Pennsylvania’s U.S. Senate candidates have staked out opposite positions on the federal consumer protection agency that investigated a banking scandal leading to 5,000 firings at Wells Fargo last week.
In a conference call with reporters today, Democratic challenger Katie McGinty lauded the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau for uncovering the wrongdoing, and noted it’s the same agency Republican incumbent Pat Toomey has threatened to dismantle.
“Is he standing for innocent consumers? Is he standing for his own constituents?” Ms. McGinty asked on the call. “He’s not. He’s working overtime to kneecap the organization that has been standing up for innocent people.”
Last year, Mr. Toomey and Sen. David Perdue, R-Ga., sponsored legislation changing the way the agency is funded. Their amendment would have put the bureau under direct control of Congress rather than under the Federal Reserve. Congressional Democrats said the change would allow the Republican-controlled Congress to cut funding in order to keep the agency from cracking down on the lenders who support their campaigns.
Mr. Toomey also has proposed replacing the agency’s director with a bipartisan board and restricting it from investigating institutions with less than $50 billion worth of assets. The current threshold is $10 billion.
The bureau was created in 2010 over objections from Republicans including Mr. Toomey, who blocked confirmation of Richard Cordray as its first director. It’s aim is to protect consumers from unscrupulous banking practices.
In his own press call with reporters today, Mr. Toomey called the agency “an ill-conceived and badly governed entity that’s not accountable to anyone.” He said it’s unlike other agencies because it isn’t controlled by a board or commission but by “one man who is in complete control and gets to dictate whatever policy he wants.”
A federal judge already has ruled that Mr. Cordray overstepped his bounds when he launched an investigation into accreditation processes of for-profit colleges.
Mr. Toomey said the agency is unnecessary because fraud already is a crime and agencies are capable of prosecuting it. And, if the bureau were abolished other agencies – such as the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. and the Securities and Exchange Commission would regain investigative authority they had ceded.
Supporters of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau say it serves an important funcation and has been doing it well.
“Without the CFPB, Wells Fargo may never have gotten caught, and there would be no cop on the beat for other banks that try to swindle hardworking families,” said Joe Valenti, director of consumer finance at the Center for American Progress Action Fund, who joined Ms. McGinty on her press call. “The Wells Fargo scandal reminds us that the CFPB works, and it deserves our support.”
Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: 703-996-9292, tmauriello@post-gazette.com or @pgPoliTweets.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.