On certain measures, Monroeville represents a solidly blue block of voters. In last year’s presidential election, the east Pittsburgh suburb voted for Hillary Clinton by a 52-44 percent margin over Donald Trump. Its mayor and seven ward leaders are all Democrats.
Since 2012, however, two Republicans and one Democrat have represented different sections of Monroeville in the U.S. House of Representatives.
During statewide voter redistricting in 2011, the Republican-controlled General Assembly chose a point just inside Monroeville’s northern boundary, where Center Road leaps over the Pennsylvania Turnpike, to demarcate the districts that U.S. Reps. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, and Keith Rothfus, R-Sewickley, serve.
As the Monroeville council member presiding over the ward where the three congressional districts converge, Ron Harvey bears the most responsibility for keeping the districts straight.
If a neighborhood in his ward needs federal assistance, Mr. Harvey consults his ward map to determine who represents the affected neighborhood in Congress. When he calls the representative’s office, Mr. Harvey checks whether he has reached the right place.
“They might tell me politely, ‘Mr. Harvey, you might want to call whoever,’ ” he said. “I wouldn’t want someone in my ward to call another councilman to get something done. ... As a politician, I get that.”
The complication creates no inconvenience for constituents, according to Mr. Harvey.
“It could be the biggest federal problem in the world, and they call me,” Mr. Harvey said. “They call their local guy.”
‘Absurd’ district lines?
While inconsistencies between congressional and municipal boundaries might have little impact at the local level, a lawsuit brought by the League of Women Voters of Pennsylvania cites congressional lines that deviate from county lines as evidence that lawmakers engaged in illegal partisan gerrymandering to draw the state’s congressional map.
The group filed the suit with individual voters from each of Pennsylvania’s 18 congressional districts in state court on June 15. It argues that Republican mapmakers used sophisticated computer programs and extensive voter data to draw “absurd” district boundaries that “pack” Democratic voters into five overwhelmingly Democratic districts or “crack” them among the remaining 13 districts, where Republicans constitute a large majority of voters.
“For those voters who are cracked, in effect their vote doesn’t really count because they’re never going to be able to elect a representative that’s in their party. In a place where they’re packed, their votes are basically wasted,” the Public Interest Law Center’s Mimi McKenzie said. Ms. McKenzie is representing the plaintiffs in Pennsylvania.
The League of Women Voters joins plaintiffs in Wisconsin and Maryland who claim that lawmakers have abused the redistricting process, which takes place every 10 years to account for changes in the size of a state’s population, to win more seats on Capitol Hill.
PG graphic: Slices of Monroeville
(Click image for larger version)
The Supreme Court, which has never struck down voting districts as partisan gerrymanders, decided in June to hear the Wisconsin case in its next term, which begins on Oct. 2.
Calling partisan gerrymandering “one of the greatest threats to American democracy today,” the League of Women Voters argues that the practice has allowed the GOP to retain 72 percent of Pennsylvania’s seats on Capitol Hill while winning only about half of the ballots cast statewide. The Associated Press estimates that Pennsylvania Republicans won three more congressional seats in the 2016 election than would be expected based on their overall vote share.
Voting rights activists point to the shape of Rothfus’ 12th Congressional District as a glaring instance of partisan gerrymandering.
Described as a barbell, District 12 links all of Beaver County along the Ohio-Pennsylvania border with the bulk of Cambria and Somerset counties around Johnstown. In between, it squeezes through the northern portions of Allegheny and Westmoreland counties, scooping up Monroeville’s northwestern quarter along the way.
“You see these odd shapes, and you have to ask yourself, ‘Why?’ ” Ms. McKenzie said. “The reality is that it doesn’t make much sense unless you’re gerrymandering based on voters’ partisan affiliations and voting records.”
The state has until Aug. 14 to reply to the suit. In the meantime, Republicans contend that congressional districts diverge from county and even municipal boundaries to ensure equal population sizes between districts.
“With congressional districts, the one-person one-vote principle is literal,” said Steve Miskin, press secretary for Pennsylvania’s Republican House Speaker, Mike Turzai, R-Marshall. Mr. Turzai was named, along with Gov. Tom Wolf and other state officials, as a defendant in the suit.
Mr. Miskin cited a federal court ruling that struck down Pennsylvania’s congressional map in 2002 to underscore his point. In that map, the state’s most populous district contained 19 more voters than its least populous district.
As Monroeville’s lone Democratic congressman in Washington, Mr. Doyle acknowledged that lawmakers sometimes must divide municipalities around populous cities such as Pittsburgh and Philadelphia to achieve population equality. But he added, “I don’t believe any community should be split. … I really think the redistricting law is clear that every effort should be made not to have that.”
The federal Voting Rights Act of 1965 prohibits states from diluting the voting strength of racial minorities by cracking blocks of minority voters between districts. The Supreme Court, moreover, has suggested that it could potentially allow states that consistently draw congressional districts to align with municipal boundaries to have populations of slightly different sizes.
Pennsylvania’s congressional map splits 58 of the state’s 2,561 municipalities between more than one district. Monroeville’s three-way split between the 12th, 14th and 18th Congressional districts stands out because only three other municipalities in Pennsylvania are divided more than two ways. Two of those municipalities — Caln Township and Spring Township — fall partly within southeastern Pennsylvania’s 7th Congressional District.
In their lawsuit, voting rights activists liken the 7th District to “Goofy Kicking Donald Duck” and report that at some points the district is as narrow as a restaurant site and an endoscopy center.
According to the suit, Republicans drew the district, which winds through five counties, to pack reliably Democratic voters in and around Philadelphia, a bastion of Democratic support.
Proposal for reform
State Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, has proposed a bill that would prohibit congressional districts from splitting counties or municipalities where possible. Though he noted that a municipality with more than one U.S. representative arguably could wield disproportionate influence, he said the Pennsylvania Constitution bars legislative districts from dividing counties and municipalities at the state level unless absolutely necessary.
“We have to follow the [state] constitution,” Mr. Costa said. “Legislative and congressional lines are both derived from the state constitution.”
A more significant reform in his bill, he added, would create a bipartisan commission of independent citizens to draw congressional lines — a potential remedy for the conflicts of interest that underlie the current redistricting process, according to Mr. Costa.
The existing restrictions on state-level redistricting, Mr. Costa observed, have done little to prevent partisan gerrymandering.
An-Li Herring: aherring@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.