Twitter filed suit Tuesday against Elon Musk to force the billionaire to make good on his promise to purchase the company, issuing the first legal volley in what is expected to be one of most high-profile business trials in recent history.
For months Mr. Musk has publicly threatened to walk away from the sale of the influential social network, efforts that culminated last week in a Securities and Exchange Commission filing claiming he was “terminating” the agreement because Twitter hadn’t given him enough information about spam and bots on its service.
Now a judge in a specialized business court in Delaware must determine whether the world’s richest man can exit the $44 billion deal, despite a contract binding him to complete the acquisition barring a major change to the company’s business.
Having mounted a public spectacle to put Twitter in play, and having proposed and then signed a seller-friendly merger agreement, Mr. Musk apparently believes that he — unlike every other party subject to Delaware contract law — is free to change his mind, trash the company, disrupt its operations, destroy stockholder value, and walk away,” the lawsuit said. “Twitter brings this action to enjoin Musk from further breaches, to compel Musk to fulfill his legal obligations, and to compel consummation of the merger upon satisfaction of the few outstanding conditions.”
Experts said they anticipated months of agonizing legal drama to play out in the Delaware Court of Chancery, a tiny, clubby court that has decided the outcomes of some of the biggest business squabbles in the U.S. The court has just seven judges — one chancellor and six vice chancellors — who have enormous discretion to force companies to take specific actions.
The process will likely submit Twitter to a grueling level of public scrutiny, forcing the platform to open up its books and expose internal deliberations in ways that might further damage its stock price and reputation, already-battered from the market downturn and months of sparring with Mr. Musk.
Read More
The lawsuit is the latest in a tumultuous saga that began in April, when Twitter’s board accepted the billionaire’s surprise offer to purchase the long-struggling social media service.
Soon after, Mr. Musk began to throw wrenches in the deal, using his popular Twitter account to call out individual company executives and to highlight what he indicated were misleading estimates of spam and fake accounts on the platform. In May, Mr. Musk tweeted that the deal was “on hold” over the bot problem.
The fight escalated last Friday, when Mr. Musk’s legal team said he was pulling out of the agreement in its letter to the SEC. Twitter executives and board members, who had long anticipated this sort of move from Mr. Musk, said they were prepared to take him to court to force him to follow through with the contract.
“We are confident we will prevail in the Delaware Court of Chancery,” Twitter board chair Bret Taylor tweeted last week.
Twitter views its chances in the court system as favorable because Mr. Musk had not pressed the platform on the bot issue before signing the contract — though the company had offered public quarterly estimates of spam and fake accounts for years. Twitter estimates that spam and bot accounts comprise fewer than 5% of the accounts on its service of 229 million daily users, but some outside researchers have projected that the number could be far higher. But Twitter doesn’t share comprehensive usage data with researchers, preventing significant external evaluation of the issue.
Twitter’s leadership believes that sharing such extensive information would violate user privacy and could run afoul of data privacy laws, according to people familiar with internal discussions, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe them.
Experts on Delaware’s Chancery Court system say the rigid contract, combined with the fact that Mr. Musk failed to amend it, will make it difficult for the billionaire to win in court.
“From the outside, it seems like Musk has an uphill climb,” said Jeremy Eicher, an attorney with over a decade of experience representing clients with cases in the Delaware Chancery Court. “He’s a sophisticated buyer with a highly competent legal team that could have asked about these issues before. It’s not just a deal between two guys.”
But Mr. Eicher noted that in recent years, Chancery Court decisions have become fairly unpredictable and that the outcomes are frequently dictated by whims of any particular judge, who is known as a chancellor or a vice chancellor.
And Mr. Musk’s argument, that he and his team relied on and trusted Twitter’s bot estimates, and only found out later that those estimates might not be accurate, could be viewed as reasonable by a judge.
Attorneys involved in the case, as well as experts, expect that Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick, head of the Chancery Court and the highest-ranking of the seven judges in the system, will take the case herself. Last year Ms. McCormick forced private equity firm Kohlberg & Co. to go through with a deal to buy cake-decorating supply company DecoPac after the firm tried to get out of the deal.
But the court has also allowed companies to get out of deals in cases where the judge determined that business being acquired was not forthright. In one notable case in 2018, a Chancery Court judge allowed medical care company, Fresenius, to terminate its planned purchase of generic pharmaceutical company, Akorn, after finding that Akorn had not disclosed major “data integrity” issues to the acquirer.
Experts said they expected the case to last four to six months, a far speedier timeline than other types of court cases and one reason that businesses prefer to headquarter in Delaware.
Both Twitter and Mr. Musk have hired law firms with close ties to the Chancery Court, a refection of the tightly knit system. Last week Twitter hired Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz. Leo Strine Jr., former Chief Justice of the Delaware Supreme Court and Chancellor of the Chancery Court, is corporate counsel at Wachtell. And a current Vice Chancellor of the Chancery Court, Lori Will, hails from Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP, a firm which is representing Mr. Musk. Ms. Will also formerly clerked for Mr. Strine.
There’s a multitude of ways the disagreement could be resolved, legal experts say, though most doubt that Mr. Musk will be able to walk away without forfeiting some sort of payment.
“If I had to call it today, Twitter’s got the better of the argument,” said Lawrence Hamermesh, executive director, Institute for Law and Economics, University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School. “What remedy the court will give is harder to forecast.”
The court could order that Mr. Musk pay the $1 billion breakup fee specified in the contract, which may not satisfy Twitter, which has faced a sinking stock and an increasingly beleaguered workforce as the deal created uncertainty around the future of the brand.
The court could also order Mr. Musk to go through with the $44 billion deal, a decision that would be “momentous,” said Anthony Casey, a professor of law and economics at the University of Chicago Law School.
But it’s not unheard of. In a 2001 decision, the court ruled Tyson Foods needed to complete its acquisition of IBP, Inc. after the foods giant tried to call it off.
Forcing Mr. Musk to go through with the deal could lead to a court appeal and an uneasy tension between a reluctant owner and his new team. Already many Twitter employees have protested his ownership.
Some legal experts think the most likely outcome is for the two sides to reach some sort of settlement agreement, either one that allows Mr. Musk to buy Twitter for a lower price or that requires him to pay a higher breakup fee to Twitter. But Mr. Musk is the wild card.
“I think Musk is a little less predictable than most litigants,” Mr. Casey said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.