U.S.-based chipmakers Nvidia and AMD have agreed to pay the United States 15% of their revenue from sales of artificial intelligence chips in China, a highly unusual arrangement that some experts warn may be unconstitutional.

Under the financial agreement, the companies will give the U.S. government a portion of their sales as a prerequisite to obtaining export licenses for China, according to three people familiar with the matter who spoke on the condition of anonymity as they were not authorized to discuss the matter in public.

Nvidia issued a statement after The Financial Times first reported the arrangement Sunday.

“We follow rules the U.S. government sets for our participation in worldwide markets. While we haven’t shipped H20 to China for months, we hope export control rules will let America compete in China and worldwide,” said a spokesperson for Nvidia, referring to the company’s sought-after H20 AI chips.

Advertise with us

“America cannot repeat 5G and lose telecommunication leadership. America’s AI tech stack can be the world’s standard if we race,” the statement added.

In April, the Trump administration halted H20 chip sales to China, citing security risks, but announced a reversal of the decision in July shortly ahead of another round of trade talks with Beijing. The H20 had been Nvidia’s last AI chip allowed to be sold to China after the Biden administration clamped down on such sales starting in 2022.

Even without the revenue-sharing provision, President Donald Trump’s decision to ease the chip-sale restrictions on Nvidia was controversial, with officials from both parties expressing concern that the flip-flopping policy would erode international trust in U.S. export controls.

The latest deal quickly drew criticism from some scholars who said it may violate the Constitution’s prohibition on taxes on exports.

“In addition to the policy problems with just charging Nvidia and AMD a 15% share of revenues to sell advanced chips in China, the U.S. Constitution flatly forbids export taxes,” Peter Harrell, the White House senior director for international economics under the Biden administration, said in a Sunday post on social media.

Advertise with us

Christopher Padilla, a top export control official in the George W. Bush administration who is now a senior adviser with the Brunswick Group consulting firm, echoed those fears, describing the deal as “unprecedented and dangerous.”

“Export controls are in place to protect national security, not raise revenue for the government,” Padilla said. “This arrangement seems like bribery or blackmail, or both.’’

The U.S. government has traditionally maintained that its export controls are based on national security imperatives, not economic considerations.

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang met with Trump on Wednesday, in his latest lobbying trip to the White House. The executive, whom Trump has praised as “amazing,” has been a frequent visitor this year.

After the latest meeting, in which the 15% arrangement was struck, the president called Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and told him to issue the licenses, according to a person familiar with the matter who spoke on the condition of anonymity due to the matter’s sensitivity.

Advertise with us

AMD and the White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment, and nor did China’s commerce or foreign ministries.

Nvidia, the world’s most valuable public company, has emerged as a focus of the U.S.-China technological rivalry, with both nations dependent on its AI chips to run supercomputers.