On a snowy afternoon in January, workers pushed a special recipe of coal into an oven at the precise temperature of 2,450 degrees Fahrenheit.
After 17 hours of baking, the coal would soften, liquefy and then solidify into hard, porous lumps of concentrated carbon. Cooled with water, the finished product — coke — would be shipped to blast furnaces and combined with limestone and iron ore to produce steel used in the automotive, construction, packaging, and oil and gas industries.
The 45-acre plant in Monessen -— equipped with 56 ovens that can each hold 12.5 tons of coke — is essentially a middleman carrying out the work necessary to keep steel mills going.

This plant has seen a revolving door of owners — Wheeling-Pittsburgh Steel, Sharon Steel, Koppers among them — as the industry has struggled.
It also has been cited for environmental violations and workplace hazards that come with baking coal and removing impurities like coal tar, sulfur, liquid ammonium sulfate and oil.
But the Monessen plant appears to have a future.
As the U.S. steel industry makes a rebound, ArcelorMittal, the largest steel company in the world, recently invested $2 million in upgrades to keep the nearly 80-year-old plant operational.
In doing so, the Luxembourg-based company pledged to keep the ovens hot in this Mon Valley city of about 7,000, whose identity is rooted in coal and steel.
Founded in 1898, Monessen’s name combined the first syllable of “Monongahela” with Essen, a German industrial town that for decades had one of the largest coke plants in Europe. After Essen’s coke plant closed in 1993, it was turned into a public museum and a popular tourist attraction.

Randy Shelton, the plant manager, sees no public museum in Monessen’s future.
“As long as there are blast furnaces, there will be a need for coke,” he said.
Mr. Shelton, who grew up in nearby Charleroi, began his career in the coke industry in 1974. He worked in Clairton and Monessen, and at plants in Indiana and Ohio, before returning to Monessen in 2015.
ArcelorMittal acquired the Monessen plant for $160 million from Koppers in 2008, just as the global financial crisis hit commodity markets. The company idled the plant for more than four years.
Then market conditions improved and the plant ramped up in 2014.
Mr. Shelton estimated about half of the plant’s original workers signed on to come back to work.
The plant now employs 180 people — 155 of them represented by United Steelworkers Local 3403 and another 25 working in management. (The USW declined to discuss jobs at the plant, citing upcoming contract negotiations with ArcelorMittal.)
“I’m a mid-Mon Valley guy. I’m invested in the mid-Mon Valley guy,” Mr. Shelton said. “I plan on being here in this plant for 10 years as long as I’m still having fun. And I have fun every day.”
Air quality concerns
Yet these are tough days for the coke-making business around Pittsburgh.
In December 2015, Detroit-based DTE Energy shut down its Shenango Coke Works on Neville Island — a surprise to 173 union workers in the midst of negotiating a new contract.
U.S. Steel’s Clairton Coke Works, about 10 miles down the Monongahela River from Monessen, has been a near-constant source of air-quality complaints.
Most recently, a mechanical fire on Dec. 24 tore through the Clairton plant’s coke gas processing system and caused extensive damage to a building the size of a football field. It triggered an air-quality warning for 22 Mon Valley communities.
Sulfur dioxide from the plant spiked above the federal emissions standard six times. That caused the Allegheny County Health Department to issue an advisory earlier this month, urging residents with pre-existing respiratory and heart conditions, children and the elderly to limit outdoor activity.

U.S. Steel has been fined repeatedly by the county health department, including $1 million in June 2018, which the Pittsburgh steelmaker is appealing.
Air quality has also been a concern surrounding the Monessen plant.
In late 2014, almost immediately after the ovens were filled with coal once again, residents in Monessen and six neighboring communities flooded the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection with complaints about odors, smoke, soot and debris causing headaches and flaring up asthma. The DEP found releases of hydrogen sulfide and sulfur dioxide that exceeded legal limits.
Last year, ArcelorMittal agreed to settle those complaints by paying $1.5 million in civil penalties and another $300,000 to convert municipal vehicles to electric. It pledged to spend an additional $2 million on upgrades to pollution control systems.
Since the agreement, the plant has not released emissions that would trigger a follow-up penalty and complaints dropped precipitously, said Josh Kratka, senior attorney for the National Environmental Law Center, a Boston-based nonprofit law firm that brought the suit on behalf of PennEnvironment.
Even with emissions falling below legal limits, Mr. Kratka added, “This is still a coke pant located at the bottom of a valley. It’s still gonna smell. It’s still gonna make soot. Coke-making is a dirty process.”
It can also be a dangerous process.
Separately, the company also agreed last year to pay $18,000 in the death of a worker crushed between a coal chute and a rail car. Occupational Safety and Health Administration investigators noted he was working a second consecutive shift and trying to clear a coal jam in the chute when the incident occurred. OSHA found a lack of proper fall protection and a failure to establish procedures that prevented workers from being crushed or shocked when clearing coal jams.

The plant had a total of 43 cases of work-related injuries or illnesses from 2014 to 2016, the company reported to the agency, though the number of cases declined each year.
An ArcelorMittal spokeswoman said the company investigated the accident and put in place “proactive measures whenever and wherever possible to prevent recurrence.”
Solutions for the future
ArcelorMittal has been sharing progress with the environmental upgrades over the last year. It’s held two public meetings in Monessen to answer questions — meetings required by last year’s settlement.
Among the fixes are new pollution control equipment, an oven maintenance plan and a system that measures hydrogen sulfide every five minutes.
Other solutions for pollution issues are unclear. The plant didn’t have an alternative method for removing sulfur from used coke oven gas when its primary desulfurization plant is down for maintenance — which meant that uncleaned gas has been released for days each year.
An alternative scrubber system successfully removed the sulfur during an eight-day trial run in July, but there were drawbacks: The process generated 60,000 gallons of waste byproduct that may be difficult to recycle, Mr. Shelton said.
“OK, we’ve cleaned the air, but it created this other problem,” he said. The company will know for sure if it’s a permanent fix by April.
Monessen Mayor Matt Shorraw toured the plant last year to hear about the upgrades. “I was impressed with their processes and the upgrades,” he said.
He sees more work to be done.

“I do feel they can still do better with pollution controls and upgrades. I know that residents and visitors have mentioned there is still a smell of sulfur in the air, as recent as last month. This is especially true late at night and when it is humid.”
And, while the coke operation is a significant employer, Mr. Shorraw sees the future of Monessen in manufacturing that could support high-tech industries in Pittsburgh.
“I think that we can still play a vital role,” he said. There are lots of reasons that businesses would want to come here to the Mon Valley, the mayor said.
“We have river, rail, highway, and located near five county seats,” he pointed out. “I would also welcome facilities to house co-working spaces, small business start-up spaces, since the cost of living is much lower.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.