At one point, state Rep. Jake Wheatley was facing three rivals in his bid to be re-elected to the 19th House District. Now he faces just one, Allentown social worker Jessica Wolfe. But she’s seeking to remove him from the April 26 ballot.
Earlier this week, Ms. Wolfe filed a lawsuit challenging some 1,447 of the 1,728 signatures Mr. Wheatley’s campaign gathered on its election petitions. If all those challenges are successful, it would leave Mr. Wheatley with 281 signatures — 19 short of the 300 he needs to qualify for the ballot.
“The overabundance of evidence shows that [the petitions] were done improperly,” said Ms. Wolfe.
Petition challenges often focus on the signatures of the voters who sign them. But Ms. Wolfe’s complaint focuses on the notaries who, by law, must notarize each petition.
The Wolfe filing alleges that there are problems with three of notaries used by Mr. Wheatley’s campaign. On 76 pages handled by two Pittsburgh notaries, the complaint charges, petitions were stamped but not signed by the notaries themselves, as the law requires. The complaint alleges that based “on information and believe,” the failure to include a signature “was in bad faith and/or was done to deceive the public.”
One of the two notaries named, Andrea Watson, denied that.
“There was no malicious intent at all,” she said Wednesday evening. “This was my first time handling petitions. I just forgot to sign them.” She said she’d be happy to testify to that effect if need be:“Jake is a good guy; I’ve worked on his campaigns before and I thought I was helping him out.”
The Wolfe filing also takes issue with 40 pages’ worth of signatures signed by a third notary, who it says “is not a qualified Notary Public as her commission was void as of September 4, 2013.”
The complaint doesn’t specify the basis for that claim, and the stamp on the petitions themselves appears to be valid. But a state-managed online notary database does appear to indicate that the notary named in the complaint, Tammy T. Thompson of Homestead, was void as of that date.
Ms. Thompson declined comment Wednesday evening. But Mr. Wheatley seemed sanguine about the court challenges.
“We’re very confident that we’ll remain on the ballot,” he said. “The intent of the law is to ensure that the will of the people is being adhered to.”
Mr. Wheatley said the stamped-but-unsigned petitions merely reflect a misunderstanding on the part of the notaries, who didn’t see any place to actually sign the document, and so merely stamped it. “In their world, a stamp is as good as a signature.”
Election lawyers said that judges are typically forgiving of such errors, should there be testimony or other evidence explaining the mistake. “If a notary performed their job correctly, and merely forgot to sign, then it is amendable,” said Chuck Pascal, who frequently handles petition challenges.
“I think the fact that two notaries made the exact same mistake is what the red flag is here,” he surmised.
As for the claims regarding Ms. Thompson? “I have no idea what they are referring to,” said Mr. Wheatley. “We’ve used her before, and if her stamp isn’t good, I wouldn’t know. When you go to a service like a notary, you don’t know anything other than whether they have a stamp.”
Mr. Pascal said he was unfamiliar with the ‘void’ claim: “I don’t know what that is,” he said. “But if a person is not a notary, my I understanding is then the document isn’t notarized, so those petitions may go away.”
Ms. Wolfe must make good on all three of her claims, which will be argued before Commonwealth Court.
“We think we’ll be good in court, and that this is a waste of time,” said Mr. Wheatley, who noted that the signatures of voters themselves weren’t being challenged. “People in the 19th district want to hear ideas about what we plan to do to help them and their families. We encourage the folks challenging us to do so on the issues, rather than use external things.”
Ms. Wolfe seemed incredulous about that assertion. “He just ran Aerion Abney out of the race by challenging his petitions,” she said, referring to the withdrawal of a challenger earlier this week. (Mr. Abney said he was withdrawing out of respect to a Democratic Committee endorsement vote, but Mr. Wheatley was pursuing a challenge.) “He was willing to use externals to do that.”
Ms. Wolfe also said she had a hard time accepting claims that the errors were mere oversights. “An oversight is ‘I’m notarizing 50 pages, and 49 are done correctly.’ But we’re talking about 100 pages of problems.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.