawl" coinage than is the basketball series. Recent years' success of both the Panthers and Mountaineers in basketball has created some great games and memories, but they are outweighed by football games with national standings in packed, frenzied stadiums.

Advertise with us

Few in either camp will ever forget the 13-9 Pitt upset on Dec. 1, 2007, that derailed WVU's national championship hopes that year.

The athletic directors and coaches from the two schools have acknowledged the value of their competition, but have also been careful to point out potential complications in continuing it.

Plus, there are possible hard feelings in Morgantown from Pitt's surprise announcement it would bolt the Big East, before WVU confirmed it was leaving. The difference in scheduling the two sports makes it more likely basketball could resume sooner than football, though nothing is certain.

"Both of them are crazy if they don't resume it on a nonconference basis," said Mickey Furfari, 88, a sportswriter in Morgantown who has covered the rivalry since the 1940s. "These guys calling the shots today ought to make every effort to resume it. They won't always be there, but the institutions will."

Fans of both schools have received unruly receptions when visiting the other's home turf, but Mr. Furfari said, "I think the fans here love Pitt. They might say they hate Pitt, but they don't hate Pitt. They love these games."

Advertise with us

Longtime Pitt broadcaster Bill Hillgrove isn't so sure about that. He recalls the first three words his daughter ever spoke, "Eat %&• # Pitt," which she repeated when with him on a Pitt team bus after listening to that jeering chant as the Panthers bus pulled up to WVU Coliseum years ago.

"There's a hate factor there that I don't think is prevalent in anything else Pitt is involved in," Mr. Hillgrove said before Thursday night's game. "I think people in Morgantown grow up learning to hate Pitt, and I've had friends from there tell me that. ... That has added to the series, no question, but I think there's less of that on Pitt's side than on West Virginia's side."

The head of the Pittsburgh chapter of WVU's Alumni Association, Bryan Bond, 33, said he's felt some "hard shoulder bumps" from Pitt fans when leaving Heinz Field in his WVU garb after a game.

"It's been students, not people of my age," said the Forest Hills resident, originally from Fairmont, W.Va. "At the Pete, it's just more normal, fun ribbing, because you don't have the massive influx like at Heinz Field, where everyone's outside tailgating and then all coming in all at once."

Whatever the level of intensity, the two schools' fans and teams could have a tough time duplicating it for many years in the new conferences.

Advertise with us

That's why Mr. Douglas, the other WVU alumnus, said, "Hopefully, we're only taking a two- or three-year hiatus until, once Pitt and West Virginia are settled, we can go back to systematically and logically playing this great rivalry."

Correction/Clarification: (Published February 19, 2012) West Virginia's football team had one prior loss in 2007 when Pitt defeated the Mountaineers and derailed their national title hopes. A story Friday on the possible end of the Backyard Brawl reported WVU's record incorrectly.