Etsy, an online marketplace where small-scale craftspeople and collectors can sell handmade and vintage items, raised the fees it imposes on transactions last month for the first time in its 13-year history.
The increase brings the fee Etsy imposes on every transaction from 3.5 percent up to 5 percent, and also extracts a 5 percent fee on shipping costs.
The website, which started in 2005, allows anyone with access to a computer and a knack for crafting to market and sell their products, now hosts 2 million sellers and almost 35 million shoppers.
In recent months, the company has made a shift away from its homespun, DIY image to that of an online retail giant focused on customer service. Though some have applauded Etsy’s efforts to market the site, the recent fare increase on transactions has more than a few of its millions of online sellers grumbling even as they resolve to remain on the website.
Several Pittsburgh-based sellers said they may have to increase prices as a result of the fees. Still, Etsy’s large customer base and low overhead for sellers means the website still has a powerful draw.
Although the fee change may not seem significant — the company says it is just a matter of cents — shop owner Sarah Korhnak said sellers should do the math to figure out if the fee increase will affect their bottom line.
“That’s a big difference,” she said. “That can really make the difference between whether you think you’re making a profit or whether you make a profit at all.”
Ms. Korhnak, who also works as a bookkeeper for other Etsy shop owners, owns an online shop called The Amateur Naturalist, where she sells make-your-own terrarium kits, complete with real, dried butterflies, that run between $12 and $24. She also sells as well as smaller items, like vintage nature images on pillowcases and tote bags.
The Amateur Naturalist is a smaller shop, with between $9,000 and $10,000 in sales a year as Ms. Korhnak balances it with her bookkeeping work. The Pleasant Hills resident said she hasn’t noticed an impact on her bottom line yet.
Ms. Korhnak’s sentiment was echoed by several other Pittsburgh-based sellers, who said they were still unsure of the impact that the fees, which went into effect last month, would have on their business.
But even if their profit margin may get thinner, many said they have little choice but to stay on the site.
“If Etsy wants to take 4 or 5 percent, whatever it ends up being, even up to 10, 15, or 20, it’s still way better than dealing with galleries,” said Blake Anthony, the owner of Pittsburgh Pottery. Galleries can sometimes take as much as 50 percent of the profit from a sale, Mr. Anthony said, making Etsy a much more profitable option.
Mr. Anthony, who has a shop on Etsy and also operates out of a Carnegie storefront, said Etsy is still a strong sales channel for his business, accounting for about $10,000 a year in sales.
Pittsburgh Pottery, true to its name, makes Pittsburgh-themed mugs, shot glasses, magnets and ornaments. A yellow mug proclaiming Pittsburgh as the “City of Champyinz” runs for $25, while magnets illustrated with anything from one of Pittsburgh’s iconic bridges to the phrase “Jeet Yet?” are $8. About half of his orders are local, he said, while the other half go out-of-state, and he’s even shipped as far as Alaska.
One of Mr. Anthony’s mugs, which has “It’s a Burgh Thing” written over an illustration of the city’s skyline is $25 with a shipping fee of about $8. Under the old transaction fees, Etsy would take about 88 cents on that transaction. Under the new fee, Etsy’s share would be $1.65.
Mr. Anthony said he usually makes around $10,000 a year off sales on the site, and he certainly isn’t the only shop owner building a business around Pittsburgh pride. Type “Pittsburgh” into the site’s search bar and Etsy will bring up results for canvas prints of the city’s iconic bridges, framed historical maps of the area and a plethora of Steelers- and Penguins-themed memorabilia.
The site’s real value is that it comes with its own customer base, or as Mr. Blake said, people who are “kind of addicted to Etsy.” It means that craftspeople can have a level of exposure when they first start that would be nearly impossible if they were selling on their own.
Since the website’s inception over a decade ago, Etsy has been joined by other online tools: Artisans now sell items over their Facebook and Instagram pages or on their own websites. Some have migrated to Amazon Handmade, a part of the company’s website that features homemade items. Amazon Handmade has a 15 percent fee on its sales, and is currently waiving its professional account monthly fee.
Several shop owners said that without Etsy, they would never have been able to get off the ground. Etsy doesn’t charge a monthly fee for sellers to stay on the site, but does require them to pay 20 cents to list an item for sale.
And in the absence of a platform as popular and with lower transaction fees, they’re sticking with Etsy.
Executives at the company have said they will focus more on marketing the site, something Allison Glancey, who runs an Etsy shop selling silk screen prints, said she appreciates. Along with the fee increases, the company also rolled out a tiered system of packages that shop owners could subscribe to in order to gain access to marketing tools and more options to customize their shop page.
The subscription packages and fee increases are part of a bit of a rebranding moment for the company — the blog post announcing them is titled “Growing alongside our sellers.” And in the past several quarters, the company’s growth has skyrockted. In the first quarter of 2018, Etsy reported a total revenue of $120.9 million, which was up 24.8 percent from the first quarter of 2017.
For Ms. Glancey, who started selling on Etsy when the site was new, watching it grow from a small, DIY site to the behemoth it is now has been rewarding.
“I really admire Etsy. They’ve 100 percent helped me grow my business,” said Ms. Glancey.
Still, she said the recent fee increases give her pause.
“There’s definitely a lot of yelling and chaos right now among sellers, but I really just try to take a beat,” she said. “It doesn’t matter how much noise I make; this is happening.”
Nora Shelly, 412-263-1936 or nshelly@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.