Tuesday likely will be decision day for answering the dual questions of which assessment numbers will be used to calculate Allegheny County property tax bills this year and whether Rich Fitzgerald, the new Democratic county executive, is violating court orders.
Common Pleas Court Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr. on Friday declined to take immediate action on a request to punish Mr. Fitzgerald following his announcement that he was throwing out new reassessment figures and instead certifying 2002 base-year property values. The new numbers already had been sent to owners of almost 150,000 parcels in the city and Mount Oliver.
Responding to Mr. Fitzgerald's Thursday announcement, Judge Wettick, who is overseeing the county's controversial reassessment project, issued his own order Friday. In it he affirmed that Pittsburgh and its school district must base their property tax rates and bills on new 2012 property values.
The issue of what numbers actually will be used for 2012 tax bills remains unclear.
In his Friday order, Judge Wettick noted that he has a status conference scheduled for 2 p.m. Tuesday. At that court session, he has agreed to consider a request from Pittsburgh Public Schools to use the base-year numbers for one more year.
But until that decision is made, Judge Wettick's order says "the City of Pittsburgh and Pittsburgh School District are barred from setting millage and calculating taxes for 2012 unless the millage and taxes are based on the 2012 assessed values."
He also will consider a request from lawyer Don Driscoll that Mr. Fitzgerald be found to be in contempt of court for declaring the new numbers "null and void."
Mr. Driscoll represents several of the property owners who sought a new assessment. "The actions taken by Mr. Fitzgerald are contrary to the orders of the court," he said Friday.
Were Mr. Fitzgerald found guilty of violating the judge's directives, his possible punishments include fines or even jail time.
Interviewed in his office late Friday afternoon, Mr. Fitzgerald said he was confident that his actions were both legal and beneficial to residents.
"We are complying with state law," he said, referring to the Second Class County Code, which requires Allegheny County to send out certified assessment numbers by Jan. 15. While new numbers are available for the city and Mount Oliver, reassessment will not be finished for the rest of the county until next month at the earliest.
"Most people are against this reassessment," he said. "I can't tell you how many letters and emails of support we've gotten." By stopping reassessment, "we're taking away a source of concern and anxiety," he said.
Mr. Fitzgerald said all reassessment should be blocked until the state Legislature develops property-valuation standards that will be uniform across Pennsylvania.
Mr. Fitzgerald said emails went out to all municipalities and school districts in the county on Friday, certifying the 2002 base-year numbers, also referred to as the 2011 numbers, for use in calculating millage rates and for sending out tax bills for this year.
City and Mount Oliver property owners, who received letters with new real estate values just before Mr. Fitzgerald took office, will be getting a second letter from the county's Office of Property Assessment confirming that their assessments have not been changed, he said.
The 2012 assessment numbers, which had been added to the assessment pages of the county website, were removed on Friday.
While Mr. Fitzgerald has canceled all informal reviews of property assessments, he has advised any residents who feel their current real estate values are too high to make a formal appeal. The deadline for taking that action is March 15.
Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl said Friday that he continues to support Mr. Fitzgerald's anti-assessment stance.
"This chaotic reassessment process has caused panic among homeowners, small business owners and all taxpayers," he said. "The 2011 [or base-year] assessment numbers must be used in 2012, and city residents and property owners must be provided with the same appeals processes and deadlines afforded to every other taxpayer of Allegheny County."
Mr. Fitzgerald said he was pleased that Judge Wettick was willing to consider delaying use of the new property values until 2013, but the better solution was a statewide assessment moratorium until the Legislature acts on uniform standards.
In addition to seeking legal sanctions against Mr. Fitzgerald, Mr. Driscoll has asked the county for more information on how the reassessment was carried out by its outside consultant, Cole Layer Trumble. Anecdotes about big errors in evaluating some city properties do not provide a clear picture of how accurate the new values are overall, he said.
Mr. Driscoll has asked the county for assessment ratio studies and the changes in total assessed values, broken down by city neighborhood and ward. Judge Wettick has told county officials to provide him with that data. Outside analysis of that information would help determine if the reassessment meets industry standards for such large projects, Mr. Driscoll said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.