NORRISTOWN, Pa. — Attorney General Kathleen Kane was “on a mission, a mission of revenge” when she orchestrated a “cloak-and-dagger” operation to illegally leak information to vilify a critic, prosecutors said Tuesday in the opening of Ms. Kane’s trial on perjury and obstruction charges.
To the contrary, Ms. Kane was a victim grappling with lies from her former second-in-command and a political consultant who have repeatedly covered up their own roles in the leak, her defense argued before a jury in Montgomery County Common Pleas Court.
Ms. Kane, 50, was charged last year after prosecutors said she had illegally leaked secret grand jury information to embarrass former state prosecutor Frank Fina — and later lied under oath to cover it up.
“Revenge is best served cold,” said prosecutor Michelle Henry in opening statements, citing a line she attributed to Ms. Kane.
“At its core, this case is very simple,” Ms. Henry told the jury of six men and six women. “The defendant wanted to get revenge against someone.”
Ms. Kane left a trail documenting her lies and lawbreaking, Ms. Henry said, including text messages, emails and phone records that will be presented at trial.
Read More
Although the defense has portrayed Ms. Kane as a high-minded prosecutor who left the details of the leak to others, Ms. Henry described her as obsessed with Mr. Fina, once the office’s most high-profile prosecutor as the overseer of all corruption cases.
She said Ms. Kane blamed him for a 2014 article in The Philadelphia Inquirer that disclosed that Ms. Kane had secretly shut down a sting investigation without bringing charges against Philadelphia Democratic officials who were caught on tape pocketing cash from an undercover agent.
Figuring that Mr. Fina had leaked that story, Ms. Kane, Ms. Henry said, decided to give him a taste of the same, providing a different newspaper with secret grand jury information to suggest that he had mishandled a corruption case involving allegations that a Philadelphia civil rights leader had misused state money.
Ms. Henry said Ms. Kane pushed hard for the Philadelphia Daily News to publish that story, texting, “Where’s my article?” to political consultant Josh Morrow in 2014 when she grew impatient for publication.
Ms. Henry, the first assistant prosecutor in Bucks County called in to assist the Montgomery County team, provided a complex account of the action of two key government witnesses — Mr. Morrow and Adrian King, Ms. Kane’s first deputy attorney general.
The two men each helped get the confidential material to the Daily News, though Mr. King says he had no idea that he was serving as a courier of such information.
For one thing, Ms. Henry said, they may minimize their own roles in the leak when they take the stand. For another, she said, Mr. Morrow had conspired with Ms. Kane at one point to pin the entire crime on Mr. King.
Now Mr. Morrow appears to be fully aligned with the prosecution. It was revealed Tuesday that he has been given immunity from prosecution in return for his testimony.
But defense lawyer Gerald Shargel promised a bruising cross-examination of Mr. Morrow, Mr. King, and other former top aides to Ms. Kane. He accused prosecutors of whitewashing the aides’ own “perjury. “They lied about their own involvement,” he said.
Although the prosecution said the case boiled down to an ugly feud between Ms. Kane and Mr. Fina, Mr. Shargel said the attorney general barely knew him and their overlapping time in office amounted to little more than a 10-minute meeting during her first week in office.
“The attorney general cared not one whit about Frank Fina,” Mr. Shargel said.
Ms. Kane is also accused of lying to the grand jury. Ms. Henry ticked off a litany of her alleged lies, including her statement that she had never signed a secrecy oath prohibiting her from disclosing the leaked information and that she had not read the newspaper article based on the leaked documents until months after it was published.
Mr. Shargel acknowledged some misstatements by Ms. Kane in his opening arguments Tuesday, calling them an “honest mistake.”
For example, he said the attorney general simply forgot that she signed a secrecy oath in her first week of office, saying it had slipped her mind as one event among many in a tumultuous week. Prosecutors recovered the oath months after Ms. Kane testified that she had signed no such document.
Mr. Shargel also acknowledged that Ms. Kane “wanted to get the story out,” regarding Mr. Fina and the probe of the civil rights leader. But he insisted that Ms. Kane did not select the grand jury material that made its way to the Daily News.
“Let me be clear: Attorney General Kathleen Kane did not leak any grand jury material,” Mr. Shargel said. “It just does not make sense that she would risk her reputation and her career.”
Under questioning from District Attorney Kevin R. Steele, Montgomery County Detective Paul Bradbury, the first witness in the trial, detailed key evidence gathered in the case, including emails, phone records, and documents from the grand jury that investigated the leak and referred the case to the Montgomery County District Attorney’s office.
“This is war,” Ms. Kane wrote in one email, sent on the morning the Inquirer published its article on the aborted sting. Her media consultant, J.J. Balaban, advised her to “make war with Fina but not with the Inquirer.”
Bruce Beemer, who served as Ms. Kane’s first deputy from 2014 until last month, testified about his stunned reaction when he saw the Daily News article that was based on secret grand jury information.
“I was shocked,” he said. “I couldn’t believe it.”
Mr. Beemer said he worried that the leak had come from the attorney general’s office.
His testimony is to resume this morning.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.