HARRISBURG -- Gov. Tom Corbett is finishing up his first year in the state's top job, and, like any rookie, he got a few bumps and bruises on the political gridiron.

His most important initiative, creating state-funded vouchers for students in charter and religious schools, has stalled out despite months of pressure on legislators to enact it.

Another much-touted goal, dismantling the state Liquor Control Board and privatizing 620 state-owned stores, has been put on hold. And, so far at least, Mr. Corbett hasn't reached a compromise on fees to be paid by drillers who are making millions by pumping natural gas from underground Marcellus Shale.

He's gotten mixed reviews related to the state investigation of former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky, accused of sexually abusing boys for years. Mr. Corbett noted that he, as attorney general in 2009, started the probe, but critics say he moved too slowly and it took too long (two years) to charge Mr. Sandusky.

Advertise with us

Democrats blame him for not raising fees or taxes to repair the state's ailing bridges and roads, which would create many jobs and make traveling safer. But he argues that such moves -- at this time, with the economy still in rough shape -- would hurt people by taking money out of their pockets.

"Gov. Corbett and the Republicans who control the Legislature have failed on creating jobs and on transportation and failed to enact a fair tax on natural gas drilling companies," charged House Democratic leader Frank Dermody of Oakmont.

But there's no doubting that Mr. Corbett, who is from Shaler and is former state attorney general, also had some notable accomplishments since taking office last January.

He got his first state budget approved by the June 30 deadline -- without tax increases, as he'd pledged during his 2010 campaign. He also won praise for leading the state's response to Hurricane Irene in late August; saturation from that storm led to massive flooding, especially in northeastern Pennsylvania, from Tropical Storm Lee in September.

Republicans praised his Public Welfare Department's effort to trim thousands of recipients from state welfare rolls and for pushing for a new law that imposes tougher rules governing sex offenders.

Advertise with us

Corbett spokesman Kevin Harley, not surprisingly, sees 2011 as "a smashing success by any measure. The governor inherited a fiscal nightmare -- a $4 billion deficit from [previous Democratic Gov.] Ed Rendell -- and balanced the budget without a tax increase," using spending freezes, state employee furloughs, unfilled retiree jobs and welfare roll reductions.

•

Generally speaking, those on the right liked what they saw, while those on the left were dismayed.

"All in all, I'd say it was an excellent year, mainly due to the way he positioned the state financially -- reducing overall spending and resetting state spending levels, while not raising taxes," said Matthew Brouillette of the Commonwealth Foundation, a staunchly conservative group.

Conservatives had been sharply critical of Mr. Rendell, who increased state spending in many areas, especially education, and who pushed through an increase in the state income tax in 2003, his first year as governor.

Advertise with us

Mr. Corbett trimmed the state budget for fiscal 2011-12 to $27 billion, a drop of more than $1 billion from the previous year. Funding for public education dropped by more than $800 million, which drew criticism from teacher unions and school boards and has led to teacher layoffs across the state. Mr. Harley said the drop was caused by the federal government's decision to end federal stimulus funds in 2011 -- "that's Barack Obama, not Tom Corbett."

By getting the state budget adopted by June 30, Mr. Corbett did something that Mr. Rendell had failed to do in his eight years.

Additional cuts may be looming in Mr. Corbett's 2012-13 budget proposal, which he'll unveil in early February. State Budget Secretary Charles Zogby recently warned that state revenues could be $500 million less than projected by June 30, the end of the current fiscal year, which could force more spending freezes or cuts.

Mr. Brouillette was disappointed that school vouchers -- which he likes to call "parental choice in education" -- didn't pass, but he's still hoping Mr. Corbett will push legislators to enact it. However, many Capitol observers think the voucher idea is dead for 2012, especially since this is an election year.

Free-market advocates were also disappointed that privatization of wine and liquor sales hasn't happened.

Advertise with us

Mr. Harley said the Legislature has a two-year term "and it's only half over," so efforts for liquor privatization, vouchers and other goals will continue.

•

Democrats, liberals and environmentalists are dismayed and alarmed by some of the corporate priorities of the Corbett administration. They see him as far too close to Marcellus drilling companies, which donated nearly $1 million to his 2010 campaign.

Mr. Corbett has said the drillers are creating thousands of jobs in Pennsylvania and paying various types of business taxes, workers are paying income taxes and he doesn't want to lay another gas-drilling tax on top of them.

He is still working with the House and Senate on differing versions of a gas-drilling "fee," to be imposed either by the state or by counties where the drilling is happening, many of them in southwestern and northern Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

State Sen. Vincent Hughes. D-Philadelphia, criticized the governor for lack of action on transportation issues, with numerous reports saying roads and bridges are in poor shape. "We should be investing more in our roads, bridges, mass transit and doing more to create new jobs," Mr. Hughes said.

Rep. Joe Markosek, D-Monroeville, said he fears that for the fiscal year starting July 1, Mr. Corbett could make "another $750 million in needlessly painful cuts to our children's public schools and to critical health and safety programs."

Other Democrats have criticized the Welfare Department for removing up to 100,000 people from welfare and medical assistance, contending that many of them qualify by income for such aid and will eventually be restored.

One of Mr. Corbett's harshest critics is Tim Potts, a former Democratic legislative aide and founder of a citizens group called Democracy Rising. "This is the fifth governor I've been around for, and this was the worst first year I can recall," he said bluntly.

He was especially critical of Mr. Corbett for not pressuring legislators to be more "open and transparent" when developing the map of the 18 new Congressional districts, which wasn't shown to the public until mid-December, just before the House and Senate voted on it.

Advertise with us

"There was no opportunity for people to know what communities each district contained before the map was adopted, and it will be in force for the next 10 years," he said.

Other critics focused on Mr. Corbett's support for a different way to count Pennsylvania's 20 electoral votes in presidential election years, such as 2012. He supported a plan by GOP Senate leader Dominic Pileggi to scrap the current system, where the statewide winner gets all 20 electoral votes, and allocate the votes based on which candidate wins each congressional district.

Critics said that change would dilute Pennsylvania's influence nationally, and it appears the idea has now been shelved.

Mr. Corbett got mixed reviews for pushing the Legislature to give him power to name a "receiver" to control the debt-ridden finances of the state's capital city. Harrisburg has more than $400 million in unpaid bond issues and an annual budget that critics say is several million out of balance.

Several weeks ago Mr. Corbett named a Philadelphia lawyer, David Unkovic, to come up with a plan to restore the city's finances.

Advertise with us

This pleased state Sen. Jeffrey Piccola, R-Dauphin, and Rep. Glen Grell, R-Cumberland, who were alarmed by Harrisburg Mayor Linda Thompson's push for a commuter income tax on people who work in the city, which includes many suburbanites who are their constituents.

Mr. Grell praised the governor for insisting on a single person to head the recovery effort, rather than a committee. "The governor wanted accountability, which would have been diffused if a board was in charge," Mr. Grell said. "He deserves a lot of credit for that."

But the move for a receiver was attacked by lawyer Mark Schwartz, who was hired by four City Council members who failed to get federal bankruptcy status for Harrisburg. Mr. Schwartz said the governor should be doing more to give state aid not just to Harrisburg, but to the 20 towns in Pennsylvania that are now under the financial protection of state Act 47.