Joseph Bartolacci has spent nearly two decades as CEO of Matthews International Corp. But in two weeks, his fate — and the future of the North Shore-based company — will be in the hands of shareholders.
Barington Capital, an activist hedge fund with a reputation for shaking up companies, has launched an all-out campaign to oust Mr. Bartolacci and replace three board members with its own handpicked candidates.
Matthews, which has more than 11,000 employees worldwide, including about 850 in southwest Pennsylvania, has traditionally manufactured products for the funeral industry, such as caskets and cremation equipment. But it also has diversified into industrial and other applications, such as warehouse automation, label printing and components for lithium batteries.
The battle with Barington has been brewing for months, but now it is headed for a showdown at Matthews’ annual shareholders meeting scheduled for Feb. 20, after the top three advisory services recently threw their weight behind Barington’s slate of directors.
Advisory firms Glass Lewis & Co, Egan-Jones Proxy Services and ISS submitted recommendations urging investors to back the hedge fund’s vision for a new era at Matthews International.
“The primary goal of the CEO and board of directors is to maximize shareholder value, and since the beginning of Mr. Bartolacci’s tenure, and especially the past five years, this has not been true,” wrote Egan-Jones.
Read More
Matthews countered by noting that one of its top five shareholders — Gamco Asset Management with an approximate 4.38% stake — is publicly supporting Matthews’ director nominees.
Meanwhile, Matthews on Friday, mailed a letter to company shareholders urging them to vote in favor of Matthews’ three director nominees at its upcoming annual meeting.
“Under the board and CEO Joe Bartolacci’s leadership, Matthews has developed into a strong, diversified and resilient provider of innovative solutions for customers around the globe,” said the letter Matthews sent to shareholders.
Matthews told its shareholders that its board is “regularly refreshed, exceptionally qualified, highly engaged and best positioned to oversee the company and the continued execution of its strategy and strategic review process.
“In contrast, none of the Barington nominees have a background or significant experience in the company’s businesses,” the letter from Matthews said.
In two weeks, all eyes will be on Matthews’ shareholders meeting.
In addition to three board nominees supported by Matthews — Terry L. Dunlap, Alvaro Garcia-Tunon and J. Michael Nauman — shareholders will see three other nominees listed on the proxy card nominated by Barington Capital — Ana B. Amicarella, Chan W. Galbato and James Mitarotonda.
Shareholders have until Feb. 20 to cast votes in the fiercely contest boardroom fight.
Barington owns approximately 2.1% of the outstanding shares of Matthews, which has a market capitalization of $822 million. Barington has said it believes Matthews shareholders deserve to know the facts about Matthews’ performance as well as the rationale for Barington’s campaign for change.
Simply put, the company has failed to take any action over the last 18 years to simplify its portfolio, conduct a strategic review, reduce costs or indebtedness or address board independence,” said James Mitarotonda, chairman and CEO of Barington Capital.
“We find it deeply troubling that the company would seek to obfuscate these facts rather than take accountability,” he said.
“Only after Barington notified Matthews of its intention to launch a proxy contest did the company seemingly begin to take action, which we believe is a desperate attempt to maintain the status quo and further entrench the board.”
Matthews disputed all of those points.
“I ask you to realize that actions speak louder than words,” Mr. Bartolacci urged during an earnings call with investors last week.
He highlighted two company developments announced in the past month that “have been in the works for several years, but due to confidentiality requirements, we have been unable to disclose. Both transactions required patience and a clear understanding by the board of directors of the value creation opportunity to be achieved upon success.”
One was the plan to sell its interest in brand and content production agency SGK Brand Solutions, an Illinois-based business it bought 10 years ago for $600 million. In the announced sale, Matthews will receive $350 million upfront, which includes $250 million cash and $50 million of preferred equity and a 40% common equity stake in the new entity created from the sale called SGS & Co.
The second, Matthews said, will pave the way for its expansion in the battery market after a favorable decision in Matthews’ yearslong legal battle with its customer Tesla. The decision, made by an arbitrator earlier this week, confirmed that Matthews had been developing advanced Dry Battery Electrode (DBE) technology long before working with Tesla, which alleged that Matthews stole Tesla’s trade secrets. The court ruling has cleared the way for the North Shore company to sell its battery technology to companies besides Tesla.
“The management and the board of directors had the will to initiate an action against one of the largest companies in the world to protect our rights to our highly valuable and proprietary DBE technology,” Mr. Bartolacci said during the earnings call.
This is in contrast to Barington’s nominees, he said, who would “bring to the board a total lack of understanding about our business, no relevant skills, and track records of poor oversight. As a consultant to the company, James Mitarotonda added no value, showed up to most meetings unprepared and made suggestions that either did not make sense or were already being executed.”
The announcements have failed to mollify Barington.
Barington first took a position in Matthews in June 2022. The hedge fund typically targets companies in the industrial and retail sectors. In February 2024, it launched a public campaign for toymaker Mattel. In December, Barington announced it is seeking board seats, spinoffs and share repurchases at Macys.
This story was updated at 2:30 p.m. on Feb. 11 to include the support of one of Matthews’s shareholders.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.